NASDAQ:PFC Premier Financial Q4 2023 Earnings Report $28.04 0.00 (0.00%) As of 03/3/2025 Earnings HistoryForecast Premier Financial EPS ResultsActual EPS$0.56Consensus EPS $0.58Beat/MissMissed by -$0.02One Year Ago EPSN/APremier Financial Revenue ResultsActual Revenue$64.34 millionExpected Revenue$66.15 millionBeat/MissMissed by -$1.81 millionYoY Revenue GrowthN/APremier Financial Announcement DetailsQuarterQ4 2023Date1/23/2024TimeN/AConference Call DateWednesday, January 24, 2024Conference Call Time10:00AM ETUpcoming EarningsPremier Financial's Q1 2025 earnings is scheduled for Tuesday, April 22, 2025, with a conference call scheduled on Wednesday, April 23, 2025 at 10:00 AM ET. Check back for transcripts, audio, and key financial metrics as they become available.Conference Call ResourcesConference Call AudioConference Call TranscriptPress Release (8-K)Annual Report (10-K)Earnings HistoryCompany ProfilePowered by Premier Financial Q4 2023 Earnings Call TranscriptProvided by QuartrJanuary 24, 2024 ShareLink copied to clipboard.There are 7 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Good morning, and welcome to the Premier Financial Corp 4th Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in listen only mode. After today's presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Paul Nungstor with Premier Financial Corp. Operator00:00:31Please go ahead. Speaker 100:00:33Thank you. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us for today's Q4 2023 earnings conference call. This call is also being webcast and the audio replay will be available at the Premier Financial Corp. Website at premierfincorp.com. Following our prepared comments on the company's strategy and performance, we will be available to take your questions. Speaker 100:00:55Before we begin, to remind you that during the conference call today, including during the question and answer period, you may hear forward looking statements related to future financial results and business operations for Premier Financial Corp. Actual results may differ materially from current management forecasts and projections as a result of factors over which the company has no control. Information on these risk factors and additional information on forward looking statements are included in the news release in the company's reports on file with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll now turn the call over to Gary for his opening remarks. Speaker 200:01:32Thank you, Paul, and good morning to all for joining us. Per our release, 4th quarter earnings totaled $20,100,000 or $0.56 per share for the quarter. The results lagged our 3rd quarter performance as anticipated due to lower net interest margin and the seasonal impacts of our residential business as guided at the end of the Q3. However, the quarter did also include a couple of unanticipated Non recurring or timing items that would left the earnings for the quarter slightly below our expectations. And now I'll run down the particulars. Speaker 200:02:06First, a quick look at capital. As you noticed, our earnings combined with the favorable AOCI movement brings our tangible book value per share to 18.69 That's a really good strong progression over the last three quarters, which of course included the big pickup we had on the sale of our insurance operation, but evidence that we've got more upside there and we've made good progress during the year. Loan growth for the quarter totaled 2.5 percent on an annualized basis and that brings our full loan growth for the year to 4.3%. And that was in line with the expectations that we had for the year Coming off of a 20 plus percent growth year in 2022, we were designed to be a 4% shop this year. Annualized Commercial growth totaled 5.8% and for the full year, it grew 4.2%. Speaker 200:02:56Again, controlled growth was our mantra for 2023. Our consumer deposits annualized for the quarter grew at just shy of 8%. And when you combine 3rd quarter and 4th quarter figures, our annualized growth for those two quarters was 6.7%. That's a really strong number for us. Non interest bearing deposits also stabilized, delivering 2% annualized growth over that same period of Q3 and Q4 combined. Speaker 200:03:25It's a good positive trend for customer deposits over the second half of the year. Net interest margin did decrease 8 basis points from Q4 to Q3 and that was a bit more slippage than we provided in guidance on our last call, which was about 4% on our high 4 basis points on our high end expectation. We had a very effective new money deposit and household acquisition program that we initiated early in the quarter and it contributed to the decline. We have selected targeted markets across the organization for a bit more aggressive deposit gathering activity and it totals less than 10% of our locations. So we're happy with that particular outcome. Speaker 200:04:07The trade off was in the margin. Fee income stories for the quarter. Our wealth fee income increased 18% versus Q3 It really reflects as we all saw the strong finish we had in equity and fixed income markets at the end of the year and should carry forward into 2024. Mortgage banking income declined more than the typical seasonal decline anticipated for the quarter. Significant move in in 10 year treasury yields toward the end of December drove unfavorable valuation adjustments on the MSR asset and on our construction commitment hedges. Speaker 200:04:40We benefited from the same volatility when the tenure was rising in the Q3. So it's just one of those lumpy factors in our business. Expenses are right on the mark, just shy of $38,000,000 for the quarter. And on the credit front, our non performing assets declined 10% for the quarter. Delinquencies did tick up a bit in auto and residential real estate, but each remains within historical norms. Speaker 200:05:06Net charge offs for the quarter were driven by a single credit, 70% or so of the total. And on the full year basis, net charge offs still come in at 6 basis points and we're very pleased with that outcome. Our special mention rating category increased in Q4 and that was driven by a single relationship. For the year that brings 3 credits to the front that make up the lion's share of the increase in our special mention category. There's no central theme. Speaker 200:05:34Each is a unique industry. Each is still accruing and we have good expectations. They represent 2 C and I clients and 1 investment in multifamily real estate. The combination of those 2 created about a $0.05 to $0.06 reduction in the quarter relative to the additional provision that we set aside for those two items. Again, credit can be a bit lumpy. Speaker 200:06:01We're very pleased with our full year performance on that front, but worth a mention here in the Q4. And now I'll turn it over to Paul for some more performance details. Speaker 300:06:12Thank you, Gary. I'll start with Speaker 100:06:13the balance sheet where total deposits increased by point 4 percent point to point annualized for 4Q, primarily due to customer deposits, which increased 7.7% annualized. We continue to experience more mix migration during the quarter, including decreases in savings and demand deposits, which were more than offset by increases in our time and money market deposits. This customer has continued to seek higher yields. On the other side, total earning assets increased primarily as a result of commercial loan growth, was 5.8% annualized for 4Q. Our loan to deposit ratio improved by 50 basis points and we were able to reduce higher cost fundings by another $90,000,000 due to the combination of our strong customer deposit growth, but only modest earning asset growth. Speaker 100:06:59As a result of these balance sheet changes and deposit costs outpacing earning asset yields, we experienced some additional net interest margin compression for 4Q. Total interest bearing deposit costs increased 29 basis points to 2.83 percent for 4Q, which was driven mostly by growth in mix migration, while loan yields increased 9 basis points to 5.21%. Excluding the impact of PPP and Marks, Earning asset yields were 4.85% in December 2023 for an increase of 146 basis points since December 2021. This represents a cumulative beta of 28%, up from 26% in September compared to the 5 25 basis point increase the monthly average effective federal funds rate for the same period. Excluding marks, cost of funds were 2.38% in December 2023 or an increase of 217 basis points since December 2021, which represents a cumulative beta of 41%, up from 38% in September. Speaker 100:08:02Next non interest income decreased $1,500,000 to $11,800,000 in 4Q, primarily due to mortgage banking income, where gains declined $2,100,000 from last quarter as a result of lower margins and hedge losses related to the drop in 10 year treasury rates in late 4Q. This is partially offset by higher security gains, better wealth revenues and increased folding income, which did include $453,000 in claim gains. Expenses of $37,900,000 were down $200,000 or 2% annualized on a linked quarter basis. Through the combination of successful cost saving initiatives and the insurance agency sale, We reduced our expense run rate by 11% to $152,000,000 annualized from our original 2023 estimate of $170,000,000 We also improved our expense to average assets ratio by 30 basis points to 1.76% compared to the Q4 of 2022. Provision for the Q4 was an expense of $1,800,000 comprised of $2,100,000 expense for loans and a $400,000 benefit on a linked quarter decrease in unfunded commitments. Speaker 100:09:14Provision expense for loans was primarily due to $2,100,000 of net charge offs, which was mostly due to the one commercial credit. The allowance coverage ratio remained flat at 1.14% of loans. Close by mentioning our, continued improvements to capital, including book equity up 24% annualized, intangible equity up 37% annualized from 3Q. Our TE ratio has climbed back north of 8% and our regulatory ratios have further strengthened, including CET1 over 12% and total capital over 14%. These enhancements represent a solid foundation as we begin 2024. Speaker 100:09:53That completes my financial review and turn the call back to Gary. Thank you, Speaker 200:09:58Paul. 2023 has been an important year of change for Premier Bank. In addition to focusing on the inverted yield curve challenges that were presented to all, we successfully divested our insurance agency business significantly rightsized our residential mortgage business during the year. When combined with the completion of other significant projects across the organization, Premier is very well positioned to leverage on our anticipated margin and revenue growth going forward. As Paul mentioned, our expenses per earning asset ratio is 1.76, it's one of the best in the industry. Speaker 200:10:33With that in mind, I'll touch on some guidance topics for 2024. Earning asset growth, we've posted a range of 4%, continuing with our mantra of controlled growth over the next 12 months. Loan growth particularly would be 2 plus percent with commercial up about 3.5% and with lower yielding residential mortgage balances declining. Customer deposits would grow generally in the same range as our earning asset growth and we will expect to see a reduction to some degree in our wholesale funding for the year. Net interest margin, we modeled for 3 turns from the Fed beginning in May. Speaker 200:11:15From a midpoint range, Net interest growth would be in the 2%, that would be midpoint. Full year margin for 2023 would be similar to 23, but trending upward from Q1 forward. From a provision perspective, the model assumption is 10 basis points for net charge offs versus the 6 that we ran this year, Factors in loan growth and on ALLL, we would expect that unemployment information and so 4th would have us moving up our coverage ratio a couple of bps from where we closed out the year. From a fee income perspective, I'll just throw a number out there since so much noise in 'twenty three, it's hard to do percentages, but $48,000,000 range is the midpoint for fee income for 'twenty four. On a normalized basis for insurance and the other factors have changed, that's about a 6% plus increase over the prior year. Speaker 200:12:14Deposit related service fees are modest growth for the year about 3%. We have initiated limits on our merchant re presentment fees in 2024 and getting that behind us, doing so creates slightly more modest year over year change on consumer fee income. Residential mortgage revenue and wealth fees though are anticipated to be up 8% to 12%. Expenses Run rate wise, dollars 160,000,000 will cover it. That's up about 4.5% over our 3rd Q4 of 'twenty three run rate. Speaker 200:12:48And the expense is a bit front loaded as it is, I think, each year for most organizations with a little bit more cost that falls in compensation wise in Q1 and the seasonality that goes with the Q1. So $41,000,000 plus of costs in the first quarter with the rest of the $160,000,000 spread pretty evenly over the remaining $3,000,000 The earnings progression from the year, it looks like a bit of a hockey stick as you leave 23, from a trajectory standpoint, 1st quarter slightly down with all that typical cost and seasonality pacing and cubes 2 through 4 ever increasing. So with that, operator, I'd ask that we turn the open lines open for questions. Operator00:13:49We will now take our first question from Michael Petrico from KBW. Michael, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 300:14:00Hi. This is Mike's associate, Andrew, filling in. Thanks for taking my questions. Speaker 100:14:05Good morning. Good morning, Andrew. Speaker 300:14:08Good morning. I'd love to start on the margin. I appreciate all the color there with the guide. Just maybe A little bit more color kind of what the cadence expectation is there. So it kind of sounds like there's room for the margin to maybe bottom here in 1Q and then we'll get some throughout the rest of the year? Speaker 300:14:26And then maybe just some additional color on the drivers there around the margin. It sounds like deposit costs obviously came up here In the Q4 when you guys were pushing for that additional growth, should we expect that dynamic to kind of continue in the Q1 or maybe kind of level out from here? Speaker 100:14:46Yes, that's correct. You've got that correct there, Andrew. So, as we exit 23, December, having a little bit higher deposit costs versus the average for the quarter, but we do have our model shown that we will be bottoming out here in the Q1 as those conditions kind of stabilize and then grow from there, which is the key driver to the earnings trajectory that Gary just mentioned. Key drivers for the NIM at this point We'll be continuing success on the deposit front, both retention and some additional growth to help fund The modest earning asset growth that we have built in for 2024 and then the Fed actions. So as Gary mentioned, we've got 3 baked into our model, kind of mid quarter for the last three quarters of the year there with May, August, November. Speaker 100:15:46So we need the Fed to hopefully play along with that trajectory. And we've got A lot of plans being finalized and ready to go, so that as that begins to happen, we can start to recapture costs where possible on the deposit front, money markets and such, especially CDs will start to reprice down with it as well, lower terms on those in terms of locking in the maturities and things like that. So really we're putting all our plans in place here to be able to take advantage of rates starting to come our way on the short end there and that will support the NIM path and ultimately the earnings goals for the year. Speaker 300:16:37Awesome. And then second from me here, maybe just switching to capital for a second. I believe, correct me if I'm wrong, I think there's around 1,200,000 shares left on the authorization. Can you just kind of Speaker 100:16:51Give Speaker 300:16:51us a little bit of a reminder on thoughts around buybacks here and then maybe alternative uses of capital for 2024, Maybe M and A conversations, anything going on there? And then, also just strictly just for a wrap up here, how when does that authorization expire as well. I just couldn't find it off the top of my head. Speaker 200:17:17On the authorization, I don't know if we have an expiration date. Speaker 100:17:20Yes, the difference is the shares. Speaker 200:17:22Andrew, we'll get back with you if we find that we do have one, but Not typically the case. On the actual activity relative to M and A, what I would share is Similar to what I would have shared last quarter, there's a little bit more conversation as we can now see over the horizon and see positive marks coming our way to the portfolios over the next 4 to 8 quarters versus uncertain marks based on the Fed's activity over 23. Having said that, I really don't think that we'll see things in earnest change until the Fed has moved quite a bit And purchase accounting and predictability of capital and other impacts are have settled down a bit more. But I do feel a little more animal spirits in the marketplace relative to conversation and so forth and that would We include ourselves in those conversations, but I wouldn't say it's a meaningful change from the last time we had this discussion. Speaker 100:18:29Yes. And then I guess a little bit more, Andrew, your questions around the buybacks. It's always a tool that we have in our chest there that we Look at for the opportunity to enhance some earnings. The math is a little different these days with the new tax roles in that extra excise tax and needing to cover that to make it move the needle and things like that. As we've said on past calls, we weren't And you can see the numbers haven't been active on that front. Speaker 100:18:58Mainly we're focused on building capital. And now that the curve has moved in the right way to help that at least from a tangible equity perspective, That's something that we will look more at on a go forward basis and find our spots to possibly executed, if that makes sense. Speaker 200:19:22We have nothing cooked into the plan and that's typical with us because we'll take the opportunistic move when the market is right. And as Paul mentioned, we've got our capital where we like it. Right now, we're running at about midpoint Pure on capital, maybe Scotia Heavy in all our trajectory would say we'll be on a little bit over capitalized, if you will, as we go through the year. So it's the right topic and we'll address those opportunities as they come up. Speaker 300:19:54Great. Thank you. And then just if I can sneak one last one in here. I believe it was last quarter, you guys were talking a little bit about This small business banking platform, possibly seeing it in early 2024. I was just curious if you could provide any update there and Maybe just kind of a broad overview on what you're looking for with that project throughout the year? Speaker 200:20:18Andrew, we've curtailed the pace of expansion of that business as we finished out the 2023 and the first half of twenty twenty four, just in keeping with the more modest business acquisition mode that we're at. But we are still building the capabilities around the business. So if you looked at the back room as far as credit capability and underwriting and the uniqueness because with small business on that and adding some talent relative to being in the market in the smaller business space, That's still moving forward along with for our folks that are in the branch network, the continued development of their understanding and knowledge. But just the pacing, if it were 2 normal years would have been faster and we backed away just a little bit And that right now with the commercial book, the larger commercial clients that we're trying to serve are getting the priority relative to our capital and our deployed lending going forward. Speaker 300:21:27Great. Appreciate all the color and thanks for taking my questions guys. Speaker 100:21:32Thank you. Operator00:21:35We will now take our next question from Nick Churchill from Home Group. Nick, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 400:21:43Good morning, everyone. How are you? Speaker 100:21:45Good morning, Speaker 200:21:46Nick. Good morning, Nick. Good morning, Nick. Speaker 100:21:48Good morning, Nick. Speaker 400:21:50Thank you. On the loan growth front, it sounds like the expectation is another moderate year. Can you just give us some color on the overall lending environment? Is competition still fierce across your markets? And Is your anticipation that more forceful growth returns once the funding landscape normalizes? Speaker 200:22:08I'll start with the fierce competition. I think that the client base is appropriately moderating their expectations for this business out there, but folks are there's enough uncertainty in the economic environment right now and in the world in general, While their order board still look healthy, capital commitments and expansion commitments are probably more modest to be sure than in a normal year. So it's really a matter of it's a little bit more moderate supply. Having said that, we've all over the last year generally reduced our a little bit of our new client prospecting and so forth because we wanted to maintain the capital and the deployed dollars that we put out for existing clients. And I think that's just been more of the approach of the competition in the market as well. Speaker 200:23:07So we'll all probably get to a point where we're ready to go back into the market as we are, more so than we were in 2023, But each bank will be a bit different story on that. The market as a whole, there's business there. I would say on the investment real estate side, We still see business in multifamily, but it's pretty quiet outside the multifamily space right now. Our markets fortunately are not bubble markets, so it's not as if there's huge absorption issues or anything to be dealt with. And that's I think we're in an advantage over our peers on the coast in that regard. Speaker 400:23:50That's great color. And then just one last one for me. It sounds like a modest increase on the expense front for the year. How far along is the company in the past to 10,000,000,000 And what are the rough costs you expect to incur on that front in 2024? Speaker 100:24:03Yes, good question, Nick. We're still early days on that path. We did start incurring some of those costs last year in 2023, adjust the beginnings of it. And we do have in our plans for this year continuing to start to build that as we head towards that mark. With the modest growth we've got that's still a few years off, so we're not racing to get those costs in place Today, obviously, we'll bring it along as the growth in the overall organization can support it. Speaker 100:24:41From beginning to end, what we've estimated is that once we get to that point, It will have added about $7,000,000 or so in annual cost to our base. We've probably added on an annualized basis maybe $1,000,000 of that so far and we'll add some more here in 'twenty four and Just keep incrementally building towards that as we add the right talent to be here and Develop the programs needed for that 10,000,000,000 space, always working at our systems and Our control is in the name of it. So it's an incremental path there, Nick. Speaker 400:25:25Thank you for taking my questions. Speaker 100:25:27Thanks, Nick. Operator00:25:32We will now take our next question from Christopher Marinac from Janney Montgomery. Christopher, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 500:25:41Thanks. Good morning. I wanted to dive into the increase in criticized assets And just curious on if there's anything driving that and if there's a path that those may retreat from here? Speaker 200:25:53Chris, it's a good question. We did have movement in the last quarter as well. What I can say is relative to those, mostly, Well, for all three, it's cash flow versus capital requirement. They're missing a little bit on, say, the initial I need $120,000,000 coverage coming Cash flow wise, and they're slipping on that. Each has good capital support, good guarantors. Speaker 200:26:20It's just because they are missing on our originally underwritten marks, we class them into that space and expect them to work out accordingly. I don't think if we looked at the 3, I don't think any of them will be in a position in the next 6 months that we will be changing that movement. But things do move in and out and we just had a couple of larger credits that We're doing some expansion and their expansion has been taking a little bit longer versus the revenue expectations for one of the clients and the others got CapEx adjustments to make so that they can live within the cash flow that they're now generating. So just the typical adjustments we look at. And if you go back a couple of years, the numbers that we're looking at are not that abnormal. Speaker 200:27:09It's just got so good for us. We got so low that the movement was noticeable. And as I mentioned in the Q4, you feel that movement. When we move A reasonable sized credit into that space, we can feel it in our provision and so forth. But they also moved back to Past credits, for the most part, support and we don't anticipate anything different here. Speaker 200:27:333 different industries, No commonality in story and whatnot, just situations. Speaker 500:27:43No, that's very helpful. It sounds like the growth of reserves is modest and not really signaling any true change in loss content at the end of the day. Speaker 100:27:51That's our expectation. Speaker 500:27:55And then just a follow-up on kind of deposit pricing. You still seeing exceptional pricing out there? Or is that slowdown in again the progress on money markets that you talked about? It sounds like you have flexibility on pricing to some extent given the success in Q4. Speaker 200:28:11We do. We operate in 8 markets and The opportunities are different between the markets. There are markets where we've got 3 markets where we have extensive market share, and that means you've got repricing risk on a pretty good sized book to think about as well. We've got other markets where we have very minimal consumer market share. We have to do commercial and building our consumer. Speaker 200:28:34And we can be a little bit more aggressive there as we're trying to build more households and dollar balances in this environment. So I think to your original question, we still see promotional pricing. I think until the Fed turns, there's still a market expectation from a customer standpoint For those that are watching, right, it better start with a 4 or 5 or we'll be looking elsewhere. And until the Fed moves, we really won't see a huge dimension on that. Our commitment is to be very nimble when the change comes. Speaker 200:29:04We would not be inclined to be sitting around on a fatter pricing margin or yield thinking perhaps will collect additional deposits on the way down. I think we in some markets that will be the case. But for the most part, we will be hitching our wagon to the Fed move and moving as quickly as possible. Where we see things changing in the market and it's true for us as well on the CD front, duration. What was 11 or 12 months is now down to 8 for 7 months and you're starting to see 5s and 6s. Speaker 200:29:39A year ago, we would have said 5 months won't get the client off the couch. They'll pick the longer duration. I can see over the next couple of months, we're all squeezing down to those commitments are going to be more in the 6 month category so that we don't have so much lag time when the Fed does move on the repricing of that book. But there's still Still pricing pressure in the market to be fair. Speaker 100:30:03Yes. And same thing on the money markets. When we were running the promo, especially, Jeez, we started in the Q4 of 'twenty two really. And similar, we had some price guarantees for duration there. And those have been running off and we haven't been extending those, giving us that flexibility for when the time comes to cut, we can act that we haven't relocked it in for another 8 to 12 months or whatever the case is. Speaker 200:30:30That's an important distinction. We have the majority of our dollars flexible to us to move. Speaker 500:30:38Great. Thanks very much for taking the questions and thanks for all the information this morning. Speaker 100:30:43Thanks, Chris. Operator00:30:53We will now take our next question from David Long from Raymond James. David, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:31:02Good morning, guys. Speaker 100:31:04Good morning. Speaker 200:31:04Good morning, David. Speaker 600:31:06Just wanted to, yes, going to stick with the deposit side of things right now. You provided an outlook that included 3 cuts later this year. What with that, what is your expectation for the deposit data On the downside then? Speaker 100:31:25Good question. We haven't actually run that, Matt. We're still running off of the start. So I'll have to get back to you for sure on better specifics, David. But what I will say is that the way that the models run-in an RALM here is that even, while, the Fed is frozen right now and the cuts begin, there will still be pressure, Right. Speaker 100:31:54Like we were just talking about finding the opportunities and setting ourselves up to be able to reprice in the pockets where we have that opportunity, but CDs will take a while to still roll. Our money markets, we'll start moving on those, But we'll be doing it in the broader context of competition and things like that. So we actually expect that on a year over year basis, Our deposit costs could either be flattish or even up some ticks, but it would be on the right trend in the back half of the year there where we're still going to Speaker 200:32:36be up for Speaker 100:32:39The early part of 'twenty four, Q1, even into the Q2 until these cut start, right? And then we'll take actions and start to bring those down. But on a year over year basis, it will look like they're still potentially up. So we're going to be focused on the trends. And to your point of resetting that beta point for the down cycle here to show how much we're recapturing from that perspective. Speaker 200:33:07I know, Dave, when we looked at 24 versus 23 on margin and then broke it down into the 2 components, It was it's like how can that be so similar, but to remember where we were this time last year, rates were running up and running up a lot more and that's cooked into our base for 2023. We had some better margins. And so it is back to the trajectory that you would see as to where are we as we close out the year. And then we climb back at a much slower pace, 3 turns versus, Gosh, how many did we see coming back in the 1st 3 or 4 months of 2024. So it does kind of neutralize, but it's on a year over year average basis, but certainly Q3 and Q4 you see material difference. Speaker 200:33:54On the betas themselves, The most pedestrian thing I could say is if there's a 25 bps movement, we won't see a 25 bps movement, say in every category because I'll take CDs for example. We still have folks that took a 12 month CD last year and it's priced at 3 or something like that. They'll be looking for even though we're bringing rates down, they've got room to move up a bit. And so that will curve a little cream off the top relative to that move and all the more reason why you've got to be ready to move downward because there will still be upward pressure on certain parts of your book. Speaker 100:34:32Yes. And then to add to that, David, when you're looking at the total portfolio, we still have significant dollars at that low end, our savings and checking and non interest obviously where we never moved up. We didn't change our board rates. There was some mix migration, but those piles, They didn't go up and they're unlikely to come down in the down cycle. So really it's focusing on the piles that We priced up and then recapturing that on the way down and the velocity will depend on partly The Fed and how quick they move and then obviously the competitive environment where we feel good about being in a position where The focus will be more so on retention versus acquisition that we've done a good job, especially the second half of twenty twenty three Building that war chest per se, we've got it and now we need to retain that and then reprice the piles on the way down here. Speaker 100:35:33Dave, one Speaker 200:35:33of the things we learned that we probably knew instinctively, but the year for showed us is there's a large quantity or dollar level quantity of clients that are inelastic on pricing. And it's one of the and then of course there are those that aren't. And we're using every tool at our disposal to manage the movement, but We will work with that inelasticity to our advantage as we go through the year. Speaker 600:36:05No, that's some great color. So greatly appreciate that additional color. So As a follow-up then, it doesn't sound like if the Fed doesn't move and we stay higher for longer throughout the rest of the year, your NII guide doesn't sound like it changes That much from that 2% for the year, would it? Speaker 200:36:27I think that the Fed didn't do anything. I think We would have to come off of that number, Dave. It's adding, beginning with beyond just the normal repricing and so forth that we'll be doing here in the 1st 4 or 5 months. Once we cook in a turn, it's going in at May end of May, so you'd start picking it up in June, another turn in the next quarter, another turn late in the 4th kind of not much of an impact there, but it would be less than what we have in our expectation right now. Speaker 100:36:56Yes, David. We're still you'll see the numbers in our K when that comes out, but we're still in that liability sensitive position today, Not as much as we were, on call midpoint of 2023 there from all the actions that we've taken and our success in getting wholesale down and things like that. But still net net, we are liability sensitive. So if they don't cut, if it was flat for all of 24, Gary is right. We'd have to come off that and recast it. Speaker 100:37:26But it shouldn't be a material deviation because we're not as sensitive to it as we were. Speaker 200:37:33On the left side of the balance sheet, new money going out the door for loans is still going out with a high 7 or mid to mid-eight on it and we're sort of holding fast on that. When things got interesting there in December, clients' expectations thought Perhaps the market would move on that, but I think we've all held pretty firm that we're going to get paid for the risks in the market right now on the loan side. Speaker 600:38:01Got it. Thanks for taking my questions, guys. Speaker 100:38:03Appreciate it. Thank you. Operator00:38:09Thank you. We have no further questions registered. And with that, I will hand back to Gary Small for final remarks. Speaker 200:38:17Well, again, 2023, an interesting year that we'll all remember. 2024, although Certain aspects of it numerically may feel similar. As I said, we can see over the horizon now. We can see the direction of the Fed. It's not a matter of if, it's when and the pacing and so forth. Speaker 200:38:36For us, there's as much to be gained on, obviously, the recapture of margin coming out of that liability since than there is that will be growth driven. And there will be a time when 6%, 7% growth is back to how we make the needle move Over the next 4 to 8 quarters, I think it's much more margin recapture, manage your Ps and Qs on the expense side, do smart things on the fee business side and we run a clean book comp from a credit perspective. So, When we come out of that cycle 4 to 8 quarters going forward, we'll be more nimble, be a stronger organization, and really well leveraged to grow going forward. And thanks for all your time this morning. Appreciate it. Operator00:39:30Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect your line.Read morePowered by Conference Call Audio Live Call not available Earnings Conference CallPremier Financial Q4 202300:00 / 00:00Speed:1x1.25x1.5x2x Earnings DocumentsPress Release(8-K)Annual report(10-K) Premier Financial Earnings HeadlinesWesBanco, Inc. Completes Acquisition of Premier Financial Corp. and Appoints DirectorsFebruary 28, 2025 | prnewswire.comWesBanco, Premier merger gets regulatory nodFebruary 12, 2025 | msn.comTrump Orders 'National Digital Asset Stockpile'Trump's Tariff Pause Creates Crypto Gold Rush This opportunity could eclipse them all…April 18, 2025 | Crypto 101 Media (Ad)WesBanco, Inc. and Premier Financial Corp. Announce Regulatory Approvals for Pending MergerFebruary 12, 2025 | prnewswire.comPremier financial director Lanier sells $83,460 in sharesJanuary 28, 2025 | msn.comPremier Financial Corp. Reports Mixed 2024 ResultsJanuary 23, 2025 | tipranks.comSee More Premier Financial Headlines Get Earnings Announcements in your inboxWant to stay updated on the latest earnings announcements and upcoming reports for companies like Premier Financial? Sign up for Earnings360's daily newsletter to receive timely earnings updates on Premier Financial and other key companies, straight to your email. Email Address About Premier FinancialPremier Financial (NASDAQ:PFC), through its subsidiaries, provides various banking services. It offers demand, checking, money market, and savings accounts, as well as certificates of deposits and certificates of deposit account registry service; and investment products. The company also provides residential and commercial real estate, commercial, construction, home improvement and home equity, installment, and consumer loans. In addition, it invests in the U.S. treasury and federal government agency obligations, obligations of states and political subdivisions, mortgage-backed securities that are issued by federal agencies, residential collateralized mortgage obligations, and corporate bonds. Further, the company offers property and casualty, life, and group health insurance agency services; mezzanine funding services; and digital banking services, which include mobile banking, zelle, online bill pay, and online account opening, as well as the MoneyPass ATM network. It operates in Ohio, Michigan, Indiana, Pennsylvania, and West Virginia. The company was formerly known as First Defiance Financial Corp. and changed its name to Premier Financial Corp. in June 2020. Premier Financial Corp. was founded in 1920 and is headquartered in Defiance, Ohio.View Premier Financial ProfileRead more More Earnings Resources from MarketBeat Earnings Tools Today's Earnings Tomorrow's Earnings Next Week's Earnings Upcoming Earnings Calls Earnings Newsletter Earnings Call Transcripts Earnings Beats & Misses Corporate Guidance Earnings Screener Earnings By Country U.S. Earnings Reports Canadian Earnings Reports U.K. Earnings Reports Latest Articles Archer Aviation Unveils NYC Network Ahead of Key Earnings Report3 Reasons to Like the Look of Amazon Ahead of EarningsTesla Stock Eyes Breakout With Earnings on DeckJohnson & Johnson Earnings Were More Good Than Bad—Time to Buy? Why Analysts Boosted United Airlines Stock Ahead of EarningsLamb Weston Stock Rises, Earnings Provide Calm Amidst ChaosIntuitive Machines Gains After Earnings Beat, NASA Missions Ahead Upcoming Earnings Tesla (4/22/2025)Intuitive Surgical (4/22/2025)Verizon Communications (4/22/2025)Canadian National Railway (4/22/2025)Novartis (4/22/2025)RTX (4/22/2025)3M (4/22/2025)Capital One Financial (4/22/2025)General Electric (4/22/2025)Danaher (4/22/2025) Get 30 Days of MarketBeat All Access for Free Sign up for MarketBeat All Access to gain access to MarketBeat's full suite of research tools. Start Your 30-Day Trial MarketBeat All Access Features Best-in-Class Portfolio Monitoring Get personalized stock ideas. Compare portfolio to indices. Check stock news, ratings, SEC filings, and more. Stock Ideas and Recommendations See daily stock ideas from top analysts. Receive short-term trading ideas from MarketBeat. Identify trending stocks on social media. Advanced Stock Screeners and Research Tools Use our seven stock screeners to find suitable stocks. Stay informed with MarketBeat's real-time news. Export data to Excel for personal analysis. Sign in to your free account to enjoy these benefits In-depth profiles and analysis for 20,000 public companies. Real-time analyst ratings, insider transactions, earnings data, and more. Our daily ratings and market update email newsletter. Sign in to your free account to enjoy all that MarketBeat has to offer. Sign In Create Account Your Email Address: Email Address Required Your Password: Password Required Log In or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google Forgot your password? Your Email Address: Please enter your email address. Please enter a valid email address Choose a Password: Please enter your password. Your password must be at least 8 characters long and contain at least 1 number, 1 letter, and 1 special character. Create My Account (Free) or Sign in with Facebook Sign in with Google By creating a free account, you agree to our terms of service. This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.
There are 7 speakers on the call. Operator00:00:00Good morning, and welcome to the Premier Financial Corp 4th Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. All participants will be in listen only mode. After today's presentation, there will be an opportunity to ask questions. Please note this event is being recorded. I would now like to turn the conference over to Paul Nungstor with Premier Financial Corp. Operator00:00:31Please go ahead. Speaker 100:00:33Thank you. Good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us for today's Q4 2023 earnings conference call. This call is also being webcast and the audio replay will be available at the Premier Financial Corp. Website at premierfincorp.com. Following our prepared comments on the company's strategy and performance, we will be available to take your questions. Speaker 100:00:55Before we begin, to remind you that during the conference call today, including during the question and answer period, you may hear forward looking statements related to future financial results and business operations for Premier Financial Corp. Actual results may differ materially from current management forecasts and projections as a result of factors over which the company has no control. Information on these risk factors and additional information on forward looking statements are included in the news release in the company's reports on file with the Securities and Exchange Commission. I'll now turn the call over to Gary for his opening remarks. Speaker 200:01:32Thank you, Paul, and good morning to all for joining us. Per our release, 4th quarter earnings totaled $20,100,000 or $0.56 per share for the quarter. The results lagged our 3rd quarter performance as anticipated due to lower net interest margin and the seasonal impacts of our residential business as guided at the end of the Q3. However, the quarter did also include a couple of unanticipated Non recurring or timing items that would left the earnings for the quarter slightly below our expectations. And now I'll run down the particulars. Speaker 200:02:06First, a quick look at capital. As you noticed, our earnings combined with the favorable AOCI movement brings our tangible book value per share to 18.69 That's a really good strong progression over the last three quarters, which of course included the big pickup we had on the sale of our insurance operation, but evidence that we've got more upside there and we've made good progress during the year. Loan growth for the quarter totaled 2.5 percent on an annualized basis and that brings our full loan growth for the year to 4.3%. And that was in line with the expectations that we had for the year Coming off of a 20 plus percent growth year in 2022, we were designed to be a 4% shop this year. Annualized Commercial growth totaled 5.8% and for the full year, it grew 4.2%. Speaker 200:02:56Again, controlled growth was our mantra for 2023. Our consumer deposits annualized for the quarter grew at just shy of 8%. And when you combine 3rd quarter and 4th quarter figures, our annualized growth for those two quarters was 6.7%. That's a really strong number for us. Non interest bearing deposits also stabilized, delivering 2% annualized growth over that same period of Q3 and Q4 combined. Speaker 200:03:25It's a good positive trend for customer deposits over the second half of the year. Net interest margin did decrease 8 basis points from Q4 to Q3 and that was a bit more slippage than we provided in guidance on our last call, which was about 4% on our high 4 basis points on our high end expectation. We had a very effective new money deposit and household acquisition program that we initiated early in the quarter and it contributed to the decline. We have selected targeted markets across the organization for a bit more aggressive deposit gathering activity and it totals less than 10% of our locations. So we're happy with that particular outcome. Speaker 200:04:07The trade off was in the margin. Fee income stories for the quarter. Our wealth fee income increased 18% versus Q3 It really reflects as we all saw the strong finish we had in equity and fixed income markets at the end of the year and should carry forward into 2024. Mortgage banking income declined more than the typical seasonal decline anticipated for the quarter. Significant move in in 10 year treasury yields toward the end of December drove unfavorable valuation adjustments on the MSR asset and on our construction commitment hedges. Speaker 200:04:40We benefited from the same volatility when the tenure was rising in the Q3. So it's just one of those lumpy factors in our business. Expenses are right on the mark, just shy of $38,000,000 for the quarter. And on the credit front, our non performing assets declined 10% for the quarter. Delinquencies did tick up a bit in auto and residential real estate, but each remains within historical norms. Speaker 200:05:06Net charge offs for the quarter were driven by a single credit, 70% or so of the total. And on the full year basis, net charge offs still come in at 6 basis points and we're very pleased with that outcome. Our special mention rating category increased in Q4 and that was driven by a single relationship. For the year that brings 3 credits to the front that make up the lion's share of the increase in our special mention category. There's no central theme. Speaker 200:05:34Each is a unique industry. Each is still accruing and we have good expectations. They represent 2 C and I clients and 1 investment in multifamily real estate. The combination of those 2 created about a $0.05 to $0.06 reduction in the quarter relative to the additional provision that we set aside for those two items. Again, credit can be a bit lumpy. Speaker 200:06:01We're very pleased with our full year performance on that front, but worth a mention here in the Q4. And now I'll turn it over to Paul for some more performance details. Speaker 300:06:12Thank you, Gary. I'll start with Speaker 100:06:13the balance sheet where total deposits increased by point 4 percent point to point annualized for 4Q, primarily due to customer deposits, which increased 7.7% annualized. We continue to experience more mix migration during the quarter, including decreases in savings and demand deposits, which were more than offset by increases in our time and money market deposits. This customer has continued to seek higher yields. On the other side, total earning assets increased primarily as a result of commercial loan growth, was 5.8% annualized for 4Q. Our loan to deposit ratio improved by 50 basis points and we were able to reduce higher cost fundings by another $90,000,000 due to the combination of our strong customer deposit growth, but only modest earning asset growth. Speaker 100:06:59As a result of these balance sheet changes and deposit costs outpacing earning asset yields, we experienced some additional net interest margin compression for 4Q. Total interest bearing deposit costs increased 29 basis points to 2.83 percent for 4Q, which was driven mostly by growth in mix migration, while loan yields increased 9 basis points to 5.21%. Excluding the impact of PPP and Marks, Earning asset yields were 4.85% in December 2023 for an increase of 146 basis points since December 2021. This represents a cumulative beta of 28%, up from 26% in September compared to the 5 25 basis point increase the monthly average effective federal funds rate for the same period. Excluding marks, cost of funds were 2.38% in December 2023 or an increase of 217 basis points since December 2021, which represents a cumulative beta of 41%, up from 38% in September. Speaker 100:08:02Next non interest income decreased $1,500,000 to $11,800,000 in 4Q, primarily due to mortgage banking income, where gains declined $2,100,000 from last quarter as a result of lower margins and hedge losses related to the drop in 10 year treasury rates in late 4Q. This is partially offset by higher security gains, better wealth revenues and increased folding income, which did include $453,000 in claim gains. Expenses of $37,900,000 were down $200,000 or 2% annualized on a linked quarter basis. Through the combination of successful cost saving initiatives and the insurance agency sale, We reduced our expense run rate by 11% to $152,000,000 annualized from our original 2023 estimate of $170,000,000 We also improved our expense to average assets ratio by 30 basis points to 1.76% compared to the Q4 of 2022. Provision for the Q4 was an expense of $1,800,000 comprised of $2,100,000 expense for loans and a $400,000 benefit on a linked quarter decrease in unfunded commitments. Speaker 100:09:14Provision expense for loans was primarily due to $2,100,000 of net charge offs, which was mostly due to the one commercial credit. The allowance coverage ratio remained flat at 1.14% of loans. Close by mentioning our, continued improvements to capital, including book equity up 24% annualized, intangible equity up 37% annualized from 3Q. Our TE ratio has climbed back north of 8% and our regulatory ratios have further strengthened, including CET1 over 12% and total capital over 14%. These enhancements represent a solid foundation as we begin 2024. Speaker 100:09:53That completes my financial review and turn the call back to Gary. Thank you, Speaker 200:09:58Paul. 2023 has been an important year of change for Premier Bank. In addition to focusing on the inverted yield curve challenges that were presented to all, we successfully divested our insurance agency business significantly rightsized our residential mortgage business during the year. When combined with the completion of other significant projects across the organization, Premier is very well positioned to leverage on our anticipated margin and revenue growth going forward. As Paul mentioned, our expenses per earning asset ratio is 1.76, it's one of the best in the industry. Speaker 200:10:33With that in mind, I'll touch on some guidance topics for 2024. Earning asset growth, we've posted a range of 4%, continuing with our mantra of controlled growth over the next 12 months. Loan growth particularly would be 2 plus percent with commercial up about 3.5% and with lower yielding residential mortgage balances declining. Customer deposits would grow generally in the same range as our earning asset growth and we will expect to see a reduction to some degree in our wholesale funding for the year. Net interest margin, we modeled for 3 turns from the Fed beginning in May. Speaker 200:11:15From a midpoint range, Net interest growth would be in the 2%, that would be midpoint. Full year margin for 2023 would be similar to 23, but trending upward from Q1 forward. From a provision perspective, the model assumption is 10 basis points for net charge offs versus the 6 that we ran this year, Factors in loan growth and on ALLL, we would expect that unemployment information and so 4th would have us moving up our coverage ratio a couple of bps from where we closed out the year. From a fee income perspective, I'll just throw a number out there since so much noise in 'twenty three, it's hard to do percentages, but $48,000,000 range is the midpoint for fee income for 'twenty four. On a normalized basis for insurance and the other factors have changed, that's about a 6% plus increase over the prior year. Speaker 200:12:14Deposit related service fees are modest growth for the year about 3%. We have initiated limits on our merchant re presentment fees in 2024 and getting that behind us, doing so creates slightly more modest year over year change on consumer fee income. Residential mortgage revenue and wealth fees though are anticipated to be up 8% to 12%. Expenses Run rate wise, dollars 160,000,000 will cover it. That's up about 4.5% over our 3rd Q4 of 'twenty three run rate. Speaker 200:12:48And the expense is a bit front loaded as it is, I think, each year for most organizations with a little bit more cost that falls in compensation wise in Q1 and the seasonality that goes with the Q1. So $41,000,000 plus of costs in the first quarter with the rest of the $160,000,000 spread pretty evenly over the remaining $3,000,000 The earnings progression from the year, it looks like a bit of a hockey stick as you leave 23, from a trajectory standpoint, 1st quarter slightly down with all that typical cost and seasonality pacing and cubes 2 through 4 ever increasing. So with that, operator, I'd ask that we turn the open lines open for questions. Operator00:13:49We will now take our first question from Michael Petrico from KBW. Michael, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 300:14:00Hi. This is Mike's associate, Andrew, filling in. Thanks for taking my questions. Speaker 100:14:05Good morning. Good morning, Andrew. Speaker 300:14:08Good morning. I'd love to start on the margin. I appreciate all the color there with the guide. Just maybe A little bit more color kind of what the cadence expectation is there. So it kind of sounds like there's room for the margin to maybe bottom here in 1Q and then we'll get some throughout the rest of the year? Speaker 300:14:26And then maybe just some additional color on the drivers there around the margin. It sounds like deposit costs obviously came up here In the Q4 when you guys were pushing for that additional growth, should we expect that dynamic to kind of continue in the Q1 or maybe kind of level out from here? Speaker 100:14:46Yes, that's correct. You've got that correct there, Andrew. So, as we exit 23, December, having a little bit higher deposit costs versus the average for the quarter, but we do have our model shown that we will be bottoming out here in the Q1 as those conditions kind of stabilize and then grow from there, which is the key driver to the earnings trajectory that Gary just mentioned. Key drivers for the NIM at this point We'll be continuing success on the deposit front, both retention and some additional growth to help fund The modest earning asset growth that we have built in for 2024 and then the Fed actions. So as Gary mentioned, we've got 3 baked into our model, kind of mid quarter for the last three quarters of the year there with May, August, November. Speaker 100:15:46So we need the Fed to hopefully play along with that trajectory. And we've got A lot of plans being finalized and ready to go, so that as that begins to happen, we can start to recapture costs where possible on the deposit front, money markets and such, especially CDs will start to reprice down with it as well, lower terms on those in terms of locking in the maturities and things like that. So really we're putting all our plans in place here to be able to take advantage of rates starting to come our way on the short end there and that will support the NIM path and ultimately the earnings goals for the year. Speaker 300:16:37Awesome. And then second from me here, maybe just switching to capital for a second. I believe, correct me if I'm wrong, I think there's around 1,200,000 shares left on the authorization. Can you just kind of Speaker 100:16:51Give Speaker 300:16:51us a little bit of a reminder on thoughts around buybacks here and then maybe alternative uses of capital for 2024, Maybe M and A conversations, anything going on there? And then, also just strictly just for a wrap up here, how when does that authorization expire as well. I just couldn't find it off the top of my head. Speaker 200:17:17On the authorization, I don't know if we have an expiration date. Speaker 100:17:20Yes, the difference is the shares. Speaker 200:17:22Andrew, we'll get back with you if we find that we do have one, but Not typically the case. On the actual activity relative to M and A, what I would share is Similar to what I would have shared last quarter, there's a little bit more conversation as we can now see over the horizon and see positive marks coming our way to the portfolios over the next 4 to 8 quarters versus uncertain marks based on the Fed's activity over 23. Having said that, I really don't think that we'll see things in earnest change until the Fed has moved quite a bit And purchase accounting and predictability of capital and other impacts are have settled down a bit more. But I do feel a little more animal spirits in the marketplace relative to conversation and so forth and that would We include ourselves in those conversations, but I wouldn't say it's a meaningful change from the last time we had this discussion. Speaker 100:18:29Yes. And then I guess a little bit more, Andrew, your questions around the buybacks. It's always a tool that we have in our chest there that we Look at for the opportunity to enhance some earnings. The math is a little different these days with the new tax roles in that extra excise tax and needing to cover that to make it move the needle and things like that. As we've said on past calls, we weren't And you can see the numbers haven't been active on that front. Speaker 100:18:58Mainly we're focused on building capital. And now that the curve has moved in the right way to help that at least from a tangible equity perspective, That's something that we will look more at on a go forward basis and find our spots to possibly executed, if that makes sense. Speaker 200:19:22We have nothing cooked into the plan and that's typical with us because we'll take the opportunistic move when the market is right. And as Paul mentioned, we've got our capital where we like it. Right now, we're running at about midpoint Pure on capital, maybe Scotia Heavy in all our trajectory would say we'll be on a little bit over capitalized, if you will, as we go through the year. So it's the right topic and we'll address those opportunities as they come up. Speaker 300:19:54Great. Thank you. And then just if I can sneak one last one in here. I believe it was last quarter, you guys were talking a little bit about This small business banking platform, possibly seeing it in early 2024. I was just curious if you could provide any update there and Maybe just kind of a broad overview on what you're looking for with that project throughout the year? Speaker 200:20:18Andrew, we've curtailed the pace of expansion of that business as we finished out the 2023 and the first half of twenty twenty four, just in keeping with the more modest business acquisition mode that we're at. But we are still building the capabilities around the business. So if you looked at the back room as far as credit capability and underwriting and the uniqueness because with small business on that and adding some talent relative to being in the market in the smaller business space, That's still moving forward along with for our folks that are in the branch network, the continued development of their understanding and knowledge. But just the pacing, if it were 2 normal years would have been faster and we backed away just a little bit And that right now with the commercial book, the larger commercial clients that we're trying to serve are getting the priority relative to our capital and our deployed lending going forward. Speaker 300:21:27Great. Appreciate all the color and thanks for taking my questions guys. Speaker 100:21:32Thank you. Operator00:21:35We will now take our next question from Nick Churchill from Home Group. Nick, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 400:21:43Good morning, everyone. How are you? Speaker 100:21:45Good morning, Speaker 200:21:46Nick. Good morning, Nick. Good morning, Nick. Speaker 100:21:48Good morning, Nick. Speaker 400:21:50Thank you. On the loan growth front, it sounds like the expectation is another moderate year. Can you just give us some color on the overall lending environment? Is competition still fierce across your markets? And Is your anticipation that more forceful growth returns once the funding landscape normalizes? Speaker 200:22:08I'll start with the fierce competition. I think that the client base is appropriately moderating their expectations for this business out there, but folks are there's enough uncertainty in the economic environment right now and in the world in general, While their order board still look healthy, capital commitments and expansion commitments are probably more modest to be sure than in a normal year. So it's really a matter of it's a little bit more moderate supply. Having said that, we've all over the last year generally reduced our a little bit of our new client prospecting and so forth because we wanted to maintain the capital and the deployed dollars that we put out for existing clients. And I think that's just been more of the approach of the competition in the market as well. Speaker 200:23:07So we'll all probably get to a point where we're ready to go back into the market as we are, more so than we were in 2023, But each bank will be a bit different story on that. The market as a whole, there's business there. I would say on the investment real estate side, We still see business in multifamily, but it's pretty quiet outside the multifamily space right now. Our markets fortunately are not bubble markets, so it's not as if there's huge absorption issues or anything to be dealt with. And that's I think we're in an advantage over our peers on the coast in that regard. Speaker 400:23:50That's great color. And then just one last one for me. It sounds like a modest increase on the expense front for the year. How far along is the company in the past to 10,000,000,000 And what are the rough costs you expect to incur on that front in 2024? Speaker 100:24:03Yes, good question, Nick. We're still early days on that path. We did start incurring some of those costs last year in 2023, adjust the beginnings of it. And we do have in our plans for this year continuing to start to build that as we head towards that mark. With the modest growth we've got that's still a few years off, so we're not racing to get those costs in place Today, obviously, we'll bring it along as the growth in the overall organization can support it. Speaker 100:24:41From beginning to end, what we've estimated is that once we get to that point, It will have added about $7,000,000 or so in annual cost to our base. We've probably added on an annualized basis maybe $1,000,000 of that so far and we'll add some more here in 'twenty four and Just keep incrementally building towards that as we add the right talent to be here and Develop the programs needed for that 10,000,000,000 space, always working at our systems and Our control is in the name of it. So it's an incremental path there, Nick. Speaker 400:25:25Thank you for taking my questions. Speaker 100:25:27Thanks, Nick. Operator00:25:32We will now take our next question from Christopher Marinac from Janney Montgomery. Christopher, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 500:25:41Thanks. Good morning. I wanted to dive into the increase in criticized assets And just curious on if there's anything driving that and if there's a path that those may retreat from here? Speaker 200:25:53Chris, it's a good question. We did have movement in the last quarter as well. What I can say is relative to those, mostly, Well, for all three, it's cash flow versus capital requirement. They're missing a little bit on, say, the initial I need $120,000,000 coverage coming Cash flow wise, and they're slipping on that. Each has good capital support, good guarantors. Speaker 200:26:20It's just because they are missing on our originally underwritten marks, we class them into that space and expect them to work out accordingly. I don't think if we looked at the 3, I don't think any of them will be in a position in the next 6 months that we will be changing that movement. But things do move in and out and we just had a couple of larger credits that We're doing some expansion and their expansion has been taking a little bit longer versus the revenue expectations for one of the clients and the others got CapEx adjustments to make so that they can live within the cash flow that they're now generating. So just the typical adjustments we look at. And if you go back a couple of years, the numbers that we're looking at are not that abnormal. Speaker 200:27:09It's just got so good for us. We got so low that the movement was noticeable. And as I mentioned in the Q4, you feel that movement. When we move A reasonable sized credit into that space, we can feel it in our provision and so forth. But they also moved back to Past credits, for the most part, support and we don't anticipate anything different here. Speaker 200:27:333 different industries, No commonality in story and whatnot, just situations. Speaker 500:27:43No, that's very helpful. It sounds like the growth of reserves is modest and not really signaling any true change in loss content at the end of the day. Speaker 100:27:51That's our expectation. Speaker 500:27:55And then just a follow-up on kind of deposit pricing. You still seeing exceptional pricing out there? Or is that slowdown in again the progress on money markets that you talked about? It sounds like you have flexibility on pricing to some extent given the success in Q4. Speaker 200:28:11We do. We operate in 8 markets and The opportunities are different between the markets. There are markets where we've got 3 markets where we have extensive market share, and that means you've got repricing risk on a pretty good sized book to think about as well. We've got other markets where we have very minimal consumer market share. We have to do commercial and building our consumer. Speaker 200:28:34And we can be a little bit more aggressive there as we're trying to build more households and dollar balances in this environment. So I think to your original question, we still see promotional pricing. I think until the Fed turns, there's still a market expectation from a customer standpoint For those that are watching, right, it better start with a 4 or 5 or we'll be looking elsewhere. And until the Fed moves, we really won't see a huge dimension on that. Our commitment is to be very nimble when the change comes. Speaker 200:29:04We would not be inclined to be sitting around on a fatter pricing margin or yield thinking perhaps will collect additional deposits on the way down. I think we in some markets that will be the case. But for the most part, we will be hitching our wagon to the Fed move and moving as quickly as possible. Where we see things changing in the market and it's true for us as well on the CD front, duration. What was 11 or 12 months is now down to 8 for 7 months and you're starting to see 5s and 6s. Speaker 200:29:39A year ago, we would have said 5 months won't get the client off the couch. They'll pick the longer duration. I can see over the next couple of months, we're all squeezing down to those commitments are going to be more in the 6 month category so that we don't have so much lag time when the Fed does move on the repricing of that book. But there's still Still pricing pressure in the market to be fair. Speaker 100:30:03Yes. And same thing on the money markets. When we were running the promo, especially, Jeez, we started in the Q4 of 'twenty two really. And similar, we had some price guarantees for duration there. And those have been running off and we haven't been extending those, giving us that flexibility for when the time comes to cut, we can act that we haven't relocked it in for another 8 to 12 months or whatever the case is. Speaker 200:30:30That's an important distinction. We have the majority of our dollars flexible to us to move. Speaker 500:30:38Great. Thanks very much for taking the questions and thanks for all the information this morning. Speaker 100:30:43Thanks, Chris. Operator00:30:53We will now take our next question from David Long from Raymond James. David, your line is now open. Please go ahead. Speaker 600:31:02Good morning, guys. Speaker 100:31:04Good morning. Speaker 200:31:04Good morning, David. Speaker 600:31:06Just wanted to, yes, going to stick with the deposit side of things right now. You provided an outlook that included 3 cuts later this year. What with that, what is your expectation for the deposit data On the downside then? Speaker 100:31:25Good question. We haven't actually run that, Matt. We're still running off of the start. So I'll have to get back to you for sure on better specifics, David. But what I will say is that the way that the models run-in an RALM here is that even, while, the Fed is frozen right now and the cuts begin, there will still be pressure, Right. Speaker 100:31:54Like we were just talking about finding the opportunities and setting ourselves up to be able to reprice in the pockets where we have that opportunity, but CDs will take a while to still roll. Our money markets, we'll start moving on those, But we'll be doing it in the broader context of competition and things like that. So we actually expect that on a year over year basis, Our deposit costs could either be flattish or even up some ticks, but it would be on the right trend in the back half of the year there where we're still going to Speaker 200:32:36be up for Speaker 100:32:39The early part of 'twenty four, Q1, even into the Q2 until these cut start, right? And then we'll take actions and start to bring those down. But on a year over year basis, it will look like they're still potentially up. So we're going to be focused on the trends. And to your point of resetting that beta point for the down cycle here to show how much we're recapturing from that perspective. Speaker 200:33:07I know, Dave, when we looked at 24 versus 23 on margin and then broke it down into the 2 components, It was it's like how can that be so similar, but to remember where we were this time last year, rates were running up and running up a lot more and that's cooked into our base for 2023. We had some better margins. And so it is back to the trajectory that you would see as to where are we as we close out the year. And then we climb back at a much slower pace, 3 turns versus, Gosh, how many did we see coming back in the 1st 3 or 4 months of 2024. So it does kind of neutralize, but it's on a year over year average basis, but certainly Q3 and Q4 you see material difference. Speaker 200:33:54On the betas themselves, The most pedestrian thing I could say is if there's a 25 bps movement, we won't see a 25 bps movement, say in every category because I'll take CDs for example. We still have folks that took a 12 month CD last year and it's priced at 3 or something like that. They'll be looking for even though we're bringing rates down, they've got room to move up a bit. And so that will curve a little cream off the top relative to that move and all the more reason why you've got to be ready to move downward because there will still be upward pressure on certain parts of your book. Speaker 100:34:32Yes. And then to add to that, David, when you're looking at the total portfolio, we still have significant dollars at that low end, our savings and checking and non interest obviously where we never moved up. We didn't change our board rates. There was some mix migration, but those piles, They didn't go up and they're unlikely to come down in the down cycle. So really it's focusing on the piles that We priced up and then recapturing that on the way down and the velocity will depend on partly The Fed and how quick they move and then obviously the competitive environment where we feel good about being in a position where The focus will be more so on retention versus acquisition that we've done a good job, especially the second half of twenty twenty three Building that war chest per se, we've got it and now we need to retain that and then reprice the piles on the way down here. Speaker 100:35:33Dave, one Speaker 200:35:33of the things we learned that we probably knew instinctively, but the year for showed us is there's a large quantity or dollar level quantity of clients that are inelastic on pricing. And it's one of the and then of course there are those that aren't. And we're using every tool at our disposal to manage the movement, but We will work with that inelasticity to our advantage as we go through the year. Speaker 600:36:05No, that's some great color. So greatly appreciate that additional color. So As a follow-up then, it doesn't sound like if the Fed doesn't move and we stay higher for longer throughout the rest of the year, your NII guide doesn't sound like it changes That much from that 2% for the year, would it? Speaker 200:36:27I think that the Fed didn't do anything. I think We would have to come off of that number, Dave. It's adding, beginning with beyond just the normal repricing and so forth that we'll be doing here in the 1st 4 or 5 months. Once we cook in a turn, it's going in at May end of May, so you'd start picking it up in June, another turn in the next quarter, another turn late in the 4th kind of not much of an impact there, but it would be less than what we have in our expectation right now. Speaker 100:36:56Yes, David. We're still you'll see the numbers in our K when that comes out, but we're still in that liability sensitive position today, Not as much as we were, on call midpoint of 2023 there from all the actions that we've taken and our success in getting wholesale down and things like that. But still net net, we are liability sensitive. So if they don't cut, if it was flat for all of 24, Gary is right. We'd have to come off that and recast it. Speaker 100:37:26But it shouldn't be a material deviation because we're not as sensitive to it as we were. Speaker 200:37:33On the left side of the balance sheet, new money going out the door for loans is still going out with a high 7 or mid to mid-eight on it and we're sort of holding fast on that. When things got interesting there in December, clients' expectations thought Perhaps the market would move on that, but I think we've all held pretty firm that we're going to get paid for the risks in the market right now on the loan side. Speaker 600:38:01Got it. Thanks for taking my questions, guys. Speaker 100:38:03Appreciate it. Thank you. Operator00:38:09Thank you. We have no further questions registered. And with that, I will hand back to Gary Small for final remarks. Speaker 200:38:17Well, again, 2023, an interesting year that we'll all remember. 2024, although Certain aspects of it numerically may feel similar. As I said, we can see over the horizon now. We can see the direction of the Fed. It's not a matter of if, it's when and the pacing and so forth. Speaker 200:38:36For us, there's as much to be gained on, obviously, the recapture of margin coming out of that liability since than there is that will be growth driven. And there will be a time when 6%, 7% growth is back to how we make the needle move Over the next 4 to 8 quarters, I think it's much more margin recapture, manage your Ps and Qs on the expense side, do smart things on the fee business side and we run a clean book comp from a credit perspective. So, When we come out of that cycle 4 to 8 quarters going forward, we'll be more nimble, be a stronger organization, and really well leveraged to grow going forward. And thanks for all your time this morning. Appreciate it. Operator00:39:30Thank you for your participation. You may now disconnect your line.Read morePowered by