NASDAQ:PBPB Potbelly Q3 2023 Earnings Report $8.10 +0.04 (+0.50%) As of 04/17/2025 03:59 PM Eastern Earnings HistoryForecast A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S EPS ResultsActual EPS$0.04Consensus EPS $0.02Beat/MissBeat by +$0.02One Year Ago EPSN/AA.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S Revenue ResultsActual Revenue$120.77 millionExpected Revenue$123.40 millionBeat/MissMissed by -$2.63 millionYoY Revenue GrowthN/AA.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S Announcement DetailsQuarterQ3 2023Date11/1/2023TimeN/AConference Call DateWednesday, November 1, 2023Conference Call Time5:00PM ETUpcoming EarningsA.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S' next earnings date is estimated for Thursday, May 1, 2025, based on past reporting schedules. Conference Call ResourcesConference Call AudioConference Call TranscriptSlide DeckPress Release (8-K)Quarterly Report (10-Q)Earnings HistoryCompany ProfileSlide DeckFull Screen Slide DeckPowered by A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S Q3 2023 Earnings Call TranscriptProvided by QuartrNovember 1, 2023 ShareLink copied to clipboard.There are 8 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Afternoon, everyone, and welcome to Potbelly Corporation's Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. Today's call is being recorded. At this time, all participants have been placed in a listen only mode and the lines will be open for your questions following the prepared remarks. On today's call, we have Bob Wright, President and Chief Executive Officer Steve Cyrillis, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer and Adia Dickson, Chief Legal Officer and Secretary of Potbelly Corporation. At this time, I'll turn the call over to Adia Dixon. Operator00:00:36Please go ahead. Speaker 100:00:39Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to our Q3 2023 earnings call. By now, everyone should have access to our earnings release and accompanying investor presentation. If not, they can be found on the Investor Relations section of our website. Before we begin our formal remarks, I need to remind everyone, certain comments made on this call will contain forward looking statements regarding future events or the future financial performance of the company. Any such statements, including our outlook for 2023 or any other future periods, should be considered forward looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Speaker 100:01:20These forward looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, nor should they be relied upon as representing management's views as of any subsequent date. Forward looking statements involve significant risks and uncertainties, and events or results could differ materially from those presented due to a number of risks and uncertainties. Additional detailed information concerning these risks Regarding our business and the factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from the forward looking statements and other information that will be given today and can be found in our Form 10 ks under the headings Risk Factors and MD and A and in our subsequent filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available at sec.gov. During the call, there will also be a discussion of some items that do not conform to U. S. Speaker 100:02:08Generally Accepted Accounting Principles for GAAP. Reconciliations of these non GAAP measures to their most directly comparable GAAP measures are included in the appendix to the press release an investor presentation issued this afternoon, both of which are available in the Investors tab of our website. With that out of the way, I would like to turn the call over to Potbelly's President and CEO, Bob Wright. Speaker 200:02:33Thank you, Adia, and good afternoon and thank you for joining our call today. We delivered strong Q3 results demonstrated by solid top line improvement And 8% same store sales growth. Notably, our traffic growth remained a strong contributor as we continue to take traffic Share from the fast casual category each week through the quarter. We also grew shop level margins through continued leverage across food and labor costs, resulting in a 400 basis point improvement year over year. I'm proud to say that these results were driven by the cumulative effect Our disciplined strategy and execution over the past many quarters, driving our confidence in the sustainability of the results we've achieved thus far. Speaker 200:03:15We remain focused on achieving the long term growth potential of this amazing brand. As we look forward to the end of the year and into 2024, We will continue to execute against our 5 pillar strategic plan to achieve traffic driven profitability and unit growth. This includes craveable quality food at a great value, people creating good vibes, customer experiences that drive traffic growth, Digitally driven awareness and connection and franchise focused development. With that, let me update you on our ongoing initiatives that support these Starting with the Potbelly digital experience. We're pleased with another quarter of outstanding performance in our digital business, driven by meaningful progress Our Perks loyalty program. Speaker 200:04:00All in all, our digital business represented approximately 37% of our total shop sales during the quarter, An increase of approximately 150 basis points relative to the same period last year. Importantly, we also continue to see a shift in our digital business away from 3rd party channels and towards Potbelly owned app, web and Perks originated orders. We are committed to serving our customers with the occasions that best meet their needs each time they visit Potbelly, including Our unique in shop fast casual dining experience and through the variety of order occasions delivered by the Potbelly digital experience. During the quarter, we were thrilled to see growth in both verticals. Turning to our Potbelly Digital Kitchen, the rollout of PDK to our existing shops is Progressing as planned and we will continue the deployment of PDK across our system of existing shops as a standard in every new franchise location. Speaker 200:04:59More importantly is the benefit of PDK to our operations, which are clearly demonstrated not only by the ongoing growth of our digital business and our ability to handle the incremental throughput, particularly during peak periods, but also operating efficiency and improvements in the customer experience From orders ready on time to accuracy of food and quality scores. Importantly, we continue to leverage the Throughput learnings from PDK and shops yet to be rolled out in our ongoing effort to drive traffic. Our traffic driven foundation to sales growth During the quarter, we introduced our latest underground menu item with the Lucky 7 sandwich, uniting all 7 meats from 2 of our most popular Overall, our underground menu introductions available only on the Potbelly app Continue to be among the most searched menu items in our digital channels. As we look ahead, we will continue to focus on Food and marketing innovation to further drive growth of our Perks loyalty program and digital channels. Lastly, let me share some exciting updates to our Franchise Growth Acceleration Initiative or FGA. Speaker 200:06:18As we mentioned on our last call, during the quarter, we 27 Unit Deal in Maryland through a partnership with our company founder, Bryant Kyle. During and subsequent to the end of We signed multiple additional new development agreements, including a 40 unit deal that is comprised of 4 refranchised shops and a commitment to develop 36 new shops in both Ohio and Florida. Our shop development commitments now total 150 shops to date. I'm proud of what our franchising team has accomplished in such a short period of time. We remain focused on achieving our 10% unit growth in 2024. Speaker 200:06:55We continue to have a highly active and fluid pipeline of qualified Potbelly franchise candidates. And when combined with our unique brand and Proven business fundamentals, we believe we have the foundation and the right team in place to drive long term growth. Looking forward, we will continue to emphasize our Franchise focus and build the organization's capability to support our franchise growth as we head towards 2,000 units in the U. S. We look forward to sharing additional updates on our next calls as more SDAA's or SHOP Development Area Agreements are finalized. Speaker 200:07:30Finally, let me reiterate how proud I am of our Potbelly team. Their hard work and commitment to our unique brand have resulted in a strong third quarter And they do so by carrying out our mission to delight customers with great food and good vibes, creating a distinct and differentiated fast casual experience for each of our customers from their first moment to their last bite. With that, I will now turn the call over to Steve to detail our financial performance for the Q3. Speaker 300:08:01Thank you, Bob. Good afternoon, everyone. Revenues in the 3rd quarter increased approximately 3% to $120,800,000 driven by same store sales growth of 8%, resulting in average weekly sales of approximately $25,190 partially offset by the short term revenue impact of our recent refranchising transaction. System wide sales of $138,200,000 Grew by approximately 7%. Traffic continues to be a strong contributor to same store sales growth Additionally, we implemented modest price increases to mitigate increases in input costs and will continue to do so as necessary, although Q3 saw appreciable inflation deceleration. Speaker 300:08:55Our digital business continues to grow and currently represents approximately 37 percent of revenue, an increase of 150 basis points versus last year predominantly through our owned channels. We attribute this growth to our progress in enhancing the overall Potbelly digital experience, dedicated efforts To increase Perk's loyalty program member acquisition and activation and engagement through targeted digital promotions and advertisements. Turning to expenses. Food, beverage and packaging costs were 27.8 percent of shop sales, A 210 basis point improvement versus the prior year period. Overall, Q3 commodity inflation was greatly improved at minus 1.5 Our grocery category, which includes produce, soup, condiments and chips, are the largest input cost increases, With meat, primarily chicken, retreating year over year. Speaker 300:09:52Labor expenses were 28.9 percent of sales, A 200 basis point improvement versus the prior year period. This improvement is attributed to sales leverage along with continued optimization of our hours based labor guide. We continue to see wage rates moderate and expect this to continue to normalize through the end of the year. Occupancy was 10.7 percent of sales, a 90 basis point improvement versus the prior year period. The improvement was driven by top line leverage and the refranchising of our New York City market, which carried higher than average occupancy costs. Speaker 300:10:29Other operating expenses were 18% of sales, a 100 basis point increase versus the prior year period. This was predominantly due to increased brand fund spend. Overall, shop level margins in the Q3 were 14.6%, an increase of 400 basis points year over year. I'll cover our forward looking guidance in a moment. But as we look to our Q4, Last year, we received one time benefits to our restaurant margin totaling 90 basis points that we do not expect to repeat this year. Speaker 300:11:02These results truly demonstrated increasing power of the Pot Valley economic model with sustainable top line growth Fueled by the effectiveness of our marketing efforts, including our Perks loyalty program, operations focus on customer experience and throughput, prudent cost control and normalization of inflationary pressures. That said, we still have more work to do and are focused on achieving our 20 24 shop level margin target of 16%. General and administrative expenses were 9.8% of revenue. The year over year increase in G and A was driven primarily by higher bonus accruals as we outperformed our targets in the quarter And increased headcount from a year ago to fuel our development efforts. As we discussed last quarter, we continue to believe general and administrative As a percentage of system wide sales is a more applicable way to view our business as we become more franchise based over time. Speaker 300:11:58For the Q3, general and administrative expenses were approximately 8.6% of system wide sales. We are encouraged by these results as we continue to leverage sales, control costs and build the development infrastructure ahead of our increasing pace of unit growth. We reported net income of $1,500,000 for the quarter. Adjusted net income was $1,100,000 An $800,000 improvement versus the prior year period. 3rd quarter adjusted EBITDA was $7,300,000 or 6% of total revenue. Speaker 300:12:33This was a $2,600,000 increase year over year and a 200 basis point improvement on the margin. Turning to our outlook. For the full year 2023, our outlook includes AUV Of $1,290,000 same store sales growth between 11.5% 12% Stock level margins between 13.4% 13.9 percent Adjusted EBITDA of between $25,900,000 $27,900,000 For the Q4 of 2023, we are currently forecasting the following: average weekly sales between $24,250 And $24,750 Same store sales growth between 4% 6%, CHOP level margin between 12.5% 14.5% and adjusted EBITDA between $5,000,000 $7,000,000 With that, I'll turn the call back over to Bob. Speaker 200:13:42Thanks, Steve. Our Q3 results demonstrated what the Potbelly business model is capable of. And with our momentum continuing into the Q4, we believe we have line of sight to achieving the Full year 2024 growth targets. Our pipeline of additional SHOP development area agreements remain strong And we look forward to sharing additional updates in the coming quarters. While we've achieved a great deal in the recent quarters, I can assure you that we are only just getting started. Speaker 200:14:10With that, we're happy to answer any questions. Operator, please open the line for questions. Operator00:14:16Of course. Today's first question comes from Todd Brooks with The Benchmark Company. Please go ahead. Speaker 400:14:45Hey, good afternoon and congratulations on the results. Good progress. Speaker 500:14:51Thanks, Todd. Good afternoon. Thanks, Todd. Speaker 400:14:55Couple of quick questions. And maybe the easiest way to talk To it is the 4% to 6% same store sales guidance for the Q4. Can you disaggregate for us Kind of pricing, traffic and mix assumptions within that 4% to 6% or if it's easier to talk about a pricing waterfall In the forward quarters, we can attack it that way as well. Speaker 300:15:23Sure, Todd. When I start with pricing itself and then we can kind of get into some of the other components. So for the quarter, we're looking at a 4% Overall price increase and that includes some of the carry forward from the prior year. We had a pricing action early In P11 here in the quarter, which was a 1.5% price increase. So if you can think about our guide at an 8 Same store sales rate, you've got sorry, if you look at our guide at 4 to 6 SafeStore sales and then you take a look at our pricing of 4, The rest ends up being a blend of traffic and mix shift. Speaker 300:16:14And our We've got a business that we feel like is moving in the right direction here and is continuing its strength. We know the category is Roughly flat to negative on traffic. I think we like where we are north of that. So we don't break down all the components beyond there, but If you take your 4% to 6% range on same store sales and our 6% sorry, our 4% price increase, that should help you get to where you need to go. Speaker 400:16:41That's perfect. Thanks, Steve. And then your consumer, I think last quarter you might have talked about Just a little bit of I don't even know if it was check management versus people opting into Mini As an option, what do you think about how they're building Chek? Are they behaving with a similar fashion as they were maybe at the outset of What are you watching on the Potbelly consumer? Speaker 300:17:09Yes, it's Speaker 200:17:09a great question, Todd. And I think some of it actually relates To build on what Steve was talking about, but we see a couple of things going on in there. Yes, there is a little bit Of a size shift that seems to continue from our Biggs and Originals to our Skinnies. When you look at the traffic growth that we have and the amount of business that we're driving, especially with the newer Perks consumers, We're not 100% sure that that is actually change Behavior of existing consumers or is it a change in the profile of our total consumer set. But it's not at all unhealthy for us. Speaker 200:17:51It's not driving a significant change in check. And the other thing is that it's actually slightly better on margin as you move through that. There's another shift that's happening. If you heard in my prepared remarks how the majority of our digital business is now coming through our own channels, our Perks App and web channels and that's the first time you've heard us say that. That means that there's a shift by channel away from the DSPs. Speaker 200:18:17So there's 3rd party delivery orders. Those are always going to carry a higher check So again, it can have some deflationary impact on Check. From a penny profit, we've engineered that to be just about even for us. So there's no profitability concern. In fact, again, from a margin perspective, that can be somewhat Of a benefit, but because of that slight channel shift, you can see some adjustment in that check too. Speaker 200:18:51So What I think is the broader question for the consumer in general is, are we seeing really significant shifts in consumer behavior In their spending patterns and what's going on with traffic patterns and our traffic patterns compared to the fast casual traffic. And the answer is, our consumer seems to be hanging in there really well. Look, they've got the jobs market is strong, they've got the income to support it, and the most revised Savings numbers suggest that the consumer in this $7,500,000 plus range has not been impacted by the pricing that we've taken anyway To offset inflation over the last 12 months. Speaker 400:19:30That's great. And one final one and then I'll jump back in queue. You just touched on Perks as an engine. Are we I know I've asked this in the past, are we closer to maybe getting some quantification On what perks means to Potbelly either size of membership or continued commentary about Membership growth rates, just wondering if we can get a better understanding of how important of an engine it is? Thanks. Speaker 200:19:58Yes, especially when it's again, we are Very pleased with just how powerful Perks continues to be for us. And when you see that shift To our own channels over the DSPs, Perks is at the heart of that, and we're seeing growth in there. The other thing that we're very excited about is the growth in Perks acquisition and in fact the growth in the rate of Perks acquisition. We are seeing year over year a 60% increase, 60% plus increase in The acquisition rate for Perks members coming through those promotional activities. Now, it's still our job to convert those More and more frequent users, we still nurture that relationship. Speaker 200:20:45We've got the nurturing flows that we've talked about in the past. But Filling the funnel, which is the biggest first step for us, has shown a lot of momentum here in the last well, in the last quarter, but in the last 6 months too. So we're really pleased with that acquisition rate. Speaker 400:21:03That's great. Thanks, Bob. Speaker 300:21:05You're welcome. Operator00:21:08Thank you. The next question comes from Jeremy Hamblin with Craig Hallum Capital Group. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:21:14Thanks. And I'll add my congratulations on terrific results. I wanted to start with your labor costs. You had pretty impressive Year over year improvement, but I think even from a sequential standpoint, 150 basis points lower than Q2. Wanted to just understand the factors involved in seeing that type of improvement. Speaker 600:21:40Is that the digital kitchen and kind of changes in the make line that we're starting to see That kind of transformed the business, but any color that you could add to what you're seeing there would be appreciated. Speaker 300:22:02Welcome, Jeremy. Thanks for the question. Yes, I'll start. I think just to give you the Headlines in terms of the shift we've seen, some of it comes from some of the sales leverage we get obviously on the fixed Element of labor, that's a benefit to us. But also, I think primarily, where we see a lot of benefit is in the management Of the hours at the shop level and the continued optimization of our hours based labor guide. Speaker 300:22:32Also, I think labor inflation for us has been fairly consistent, certainly off its peak from probably about 18 months ago and having that visibility is helpful. We've also experienced Turnover rates, which are certainly lower than from the data we've seen lower than that of the fast casual industry. And so all of those elements, I think would be contributing factors to that improvement on the labor line that you're seeing. Speaker 200:23:05Yes, Jeremy, nothing like The continued momentum on the top line, really stable associate and management turnover and retention, and we're getting the efficiency that You asked specifically about PDK. The rate of our continued implementation of DK is really just isn't rapid enough to influence the entire portfolio that quickly, but what we are seeing is we continue to see The savings that we seek out of the labor that goes with that efficiency on the back line, we capture most of that in the 1st 2 or 3 weeks after implementing PDK getting those behaviors changed and then that becomes the new normal. And the better part of that, As we've said in previous quarters, we are continuing to expand the rollout of PDK And we do it by prioritizing those most capacity constrained shops. Those are the ones that are going to be very peaky at dinner or peaky at lunch Where we have that longest line because we often talk about PDK with the back line digital components and helping us with all that digital business Coming through those channels, PDK also includes a handheld order tablet that helps us move the frontline. So that's why we've prioritized those shops. Speaker 200:24:28And when we put it in there, we get the benefit of being able to move that frontline and extract even more throughput. And of course, there's a benefit that goes with that. Last thing I'd say, we have to give our operations team a lot of credit here. They're becoming more seasoned. The multi unit operators at the district manager and director level have been in position for a long time. Speaker 200:24:49They really are gelling as a team And their management of the labor and the stability of that management continues to help us as well. Speaker 600:24:59Great. Helpful color. So as a follow-up question, as we look towards getting to that 16% And shop level margin target for FY 2024. I want to just understand in terms of the I'm following parts here. Your guidance for FY 2023 is 13.4% to 13.9% shop level margin. Speaker 600:25:24In terms of which of the line items you expect to generate that kind of 200 to a little bit over 200 basis point Improvement in margins next year, where do you expect the primary contributing factors to come from? Is that Still labor and occupancy leverage or what are kind of the factors you expect to drive most of those gains? Speaker 300:25:52Yes, sure. I think it's you hit on 2 of them. I can give some more color. I think certainly on the labor side, we expect to get more Efficient and effective through PDK as well as some additional efforts to continue to optimize labor in the shops as I'll describe that will be a major contributor to it. We frankly, on the sales leverage, they'll flow through That's going to be another kind of a benefit to us. Speaker 300:26:18But also, we expect to see continued benefit to us in terms of food input costs That will be a contributor as well. And then when you look at the business and you say, okay, well, there's not one silver bullet for us that's going to The margin all the way. It's going to be a contribution from a few other things too. So for example, we expect our catering business to continue to grow. That tends to be A healthy margin business for us. Speaker 300:26:46We still have runway yet to go in our CBD Portfolio and that still continues to be a tailwind for us as there are return to work There's return to work momentum that continues to build. That's going to be a component for us as well. And then we also will continue to price strategically to continue to outrun inflation and we feel like While we won't expand margin because of that, we will remain competitive and being competitive means for us kind of being at or below where our fast Casual competitors are and we've seen some benefit on traffic from being in that position. And so added traffic obviously creates the leverage that then starts to flow Where we typically don't get a ton of additional leverage like we used to before the pandemic is in our other OpEx line, about half of it's Fixed and the other half is floats with the business. That's where our brand fund sits. Speaker 300:27:46That's where our fees for 3rd party delivery and so forth sit. So we might get a little bit of benefit there if we see continued shift away from the DSP component of things, but It's really that amalgamation of all those components that I described that will help us get to that 16%. And by the way, based on our momentum and our trends, We feel like we've got that 16% clearly in our sights for next year. Speaker 600:28:13Great. Another question here, just in terms of the sale of the color that you provided in the Q here on the sale of the Ohio locations, $3,300,000 substantially higher, I think that's what, dollars 825,000 A unit substantially higher than what you realized on your first two deals this year. Wanted to understand first, what should we be expecting as you look to refranchise approximately 100 locations over the next few years? And then what was driving specific to these deals? Why the Ohio locations were So much more highly valued, than the other locations. Speaker 600:29:01I know that New York City locations were not super profitable, And that's probably part of the answer, but wanted just a little more color there. Speaker 200:29:09Yes. Look, that's the primary element Goes into valuation of a franchised restaurant concept and its trading. And the other thing that I think affects That is the timing. If you look at this business continues to get stronger and stronger. And Our willingness to sell franchise or company units into the franchise system is really driven by our desire to Continue to develop and to spur that development. Speaker 200:29:41In terms of the value difference, each deal is going to be different. Each deal has to be rooted in So That really is the difference between those. But I can tell you that we're excited about each one. We would only do one if it were Accretive to the business overall, especially with the growth that comes with them. But, yes, you spotted it in the queue that Most recent deal with Royal Restaurant Group, we're very pleased with. Speaker 200:30:16To sell 4 units, get 17 additional units in Central to be developed there and then of course the remainder of the other 19 down in Florida in a group that The CEO, the CFO and the COO all work together in one of QSR's largest franchise groups In a multi state environment, done development before, and we're just incredibly excited to see this quality of franchisees coming to the brand. Speaker 600:30:46Yes. It sounds tremendous. And if you can add color there on just the franchisee pipeline, are you seeing a different type of Type of franchisee that's interested in the business now as opposed to 6 or 9 months ago, are you anticipating or looking for slightly larger partners like RRG? Or are you still looking to fill kind of more mid tier, mid scale franchisees? Speaker 200:31:19Yes. I think there's kind of 2 parts to the answer to your question. First one is just in the quality of franchise candidates that we're seeing. We are very excited To see the quality of our franchise candidates just continue to improve. And I mean that with all the same excitement we've stated about all the previous ones that have joined the The brand is getting stronger, our performance is getting stronger and candidly franchisees follow the lead of other franchisees that they respect. Speaker 200:31:47And so As you strengthen the system, you tend to strengthen the candidate pool. And I'm glad we're enjoying that natural trend And we're taking advantage of it. But we've also invested heavily in our development team to be able to recruit the best. So that's very exciting for us. 40 units is a big deal. Speaker 200:32:10In fact, you probably could You'll find me saying in the past that we wouldn't do very many of those because there aren't that many groups that can fulfill that much development in that shorter period of time. As a reminder, we've always said that our development deals, we'd like them to be about 1 a unit a year unless You have more than 8 units and then it's an 8 year limit to finish developing that out. And by and large, we've stayed really true to that Development pipeline and pace. Well, there aren't many groups that can develop that many units that quickly. This group can, we believe that 100%, so today. Speaker 200:32:48And so I think over time, you're still going to see a blend. We'll see some in the mid to high single digit number of units deals. We'll see some in the double digit Deals and there may be 1 or 2 more of this scale depending on the candidate that comes in and their capabilities. It's all about building that compounded growth that comes with the number of deals that we're able to keep doing. So generally speaking, kind of qualitatively, I'm very pleased with what we can see in the pipeline from this point We're really pleased with the team and the work they've done so far. Speaker 600:33:25Thanks for taking all my questions. Best wishes. Speaker 300:33:29Thank you. Thanks. Operator00:33:32Thank you. The next question is from Mark Smith with Lake Street Capital. Please go ahead. Speaker 400:33:39Hi, guys. Kind of Speaker 700:33:40a follow-up to that last question. Are there any characteristics of the restaurants You've been selling or maybe the franchisees are more interested in. For instance, are we looking at lower volume or lower And these restaurants that you're selling or the franchisees like kind of cleaner ones, anything that you can call out there? Speaker 200:34:03Mark, great question. There is some difference and you kind of see that reflected in the asset Purchase numbers that we've got in the queue, but it's not necessarily driven by the franchisees desire for A particular type of restaurant. A lot of it is geography, where are they, where do they want to develop, Where do they believe they understand the marketplace? In many cases, where do they have existing or previous businesses, because that's their comfort level. And that certainly has been the case with the refranchise deals that we've done so far. Speaker 200:34:42I'll tell you, we have had An increasing amount of interest in just direct development and for those that do contact us sometimes that are mostly focused on Those conversations don't go very far. There are a lot of QSR brands and other brands that are doing and have done refranchising where it truly is Kind of an EBITDA acquisition by the franchisee looking for growth so that they can increase value and resell the business at some point in the future. And those just don't tend to be very long conversations with us because we're a growth brand. And you see that in this RRG deal, 36 new units after buying 4. They would tell you they just love the idea of having a base of operations. Speaker 200:35:31Even 4 units for them was exciting. They have managers to start with. They have places where they can train as they build all these new units. They've got a running start in a market that they really love in Central Ohio. So they didn't need a large acquisition, but they didn't really Speaker 700:35:54Perfect. And then next question, As we look at the marketing brands on contribution, do you now have that kind of where you want it or do you Do you think there's opportunities for it to creep higher? And then maybe discuss benefits that you as well as your franchisees are seeing from that? Speaker 200:36:17Yes. I think we like where we are today. We reserve the right both publicly and with our franchisees Our expectation is and David's expectation leading marketing is that if we're going to put a dollar into incremental brand fund investment We'd like $3, $4,000,000 or $5 back on the top line. That's where we drive additional profitability. And in this world where we've got so many digital opportunities to invest that amount of money, today it's about 3%, that We have a chance to get the kind of returns that we're really pleased with. Speaker 200:36:56There will be natural plateaus in the media or in the The approach that you use or in the creative that you use and when you hit a plateau, then there's another investment And so I do expect that over the years, we'll continue to invest in more Of an industry standard of around 4%, some brands are spending upwards of 5%, but we're not in any rush to try to catch up That if we can't prove that we can get the returns. Franchisees have been very happy with our marketing investments because they're seeing that same top line growth that we've been seeing. Particularly when you look at the underlying indicators like we're talking about with Perks and digital and the digital mix and our ability To drive traffic, these are all things we think are rooted in the operations and how we're marketing that. So I think we're in a good place right now for now. Speaker 700:37:57Excellent. Thank you. Speaker 200:38:00Yes. Thanks, Mark. Operator00:38:03Thank you. The next question comes from Matt Curtis with William Blair. Please go ahead. Speaker 500:38:10Hi, good afternoon. I just wanted to get back to the pricing Discussion for a moment. And I ask how you view the value proposition right now following your most recent price increase? And if there's been any signs of consumer resistance so far. And then relatedly, I noticed on this last increase, You seem to have left pricing on Biggs unchanged, correct me if I'm wrong. Speaker 500:38:36So I was wondering what your thought process was around that? Speaker 300:38:41Sure. Let me just take the sort of consumer dynamic for one second. If you remember, when we talked about our pricing strategy for the year, we knew that based on the way we could see inflation evolving, we would be modest in our price increases And we have it. Our first action was 1.5, we had a 1.1 and the recent one was in a similar zone as those others. And That was deliberate. Speaker 300:39:06We got where we needed to be vis a vis inflation, which has come back to us. So that's been helpful. What we've seen as a benefit, I alluded to it in the answer to the earlier question is, it looks like some other Our competitors have continued to take some price and that may have benefited us in terms of relative value that we're providing To our customer base, as well our menu is fairly broad. So even though we might see some movement around From whether that's away from DSPs or whether that's from big sandwiches to others, We feel like we still create that kind of what you get for what you pay equation is working in our favor. And the best we can tell, Matt, from the data we see Relative to fast casual, our traffic continues to put us in a position where we're taking share. Speaker 300:40:00We're taking traffic share and we're doing it consistently week over week over week and have throughout the quarter. So, as Bob said, I think we're in a good spot as it relates to our demographic, in terms of their employment level, their savings that they still have left And they still like to come to Potbelly. So I think we feel pretty good about where we're headed here into the Q4. And then the second part of your question was related to kind of where we're taking pricing, where we're not taking price. We tend not to take pricing consistent places across the menu because we want to make sure that we're within Both psychological barriers, right, nines and zeros and those kinds of things we want to make sure as well we want to balance across channels. Speaker 300:40:47So sometimes we'll take a digital only price, Sometimes we'll take a size only price or sometimes we'll take a category only price. It really varies. And this last price increase, We may have hit Biggs a little bit less than we did others as we try to maintain that value across the menu for our consumers. Speaker 500:41:10Okay, understood. And then for the increased grant fund contribution, Which hit the other operating expenses line. Could you run us through what that spend has been specifically earmarked for? Speaker 200:41:26Yes. BrandFund is, I mean, it's marketing, right? So it's our media is 100% digital. It's delivered back to the shops in an equitable fashion. That's one of the reasons franchisees really appreciate How we manage the brand fund because they know that they get their contributions redeployed into their markets. Speaker 200:41:49But It's across the media channels. We've got paid social, we've got Digital, we've got I should say our web and our app advertising, we've got promotional activity and then promotional Activations that we do for every one of our new products that get rolled out, we've got Search engine optimization and the like, catering, advertising and so on. So it's across the spectrum What you would see in normal digital advertising for us. We have started to experiment with some media expansion in there too, because again, We know that we're even for what we're investing and what we're getting back, we know that there's more that we can continue to pour in. So we've got to do some experimentation along the way too. Speaker 500:42:45Okay, great. Thanks a lot guys and good luck the rest of the year. Speaker 300:42:49Yes. Thanks, Matt. Thanks, Matt. Operator00:42:52Thank you. The next question is a follow-up from Jeremy Hamblin with Craig Hallum Capital Group. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:43:01Thanks for taking the additional question. Just want to make sure on the for Q4, you've got a 14th week here. And just wanted to understand, I believe that that is kind of the holiday week post Christmas. And to understand what the typical sales volumes look like in that week and how we should be thinking about The impact of that week on some of these line items like occupancy and labor? Speaker 300:43:36Sure. I think there's probably a few things going on. Number 1, that week for us anyway Includes Christmas and it includes New Year's Eve. So it is going to be the way we would play it out a lower Volume week. So you can imagine how that starts to flow through the rest of the P and L. Speaker 300:44:02So we don't it ends up being about if we have a 7 day week, normally it ends up being about a 5.5 day week. I think as we try to think about The adjustment in our P and L, margins and so forth, I Speaker 600:44:27Got it. Thanks for taking the extra one. Speaker 200:44:30Yes, Jeremy, just a couple of specifics. One of the things that I think Steve and his team do really well as we look at something like this. We don't get a free week of occupancy. We would have Accrued or accounted for that with that 53rd week and spread that accordingly. And Same thing with any of the other fixed costs. Speaker 200:44:52So it puts a little sales pressure on there, but other than that, it's just It happens to us every 5 or 6 years, right? Yes. Speaker 300:45:03Got it. Thank you. Speaker 400:45:06Yes, you bet. Operator00:45:08Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached the end of today's question and answer session. I would like to turn the call back over to Bob Wright for closing remarks. Speaker 200:45:19Thank you, operator, and thank you all again for your time this evening and for joining us. We appreciate the questions, the engagement and certainly look forward to talking again soon. Hope you all have a great night. Operator00:45:32The conference has now concluded. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect yourRead morePowered by Conference Call Audio Live Call not available Earnings Conference CallA.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S Q3 202300:00 / 00:00Speed:1x1.25x1.5x2x Earnings DocumentsSlide DeckPress Release(8-K)Quarterly report(10-Q) A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S Earnings HeadlinesPotbelly Corporation Announces Conference Call to Discuss First Quarter 2025 Results on May 7, 2025April 17 at 9:39 AM | gurufocus.comThe Impact of Trump’s Tariffs on the Restaurant IndustryApril 15, 2025 | uk.finance.yahoo.comCrypto’s crashing…but we’re still profitingMost traders are panicking right now. Bitcoin’s dropping. Altcoins are bleeding. The stock market’s a mess. The news is screaming fear. But while most traders watch their portfolios tank…April 19, 2025 | Crypto Swap Profits (Ad)Is Potbelly Corporation (PBPB) Among the Top Restaurant Stocks to Buy Under $20?April 15, 2025 | insidermonkey.comModern Fast Food Stocks Q4 In Review: Chipotle (NYSE:CMG) Vs PeersMarch 31, 2025 | msn.comCould The Market Be Wrong About Potbelly Corporation (NASDAQ:PBPB) Given Its Attractive Financial Prospects?March 27, 2025 | finance.yahoo.comSee More Potbelly Headlines Get Earnings Announcements in your inboxWant to stay updated on the latest earnings announcements and upcoming reports for companies like A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S? Sign up for Earnings360's daily newsletter to receive timely earnings updates on A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S and other key companies, straight to your email. Email Address About A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/SA.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S (OTCMKTS:AMKBY), together with its subsidiaries, engages in the ocean transport and logistics business in Denmark and internationally. It operates through Ocean, Logistics & Services, Terminals, and Towage & Maritime Services segments. The Ocean segment is involved in container shipping activities, including demurrage and detention, terminal handling, documentation and container services, and container storage, as well as transshipment hubs. The Logistics & Services segment offers integrated transportation solutions; fulfillment and management solutions, such as landside and air transportation; warehousing, distribution, and depot services; and supply chain management, cold chain logistics, and custom brokerage services. The Terminals segment engages in gateway terminal activities. The Towage & Maritime Services segment provides offshore towage and marine services under the Svitzer brand; reefer containers; offshore supply services; trading; and marine services and integrated solutions to the energy sector. It also offers digital solutions that offer booking, managing, tracking of shipments, and other related activities. The company serves fashion and lifestyle, retail, automotive, chemicals, technology, and FMCG industries. A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S was founded in 1904 and is headquartered in Copenhagen, Denmark.View A.P. Møller - Mærsk A/S ProfileRead more More Earnings Resources from MarketBeat Earnings Tools Today's Earnings Tomorrow's Earnings Next Week's Earnings Upcoming Earnings Calls Earnings Newsletter Earnings Call Transcripts Earnings Beats & Misses Corporate Guidance Earnings Screener Earnings By Country U.S. Earnings Reports Canadian Earnings Reports U.K. Earnings Reports Latest Articles Archer Aviation Unveils NYC Network Ahead of Key Earnings Report3 Reasons to Like the Look of Amazon Ahead of EarningsTesla Stock Eyes Breakout With Earnings on DeckJohnson & Johnson Earnings Were More Good Than Bad—Time to Buy? Why Analysts Boosted United Airlines Stock Ahead of EarningsLamb Weston Stock Rises, Earnings Provide Calm Amidst ChaosIntuitive Machines Gains After Earnings Beat, NASA Missions Ahead Upcoming Earnings Tesla (4/22/2025)Intuitive Surgical (4/22/2025)Verizon Communications (4/22/2025)Canadian National Railway (4/22/2025)Novartis (4/22/2025)RTX (4/22/2025)3M (4/22/2025)Capital One Financial (4/22/2025)General Electric (4/22/2025)Danaher (4/22/2025) Get 30 Days of MarketBeat All Access for Free Sign up for MarketBeat All Access to gain access to MarketBeat's full suite of research tools. Start Your 30-Day Trial MarketBeat All Access Features Best-in-Class Portfolio Monitoring Get personalized stock ideas. Compare portfolio to indices. Check stock news, ratings, SEC filings, and more. Stock Ideas and Recommendations See daily stock ideas from top analysts. Receive short-term trading ideas from MarketBeat. Identify trending stocks on social media. Advanced Stock Screeners and Research Tools Use our seven stock screeners to find suitable stocks. Stay informed with MarketBeat's real-time news. Export data to Excel for personal analysis. Sign in to your free account to enjoy these benefits In-depth profiles and analysis for 20,000 public companies. Real-time analyst ratings, insider transactions, earnings data, and more. Our daily ratings and market update email newsletter. Sign in to your free account to enjoy all that MarketBeat has to offer. Sign In Create Account Your Email Address: Email Address Required Your Password: Password Required Log In or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google Forgot your password? Your Email Address: Please enter your email address. Please enter a valid email address Choose a Password: Please enter your password. Your password must be at least 8 characters long and contain at least 1 number, 1 letter, and 1 special character. Create My Account (Free) or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google By creating a free account, you agree to our terms of service. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
There are 8 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Afternoon, everyone, and welcome to Potbelly Corporation's Third Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. Today's call is being recorded. At this time, all participants have been placed in a listen only mode and the lines will be open for your questions following the prepared remarks. On today's call, we have Bob Wright, President and Chief Executive Officer Steve Cyrillis, Senior Vice President and Chief Financial Officer and Adia Dickson, Chief Legal Officer and Secretary of Potbelly Corporation. At this time, I'll turn the call over to Adia Dixon. Operator00:00:36Please go ahead. Speaker 100:00:39Good afternoon, everyone, and welcome to our Q3 2023 earnings call. By now, everyone should have access to our earnings release and accompanying investor presentation. If not, they can be found on the Investor Relations section of our website. Before we begin our formal remarks, I need to remind everyone, certain comments made on this call will contain forward looking statements regarding future events or the future financial performance of the company. Any such statements, including our outlook for 2023 or any other future periods, should be considered forward looking statements within the meaning of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. Speaker 100:01:20These forward looking statements are not guarantees of future performance, nor should they be relied upon as representing management's views as of any subsequent date. Forward looking statements involve significant risks and uncertainties, and events or results could differ materially from those presented due to a number of risks and uncertainties. Additional detailed information concerning these risks Regarding our business and the factors that could cause actual results to differ materially from the forward looking statements and other information that will be given today and can be found in our Form 10 ks under the headings Risk Factors and MD and A and in our subsequent filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission, which are available at sec.gov. During the call, there will also be a discussion of some items that do not conform to U. S. Speaker 100:02:08Generally Accepted Accounting Principles for GAAP. Reconciliations of these non GAAP measures to their most directly comparable GAAP measures are included in the appendix to the press release an investor presentation issued this afternoon, both of which are available in the Investors tab of our website. With that out of the way, I would like to turn the call over to Potbelly's President and CEO, Bob Wright. Speaker 200:02:33Thank you, Adia, and good afternoon and thank you for joining our call today. We delivered strong Q3 results demonstrated by solid top line improvement And 8% same store sales growth. Notably, our traffic growth remained a strong contributor as we continue to take traffic Share from the fast casual category each week through the quarter. We also grew shop level margins through continued leverage across food and labor costs, resulting in a 400 basis point improvement year over year. I'm proud to say that these results were driven by the cumulative effect Our disciplined strategy and execution over the past many quarters, driving our confidence in the sustainability of the results we've achieved thus far. Speaker 200:03:15We remain focused on achieving the long term growth potential of this amazing brand. As we look forward to the end of the year and into 2024, We will continue to execute against our 5 pillar strategic plan to achieve traffic driven profitability and unit growth. This includes craveable quality food at a great value, people creating good vibes, customer experiences that drive traffic growth, Digitally driven awareness and connection and franchise focused development. With that, let me update you on our ongoing initiatives that support these Starting with the Potbelly digital experience. We're pleased with another quarter of outstanding performance in our digital business, driven by meaningful progress Our Perks loyalty program. Speaker 200:04:00All in all, our digital business represented approximately 37% of our total shop sales during the quarter, An increase of approximately 150 basis points relative to the same period last year. Importantly, we also continue to see a shift in our digital business away from 3rd party channels and towards Potbelly owned app, web and Perks originated orders. We are committed to serving our customers with the occasions that best meet their needs each time they visit Potbelly, including Our unique in shop fast casual dining experience and through the variety of order occasions delivered by the Potbelly digital experience. During the quarter, we were thrilled to see growth in both verticals. Turning to our Potbelly Digital Kitchen, the rollout of PDK to our existing shops is Progressing as planned and we will continue the deployment of PDK across our system of existing shops as a standard in every new franchise location. Speaker 200:04:59More importantly is the benefit of PDK to our operations, which are clearly demonstrated not only by the ongoing growth of our digital business and our ability to handle the incremental throughput, particularly during peak periods, but also operating efficiency and improvements in the customer experience From orders ready on time to accuracy of food and quality scores. Importantly, we continue to leverage the Throughput learnings from PDK and shops yet to be rolled out in our ongoing effort to drive traffic. Our traffic driven foundation to sales growth During the quarter, we introduced our latest underground menu item with the Lucky 7 sandwich, uniting all 7 meats from 2 of our most popular Overall, our underground menu introductions available only on the Potbelly app Continue to be among the most searched menu items in our digital channels. As we look ahead, we will continue to focus on Food and marketing innovation to further drive growth of our Perks loyalty program and digital channels. Lastly, let me share some exciting updates to our Franchise Growth Acceleration Initiative or FGA. Speaker 200:06:18As we mentioned on our last call, during the quarter, we 27 Unit Deal in Maryland through a partnership with our company founder, Bryant Kyle. During and subsequent to the end of We signed multiple additional new development agreements, including a 40 unit deal that is comprised of 4 refranchised shops and a commitment to develop 36 new shops in both Ohio and Florida. Our shop development commitments now total 150 shops to date. I'm proud of what our franchising team has accomplished in such a short period of time. We remain focused on achieving our 10% unit growth in 2024. Speaker 200:06:55We continue to have a highly active and fluid pipeline of qualified Potbelly franchise candidates. And when combined with our unique brand and Proven business fundamentals, we believe we have the foundation and the right team in place to drive long term growth. Looking forward, we will continue to emphasize our Franchise focus and build the organization's capability to support our franchise growth as we head towards 2,000 units in the U. S. We look forward to sharing additional updates on our next calls as more SDAA's or SHOP Development Area Agreements are finalized. Speaker 200:07:30Finally, let me reiterate how proud I am of our Potbelly team. Their hard work and commitment to our unique brand have resulted in a strong third quarter And they do so by carrying out our mission to delight customers with great food and good vibes, creating a distinct and differentiated fast casual experience for each of our customers from their first moment to their last bite. With that, I will now turn the call over to Steve to detail our financial performance for the Q3. Speaker 300:08:01Thank you, Bob. Good afternoon, everyone. Revenues in the 3rd quarter increased approximately 3% to $120,800,000 driven by same store sales growth of 8%, resulting in average weekly sales of approximately $25,190 partially offset by the short term revenue impact of our recent refranchising transaction. System wide sales of $138,200,000 Grew by approximately 7%. Traffic continues to be a strong contributor to same store sales growth Additionally, we implemented modest price increases to mitigate increases in input costs and will continue to do so as necessary, although Q3 saw appreciable inflation deceleration. Speaker 300:08:55Our digital business continues to grow and currently represents approximately 37 percent of revenue, an increase of 150 basis points versus last year predominantly through our owned channels. We attribute this growth to our progress in enhancing the overall Potbelly digital experience, dedicated efforts To increase Perk's loyalty program member acquisition and activation and engagement through targeted digital promotions and advertisements. Turning to expenses. Food, beverage and packaging costs were 27.8 percent of shop sales, A 210 basis point improvement versus the prior year period. Overall, Q3 commodity inflation was greatly improved at minus 1.5 Our grocery category, which includes produce, soup, condiments and chips, are the largest input cost increases, With meat, primarily chicken, retreating year over year. Speaker 300:09:52Labor expenses were 28.9 percent of sales, A 200 basis point improvement versus the prior year period. This improvement is attributed to sales leverage along with continued optimization of our hours based labor guide. We continue to see wage rates moderate and expect this to continue to normalize through the end of the year. Occupancy was 10.7 percent of sales, a 90 basis point improvement versus the prior year period. The improvement was driven by top line leverage and the refranchising of our New York City market, which carried higher than average occupancy costs. Speaker 300:10:29Other operating expenses were 18% of sales, a 100 basis point increase versus the prior year period. This was predominantly due to increased brand fund spend. Overall, shop level margins in the Q3 were 14.6%, an increase of 400 basis points year over year. I'll cover our forward looking guidance in a moment. But as we look to our Q4, Last year, we received one time benefits to our restaurant margin totaling 90 basis points that we do not expect to repeat this year. Speaker 300:11:02These results truly demonstrated increasing power of the Pot Valley economic model with sustainable top line growth Fueled by the effectiveness of our marketing efforts, including our Perks loyalty program, operations focus on customer experience and throughput, prudent cost control and normalization of inflationary pressures. That said, we still have more work to do and are focused on achieving our 20 24 shop level margin target of 16%. General and administrative expenses were 9.8% of revenue. The year over year increase in G and A was driven primarily by higher bonus accruals as we outperformed our targets in the quarter And increased headcount from a year ago to fuel our development efforts. As we discussed last quarter, we continue to believe general and administrative As a percentage of system wide sales is a more applicable way to view our business as we become more franchise based over time. Speaker 300:11:58For the Q3, general and administrative expenses were approximately 8.6% of system wide sales. We are encouraged by these results as we continue to leverage sales, control costs and build the development infrastructure ahead of our increasing pace of unit growth. We reported net income of $1,500,000 for the quarter. Adjusted net income was $1,100,000 An $800,000 improvement versus the prior year period. 3rd quarter adjusted EBITDA was $7,300,000 or 6% of total revenue. Speaker 300:12:33This was a $2,600,000 increase year over year and a 200 basis point improvement on the margin. Turning to our outlook. For the full year 2023, our outlook includes AUV Of $1,290,000 same store sales growth between 11.5% 12% Stock level margins between 13.4% 13.9 percent Adjusted EBITDA of between $25,900,000 $27,900,000 For the Q4 of 2023, we are currently forecasting the following: average weekly sales between $24,250 And $24,750 Same store sales growth between 4% 6%, CHOP level margin between 12.5% 14.5% and adjusted EBITDA between $5,000,000 $7,000,000 With that, I'll turn the call back over to Bob. Speaker 200:13:42Thanks, Steve. Our Q3 results demonstrated what the Potbelly business model is capable of. And with our momentum continuing into the Q4, we believe we have line of sight to achieving the Full year 2024 growth targets. Our pipeline of additional SHOP development area agreements remain strong And we look forward to sharing additional updates in the coming quarters. While we've achieved a great deal in the recent quarters, I can assure you that we are only just getting started. Speaker 200:14:10With that, we're happy to answer any questions. Operator, please open the line for questions. Operator00:14:16Of course. Today's first question comes from Todd Brooks with The Benchmark Company. Please go ahead. Speaker 400:14:45Hey, good afternoon and congratulations on the results. Good progress. Speaker 500:14:51Thanks, Todd. Good afternoon. Thanks, Todd. Speaker 400:14:55Couple of quick questions. And maybe the easiest way to talk To it is the 4% to 6% same store sales guidance for the Q4. Can you disaggregate for us Kind of pricing, traffic and mix assumptions within that 4% to 6% or if it's easier to talk about a pricing waterfall In the forward quarters, we can attack it that way as well. Speaker 300:15:23Sure, Todd. When I start with pricing itself and then we can kind of get into some of the other components. So for the quarter, we're looking at a 4% Overall price increase and that includes some of the carry forward from the prior year. We had a pricing action early In P11 here in the quarter, which was a 1.5% price increase. So if you can think about our guide at an 8 Same store sales rate, you've got sorry, if you look at our guide at 4 to 6 SafeStore sales and then you take a look at our pricing of 4, The rest ends up being a blend of traffic and mix shift. Speaker 300:16:14And our We've got a business that we feel like is moving in the right direction here and is continuing its strength. We know the category is Roughly flat to negative on traffic. I think we like where we are north of that. So we don't break down all the components beyond there, but If you take your 4% to 6% range on same store sales and our 6% sorry, our 4% price increase, that should help you get to where you need to go. Speaker 400:16:41That's perfect. Thanks, Steve. And then your consumer, I think last quarter you might have talked about Just a little bit of I don't even know if it was check management versus people opting into Mini As an option, what do you think about how they're building Chek? Are they behaving with a similar fashion as they were maybe at the outset of What are you watching on the Potbelly consumer? Speaker 300:17:09Yes, it's Speaker 200:17:09a great question, Todd. And I think some of it actually relates To build on what Steve was talking about, but we see a couple of things going on in there. Yes, there is a little bit Of a size shift that seems to continue from our Biggs and Originals to our Skinnies. When you look at the traffic growth that we have and the amount of business that we're driving, especially with the newer Perks consumers, We're not 100% sure that that is actually change Behavior of existing consumers or is it a change in the profile of our total consumer set. But it's not at all unhealthy for us. Speaker 200:17:51It's not driving a significant change in check. And the other thing is that it's actually slightly better on margin as you move through that. There's another shift that's happening. If you heard in my prepared remarks how the majority of our digital business is now coming through our own channels, our Perks App and web channels and that's the first time you've heard us say that. That means that there's a shift by channel away from the DSPs. Speaker 200:18:17So there's 3rd party delivery orders. Those are always going to carry a higher check So again, it can have some deflationary impact on Check. From a penny profit, we've engineered that to be just about even for us. So there's no profitability concern. In fact, again, from a margin perspective, that can be somewhat Of a benefit, but because of that slight channel shift, you can see some adjustment in that check too. Speaker 200:18:51So What I think is the broader question for the consumer in general is, are we seeing really significant shifts in consumer behavior In their spending patterns and what's going on with traffic patterns and our traffic patterns compared to the fast casual traffic. And the answer is, our consumer seems to be hanging in there really well. Look, they've got the jobs market is strong, they've got the income to support it, and the most revised Savings numbers suggest that the consumer in this $7,500,000 plus range has not been impacted by the pricing that we've taken anyway To offset inflation over the last 12 months. Speaker 400:19:30That's great. And one final one and then I'll jump back in queue. You just touched on Perks as an engine. Are we I know I've asked this in the past, are we closer to maybe getting some quantification On what perks means to Potbelly either size of membership or continued commentary about Membership growth rates, just wondering if we can get a better understanding of how important of an engine it is? Thanks. Speaker 200:19:58Yes, especially when it's again, we are Very pleased with just how powerful Perks continues to be for us. And when you see that shift To our own channels over the DSPs, Perks is at the heart of that, and we're seeing growth in there. The other thing that we're very excited about is the growth in Perks acquisition and in fact the growth in the rate of Perks acquisition. We are seeing year over year a 60% increase, 60% plus increase in The acquisition rate for Perks members coming through those promotional activities. Now, it's still our job to convert those More and more frequent users, we still nurture that relationship. Speaker 200:20:45We've got the nurturing flows that we've talked about in the past. But Filling the funnel, which is the biggest first step for us, has shown a lot of momentum here in the last well, in the last quarter, but in the last 6 months too. So we're really pleased with that acquisition rate. Speaker 400:21:03That's great. Thanks, Bob. Speaker 300:21:05You're welcome. Operator00:21:08Thank you. The next question comes from Jeremy Hamblin with Craig Hallum Capital Group. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:21:14Thanks. And I'll add my congratulations on terrific results. I wanted to start with your labor costs. You had pretty impressive Year over year improvement, but I think even from a sequential standpoint, 150 basis points lower than Q2. Wanted to just understand the factors involved in seeing that type of improvement. Speaker 600:21:40Is that the digital kitchen and kind of changes in the make line that we're starting to see That kind of transformed the business, but any color that you could add to what you're seeing there would be appreciated. Speaker 300:22:02Welcome, Jeremy. Thanks for the question. Yes, I'll start. I think just to give you the Headlines in terms of the shift we've seen, some of it comes from some of the sales leverage we get obviously on the fixed Element of labor, that's a benefit to us. But also, I think primarily, where we see a lot of benefit is in the management Of the hours at the shop level and the continued optimization of our hours based labor guide. Speaker 300:22:32Also, I think labor inflation for us has been fairly consistent, certainly off its peak from probably about 18 months ago and having that visibility is helpful. We've also experienced Turnover rates, which are certainly lower than from the data we've seen lower than that of the fast casual industry. And so all of those elements, I think would be contributing factors to that improvement on the labor line that you're seeing. Speaker 200:23:05Yes, Jeremy, nothing like The continued momentum on the top line, really stable associate and management turnover and retention, and we're getting the efficiency that You asked specifically about PDK. The rate of our continued implementation of DK is really just isn't rapid enough to influence the entire portfolio that quickly, but what we are seeing is we continue to see The savings that we seek out of the labor that goes with that efficiency on the back line, we capture most of that in the 1st 2 or 3 weeks after implementing PDK getting those behaviors changed and then that becomes the new normal. And the better part of that, As we've said in previous quarters, we are continuing to expand the rollout of PDK And we do it by prioritizing those most capacity constrained shops. Those are the ones that are going to be very peaky at dinner or peaky at lunch Where we have that longest line because we often talk about PDK with the back line digital components and helping us with all that digital business Coming through those channels, PDK also includes a handheld order tablet that helps us move the frontline. So that's why we've prioritized those shops. Speaker 200:24:28And when we put it in there, we get the benefit of being able to move that frontline and extract even more throughput. And of course, there's a benefit that goes with that. Last thing I'd say, we have to give our operations team a lot of credit here. They're becoming more seasoned. The multi unit operators at the district manager and director level have been in position for a long time. Speaker 200:24:49They really are gelling as a team And their management of the labor and the stability of that management continues to help us as well. Speaker 600:24:59Great. Helpful color. So as a follow-up question, as we look towards getting to that 16% And shop level margin target for FY 2024. I want to just understand in terms of the I'm following parts here. Your guidance for FY 2023 is 13.4% to 13.9% shop level margin. Speaker 600:25:24In terms of which of the line items you expect to generate that kind of 200 to a little bit over 200 basis point Improvement in margins next year, where do you expect the primary contributing factors to come from? Is that Still labor and occupancy leverage or what are kind of the factors you expect to drive most of those gains? Speaker 300:25:52Yes, sure. I think it's you hit on 2 of them. I can give some more color. I think certainly on the labor side, we expect to get more Efficient and effective through PDK as well as some additional efforts to continue to optimize labor in the shops as I'll describe that will be a major contributor to it. We frankly, on the sales leverage, they'll flow through That's going to be another kind of a benefit to us. Speaker 300:26:18But also, we expect to see continued benefit to us in terms of food input costs That will be a contributor as well. And then when you look at the business and you say, okay, well, there's not one silver bullet for us that's going to The margin all the way. It's going to be a contribution from a few other things too. So for example, we expect our catering business to continue to grow. That tends to be A healthy margin business for us. Speaker 300:26:46We still have runway yet to go in our CBD Portfolio and that still continues to be a tailwind for us as there are return to work There's return to work momentum that continues to build. That's going to be a component for us as well. And then we also will continue to price strategically to continue to outrun inflation and we feel like While we won't expand margin because of that, we will remain competitive and being competitive means for us kind of being at or below where our fast Casual competitors are and we've seen some benefit on traffic from being in that position. And so added traffic obviously creates the leverage that then starts to flow Where we typically don't get a ton of additional leverage like we used to before the pandemic is in our other OpEx line, about half of it's Fixed and the other half is floats with the business. That's where our brand fund sits. Speaker 300:27:46That's where our fees for 3rd party delivery and so forth sit. So we might get a little bit of benefit there if we see continued shift away from the DSP component of things, but It's really that amalgamation of all those components that I described that will help us get to that 16%. And by the way, based on our momentum and our trends, We feel like we've got that 16% clearly in our sights for next year. Speaker 600:28:13Great. Another question here, just in terms of the sale of the color that you provided in the Q here on the sale of the Ohio locations, $3,300,000 substantially higher, I think that's what, dollars 825,000 A unit substantially higher than what you realized on your first two deals this year. Wanted to understand first, what should we be expecting as you look to refranchise approximately 100 locations over the next few years? And then what was driving specific to these deals? Why the Ohio locations were So much more highly valued, than the other locations. Speaker 600:29:01I know that New York City locations were not super profitable, And that's probably part of the answer, but wanted just a little more color there. Speaker 200:29:09Yes. Look, that's the primary element Goes into valuation of a franchised restaurant concept and its trading. And the other thing that I think affects That is the timing. If you look at this business continues to get stronger and stronger. And Our willingness to sell franchise or company units into the franchise system is really driven by our desire to Continue to develop and to spur that development. Speaker 200:29:41In terms of the value difference, each deal is going to be different. Each deal has to be rooted in So That really is the difference between those. But I can tell you that we're excited about each one. We would only do one if it were Accretive to the business overall, especially with the growth that comes with them. But, yes, you spotted it in the queue that Most recent deal with Royal Restaurant Group, we're very pleased with. Speaker 200:30:16To sell 4 units, get 17 additional units in Central to be developed there and then of course the remainder of the other 19 down in Florida in a group that The CEO, the CFO and the COO all work together in one of QSR's largest franchise groups In a multi state environment, done development before, and we're just incredibly excited to see this quality of franchisees coming to the brand. Speaker 600:30:46Yes. It sounds tremendous. And if you can add color there on just the franchisee pipeline, are you seeing a different type of Type of franchisee that's interested in the business now as opposed to 6 or 9 months ago, are you anticipating or looking for slightly larger partners like RRG? Or are you still looking to fill kind of more mid tier, mid scale franchisees? Speaker 200:31:19Yes. I think there's kind of 2 parts to the answer to your question. First one is just in the quality of franchise candidates that we're seeing. We are very excited To see the quality of our franchise candidates just continue to improve. And I mean that with all the same excitement we've stated about all the previous ones that have joined the The brand is getting stronger, our performance is getting stronger and candidly franchisees follow the lead of other franchisees that they respect. Speaker 200:31:47And so As you strengthen the system, you tend to strengthen the candidate pool. And I'm glad we're enjoying that natural trend And we're taking advantage of it. But we've also invested heavily in our development team to be able to recruit the best. So that's very exciting for us. 40 units is a big deal. Speaker 200:32:10In fact, you probably could You'll find me saying in the past that we wouldn't do very many of those because there aren't that many groups that can fulfill that much development in that shorter period of time. As a reminder, we've always said that our development deals, we'd like them to be about 1 a unit a year unless You have more than 8 units and then it's an 8 year limit to finish developing that out. And by and large, we've stayed really true to that Development pipeline and pace. Well, there aren't many groups that can develop that many units that quickly. This group can, we believe that 100%, so today. Speaker 200:32:48And so I think over time, you're still going to see a blend. We'll see some in the mid to high single digit number of units deals. We'll see some in the double digit Deals and there may be 1 or 2 more of this scale depending on the candidate that comes in and their capabilities. It's all about building that compounded growth that comes with the number of deals that we're able to keep doing. So generally speaking, kind of qualitatively, I'm very pleased with what we can see in the pipeline from this point We're really pleased with the team and the work they've done so far. Speaker 600:33:25Thanks for taking all my questions. Best wishes. Speaker 300:33:29Thank you. Thanks. Operator00:33:32Thank you. The next question is from Mark Smith with Lake Street Capital. Please go ahead. Speaker 400:33:39Hi, guys. Kind of Speaker 700:33:40a follow-up to that last question. Are there any characteristics of the restaurants You've been selling or maybe the franchisees are more interested in. For instance, are we looking at lower volume or lower And these restaurants that you're selling or the franchisees like kind of cleaner ones, anything that you can call out there? Speaker 200:34:03Mark, great question. There is some difference and you kind of see that reflected in the asset Purchase numbers that we've got in the queue, but it's not necessarily driven by the franchisees desire for A particular type of restaurant. A lot of it is geography, where are they, where do they want to develop, Where do they believe they understand the marketplace? In many cases, where do they have existing or previous businesses, because that's their comfort level. And that certainly has been the case with the refranchise deals that we've done so far. Speaker 200:34:42I'll tell you, we have had An increasing amount of interest in just direct development and for those that do contact us sometimes that are mostly focused on Those conversations don't go very far. There are a lot of QSR brands and other brands that are doing and have done refranchising where it truly is Kind of an EBITDA acquisition by the franchisee looking for growth so that they can increase value and resell the business at some point in the future. And those just don't tend to be very long conversations with us because we're a growth brand. And you see that in this RRG deal, 36 new units after buying 4. They would tell you they just love the idea of having a base of operations. Speaker 200:35:31Even 4 units for them was exciting. They have managers to start with. They have places where they can train as they build all these new units. They've got a running start in a market that they really love in Central Ohio. So they didn't need a large acquisition, but they didn't really Speaker 700:35:54Perfect. And then next question, As we look at the marketing brands on contribution, do you now have that kind of where you want it or do you Do you think there's opportunities for it to creep higher? And then maybe discuss benefits that you as well as your franchisees are seeing from that? Speaker 200:36:17Yes. I think we like where we are today. We reserve the right both publicly and with our franchisees Our expectation is and David's expectation leading marketing is that if we're going to put a dollar into incremental brand fund investment We'd like $3, $4,000,000 or $5 back on the top line. That's where we drive additional profitability. And in this world where we've got so many digital opportunities to invest that amount of money, today it's about 3%, that We have a chance to get the kind of returns that we're really pleased with. Speaker 200:36:56There will be natural plateaus in the media or in the The approach that you use or in the creative that you use and when you hit a plateau, then there's another investment And so I do expect that over the years, we'll continue to invest in more Of an industry standard of around 4%, some brands are spending upwards of 5%, but we're not in any rush to try to catch up That if we can't prove that we can get the returns. Franchisees have been very happy with our marketing investments because they're seeing that same top line growth that we've been seeing. Particularly when you look at the underlying indicators like we're talking about with Perks and digital and the digital mix and our ability To drive traffic, these are all things we think are rooted in the operations and how we're marketing that. So I think we're in a good place right now for now. Speaker 700:37:57Excellent. Thank you. Speaker 200:38:00Yes. Thanks, Mark. Operator00:38:03Thank you. The next question comes from Matt Curtis with William Blair. Please go ahead. Speaker 500:38:10Hi, good afternoon. I just wanted to get back to the pricing Discussion for a moment. And I ask how you view the value proposition right now following your most recent price increase? And if there's been any signs of consumer resistance so far. And then relatedly, I noticed on this last increase, You seem to have left pricing on Biggs unchanged, correct me if I'm wrong. Speaker 500:38:36So I was wondering what your thought process was around that? Speaker 300:38:41Sure. Let me just take the sort of consumer dynamic for one second. If you remember, when we talked about our pricing strategy for the year, we knew that based on the way we could see inflation evolving, we would be modest in our price increases And we have it. Our first action was 1.5, we had a 1.1 and the recent one was in a similar zone as those others. And That was deliberate. Speaker 300:39:06We got where we needed to be vis a vis inflation, which has come back to us. So that's been helpful. What we've seen as a benefit, I alluded to it in the answer to the earlier question is, it looks like some other Our competitors have continued to take some price and that may have benefited us in terms of relative value that we're providing To our customer base, as well our menu is fairly broad. So even though we might see some movement around From whether that's away from DSPs or whether that's from big sandwiches to others, We feel like we still create that kind of what you get for what you pay equation is working in our favor. And the best we can tell, Matt, from the data we see Relative to fast casual, our traffic continues to put us in a position where we're taking share. Speaker 300:40:00We're taking traffic share and we're doing it consistently week over week over week and have throughout the quarter. So, as Bob said, I think we're in a good spot as it relates to our demographic, in terms of their employment level, their savings that they still have left And they still like to come to Potbelly. So I think we feel pretty good about where we're headed here into the Q4. And then the second part of your question was related to kind of where we're taking pricing, where we're not taking price. We tend not to take pricing consistent places across the menu because we want to make sure that we're within Both psychological barriers, right, nines and zeros and those kinds of things we want to make sure as well we want to balance across channels. Speaker 300:40:47So sometimes we'll take a digital only price, Sometimes we'll take a size only price or sometimes we'll take a category only price. It really varies. And this last price increase, We may have hit Biggs a little bit less than we did others as we try to maintain that value across the menu for our consumers. Speaker 500:41:10Okay, understood. And then for the increased grant fund contribution, Which hit the other operating expenses line. Could you run us through what that spend has been specifically earmarked for? Speaker 200:41:26Yes. BrandFund is, I mean, it's marketing, right? So it's our media is 100% digital. It's delivered back to the shops in an equitable fashion. That's one of the reasons franchisees really appreciate How we manage the brand fund because they know that they get their contributions redeployed into their markets. Speaker 200:41:49But It's across the media channels. We've got paid social, we've got Digital, we've got I should say our web and our app advertising, we've got promotional activity and then promotional Activations that we do for every one of our new products that get rolled out, we've got Search engine optimization and the like, catering, advertising and so on. So it's across the spectrum What you would see in normal digital advertising for us. We have started to experiment with some media expansion in there too, because again, We know that we're even for what we're investing and what we're getting back, we know that there's more that we can continue to pour in. So we've got to do some experimentation along the way too. Speaker 500:42:45Okay, great. Thanks a lot guys and good luck the rest of the year. Speaker 300:42:49Yes. Thanks, Matt. Thanks, Matt. Operator00:42:52Thank you. The next question is a follow-up from Jeremy Hamblin with Craig Hallum Capital Group. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:43:01Thanks for taking the additional question. Just want to make sure on the for Q4, you've got a 14th week here. And just wanted to understand, I believe that that is kind of the holiday week post Christmas. And to understand what the typical sales volumes look like in that week and how we should be thinking about The impact of that week on some of these line items like occupancy and labor? Speaker 300:43:36Sure. I think there's probably a few things going on. Number 1, that week for us anyway Includes Christmas and it includes New Year's Eve. So it is going to be the way we would play it out a lower Volume week. So you can imagine how that starts to flow through the rest of the P and L. Speaker 300:44:02So we don't it ends up being about if we have a 7 day week, normally it ends up being about a 5.5 day week. I think as we try to think about The adjustment in our P and L, margins and so forth, I Speaker 600:44:27Got it. Thanks for taking the extra one. Speaker 200:44:30Yes, Jeremy, just a couple of specifics. One of the things that I think Steve and his team do really well as we look at something like this. We don't get a free week of occupancy. We would have Accrued or accounted for that with that 53rd week and spread that accordingly. And Same thing with any of the other fixed costs. Speaker 200:44:52So it puts a little sales pressure on there, but other than that, it's just It happens to us every 5 or 6 years, right? Yes. Speaker 300:45:03Got it. Thank you. Speaker 400:45:06Yes, you bet. Operator00:45:08Thank you. Ladies and gentlemen, we have reached the end of today's question and answer session. I would like to turn the call back over to Bob Wright for closing remarks. Speaker 200:45:19Thank you, operator, and thank you all again for your time this evening and for joining us. We appreciate the questions, the engagement and certainly look forward to talking again soon. Hope you all have a great night. Operator00:45:32The conference has now concluded. Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect yourRead morePowered by