Papa Johns International Q3 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

Quartr
Provided by Quartr
October 24, 2024

There are 12 speakers on the call.

Operator

Thank you for standing by. This is the conference operator. Welcome to the Rogers Communications, Inc. 3rd Quarter 2024 Results Conference Call. As a reminder, all participants are in a listen only mode and the conference is being recorded.

Operator

Following the presentation, we will conduct a question and answer session. I would now like to turn the conference over to Paul Carpino, Vice President of Investor Relations with Rogers Communications. Please go ahead, Mr. Carpino.

Speaker 1

Thank you, Gayleen, and good morning, everyone, and thank you for joining us today. I'm here with our President and Chief Executive Officer, Tony Staffieri and our Chief Financial Officer, Glen Brandt. During our Q and A, I'd ask you to limit yourself to one question and a quick follow-up, if needed. Today's discussion will include estimates and other forward looking information from which our actual results could differ. Please review the cautionary language in today's earnings report, MD and A and in our 2023 Annual Report regarding the various factors, assumptions and risks that could cause our actual results to differ.

Speaker 1

With that, let me turn it over to Tony to begin.

Speaker 2

Thank you, Paul, and good morning, everyone. I'm very pleased to report that Rogers delivered another strong quarter of results. For 11 consecutive quarters, we have delivered industry leading results driven by disciplined execution in a healthy and competitive market. We once again reported industry leading market share in wireless, industry leading margins in wireless and cable and strong profitability in media. And we continue to invest in the future growth of our 3 core businesses.

Speaker 2

And we made significant progress in strengthening our balance sheet. As you saw this morning, we announced the transaction with a leading global financial investor to provide an innovative $7,000,000,000 structured equity financing. The proceeds will be used to pay down debt and as a result, we now expect our debt leverage ratio to reach 3.7 times by year end. This is well ahead of our 4.2 times target we previously communicated and it will accelerate our Shaw deleveraging plans by a full 12 months. This structured financing transaction is the first of its kind in Canada and demonstrates our innovative approach to maintaining an investment grade balance sheet while investing in growth.

Speaker 2

Closing is subject to the finalization of definitive agreements and is expected to happen in the Q4. Let me now turn to our Q3 results. This quarter, we added a record 200 and 27,000 mobile phone and Internet net additions. And over the past 11 quarters, we have added 1,900,000 mobile phone and Internet net additions. It's clear our strategy is working and our team is executing with discipline.

Speaker 2

More Canadians continue to choose Rogers more than any other provider in Canada. I'm proud of our team and the efforts their efforts to compete in a healthy and competitive marketplace. Wireless postpaid mobile phone net additions were 101,000 and prepaid net adds were 93,000. The market was competitive during the seasonally busy back to school period and we effectively used our chatter brand to gain customers in the new to Canada market. We remain focused on ensuring a clear delineation between our premium 5 gs brand and our successful prepaid Chatter brand.

Speaker 2

We have been executing on our brand differentiation strategy for almost 2 years now, and it's been highly effective in delivering strong results. Cable loading was also strong in the Q3. We delivered retail Internet net additions of 33,000, up 15,000 or 83% from last year. This brings our year to date retail Internet net additions to 85,000, a 50% increase from 1 year ago. Our expanded footprint and diversified Internet product offering are driving this growth.

Speaker 2

By choosing Rogers, customers can select the products and plans that best meet their needs delivered seamlessly through our network capabilities, whether it's direct fiber, fiber coax, 5 gs wireless home Internet or wholesale TPIA. Our strong wireless and cable loading is underpinned by our networks. In the Q3, 2 global leaders in network benchmarking reaffirmed our network leadership position. Oumlak once again awarded Rogers Canada's most reliable 5 gs network. In a separate benchmarking study, OpenSignal recognized Rogers for delivering the most reliable wireless services in Canada.

Speaker 2

OpenSignal also awarded Rogers as Canada's fastest and most reliable Internet. The report found we consistently deliver the most reliable experience, the fastest overall download speeds and the best streaming experience in Canada. Our customers have told us reliability is what matters most to them and we're outperforming our competitors on this key metric. We're also advancing our DOCSIS roadmap. This quarter, we successfully trialed DOCSIS 4 modem technology with 4 gigabit download and 1 gigabit upload speeds.

Speaker 2

This is a global first and we just hit another milestone. We have started Comcast XER modem, the most advanced Wi Fi 7 and 10 gs capable router in Canada. And Rogers satellite to mobile partner SpaceX just completed a global first, a successful real world test with T Mobile of their Starlink low earth orbit direct to cell constellation during hurricanes Helene and Milton. SpaceX also enabled and tested emergency alerts via satellite to mobile phones in affected areas. With over 300 LEO satellites in service, the technology was able to support thousands of residents with messaging service.

Speaker 2

As we previously announced, we are bringing the same industry leading technology to Canadians. From a financial perspective, our growth, strong execution and continued efficiency gains are delivering industry leading financial performance and the industry best margins. In fact, we've set a new benchmark at Rogers with our best ever cable and wireless margins. Wireless service revenue was up 2% and adjusted EBITDA was up 5%. We delivered wireless margins of 66% and blended ARPU remained stable.

Speaker 2

In cable, we remain on track to return to growth in the Q4. In Q3, cable revenue improved sequentially to a decline of 1%. So we're seeing steady progress here towards our return to growth in the Q4. With the improvements in cable revenue, adjusted EBITDA was strong, up 5% and our team delivered industry leading margins of 58%. Our Sports and Media business also had a strong quarter.

Speaker 2

We showed strong growth and profitability with revenue growth of 11% and adjusted EBITDA was up a healthy 25%. As Canada's communications and entertainment company, live sports and entertainment are core to our business strategy. In the 3rd quarter, we signed a strategic agreement to buy Bell's 37.5 percent ownership stake in Maple Leaf Sports and Entertainment. It's a significant step in our long term plan to surface value more value for our shareholders. So overall, all three businesses are executing very well and we have clearly and significantly advanced our balance sheet, delivering well ahead of plan.

Speaker 2

Before I hand over things to Glenn, I want to thank our team for delivering strong results and disciplined execution in a competitive and healthy market. We've delivered 11 straight quarters of growth, invested in new innovations and made big bold bets. We have momentum and I'm proud of our team for their relentless hard work. Let me now turn over the call to Glenn.

Speaker 3

Thank you, Tony, and good morning, everyone. Thank you for joining us. As Tony has said, this is now our 11th straight quarter for posting sector leading operating and financial performance, and we are proud of those results. We remain focused on delivering consistent, disciplined execution with strong performance and growth. We are following through on what we have said we would do with urgency and without distraction, including on our accelerated delevering plans.

Speaker 3

This morning, we announced an innovative $7,000,000,000 structured equity financing with a leading global financial investor to acquire a minority stake in a portion of our wireless backhaul transport infrastructure. This is a transformative transaction and the first of its kind in Canada, and it will further strengthen our investment grade balance sheet. This transaction is subject to completion of definitive agreements, which we expect we will complete and close on in the Q4. The $7,000,000,000 in proceeds will be used to pay down a corresponding amount of debt. As a result, we now expect to end the year with leverage in the range of 3.7 times.

Speaker 3

More on this shortly, but let me now turn to an overview of our strong Q3 results. Wireless service revenue grew 2% year over year, reflecting the continued growth in our mobile subscriber base and continued emphasis to add subscribers on our Rogers Premium 5 gs brand. Postpaid mobile phone customer net additions were a strong a very strong 101,000 and prepaid net additions were 93,000 in the quarter. As expected, the back to school period was competitive this year, particularly in the seasonally strong prepaid market, which tends to be more active for back to school. Rogers remained disciplined in the market and delivered an effective balance across strong subscriber loading and disciplined fundamentals reflected in stable ARPU.

Speaker 3

As a result, our aggregate net phone additions were 194,000 in Q3, which we expect will once again lead the sector on market share for subscriber growth for the 11th consecutive quarter. In a competitive environment, we are leading in net adds, while maintaining stable ARPU and driving service revenue growth. Postpaid mobile phone churn was 1.12% for the quarter, which is roughly unchanged from the prior year and from the first half of twenty twenty four. Wireless adjusted EBITDA was up a strong 5% year over year, reflecting enhanced economies of scale and improved efficiency. This was reflected in our adjusted EBITDA margin, which was up by 2 20 basis points over the prior year to 66%, a company all time high and sequentially up from the Q2, our prior all time high.

Speaker 3

Moving to our cable business. We continue to deliver strong profitability as we focus on returning to revenue growth. Cable revenue was down negative 1% year over year, a further sequential improvement from the negative 2% decline in the 2nd quarter and on its path to turning positive as we exit 2024. That remains our intent and focus. Cable adjusted EBITDA is up a healthy 5% year over year and cable margins are a very strong 58%,

Operator

up 3.30 basis points from last year and

Speaker 3

an all time high. Our employees have worked very hard to leverage our scale efficiencies and cost synergies to deliver enhanced services to our customers, while delivering stronger operating performance. Internet net additions are up significantly year over year, reaching 33,000 in the Q3, which is up almost double from the prior year. And finally, our sports and media revenue is up 11% and adjusted EBITDA is up 25% for the quarter. The 3rd and 4th quarters are seasonally our strongest of the year for our sports and media business, driven primarily by revenue growth at the Toronto Blue Jays and the NHL on Rogers Sportsnet.

Speaker 3

We expect this performance will continue through the Q4 as well. At a consolidated level, total service revenue increased 1% and adjusted EBITDA was up 6% year over year. This drove our consolidated EBITDA margin up by 2 30 basis points to a strong 50%. Free cash flow for the quarter was $915,000,000 up 23% from the prior year, primarily reflecting the higher adjusted EBITDA and lower interest expense on long term debt. Capital expenditures were $977,000,000 in the quarter, down $40,000,000 or 4% from last year, largely as a result of minor timing shifts.

Speaker 3

Turning to the balance sheet. At September 30, we had $4,800,000,000 of available liquidity, including $800,000,000 in cash and short term deposits on hand and $4,000,000,000 available under our bank credit facilities. Our weighted average cost of all borrowings was 4.7% and our weighted average term to maturity was 10 years. We ended the quarter with a debt leverage ratio of 4.6 times, down 0.1 times from the prior quarter, driven by stronger earnings combined with debt repayments. This morning's announced $7,000,000,000 structured equity financing signed with a leading global financial investor reflects our commitment to delever and further strengthen our investment grade balance sheet.

Speaker 3

The Shaw transaction has broadened our national reach and expanded the scale of our world class assets. This $7,000,000,000 structured equity financing represents another transformative opportunity for us. It is a first of its kind in Canada with one of the world's leading financial investors. Succinctly, the companies have agreed to terms for Rogers to sell a minority interest in certain parts of our wireless backhaul transport infrastructure. To be very clear, our cell towers and related spectrum holdings are not included in this transaction and remain 100% owned and controlled, and we will continue to retain full operational control and consolidation for our entire national wireless network.

Speaker 3

Closing is subject to finalizing definitive agreements, all of which are expected to be completed and closed in the Q4. We will use the proceeds to repay debt. And with this transaction, we expect that we will have reduced year end leverage to around 3.7 times, a full turn improved from prior quarters and well ahead of our previously communicated target of 4.2 times. We remain committed to delevering and will remain opportunistic for further strengthening of our balance sheet, including in regard to our purchase of an additional 37.5 percent interest in MLSE, which we expect to close in 2025. As we delever, it is also important to highlight that we are still investing in growth in our core businesses in Canada for long term value creation.

Speaker 3

Our wireless, cable and sports and media operations are built on disciplined investing, targeting sustainable long term growth. And finally, we are reaffirming all of our 2024 guidance range targets. We consistently lead in a competitive environment and we continue to deliver on our near term and longer term goals. Let me conclude by thanking the entire Rogers team. Thank you.

Speaker 3

Your perseverance, dedication and resourcefulness has consistently outperformed our peers on growth and financial performance quarter in and quarter out. This is a strong team working with world class assets attracting global investors, and we remain optimistic with the opportunities ahead for us. Thank you for your time this morning. And with that, Gaylene, may we please commence with the question and answer session. Thank you.

Operator

Certainly. We'll now begin the question and answer session. Our first question is from Batya Levi with UBS. Please go ahead.

Speaker 4

Great. Thank you. I'd like to start with the structured equity financing. If you could provide a little bit more detail in terms of if there will be any shares issued with this, how it would impact maybe your operational your operations as you lease back some of that network elements for your own support? Any color on that, that would be great.

Speaker 4

And then second question was more on the wireless side. If we could talk about a bit more on the competitive environment as we go ahead into the holiday season and if you think that the stable ARPU can be sustained? Thank you.

Speaker 3

Thank you, Batya. On the first question, to be clear, we are not leasing assets. This is not a sale and leaseback transaction. We are selling a minority equity interest in a portion regional portion of our wireless backhaul transport infrastructure. And that's the extent of the transaction.

Speaker 3

It is an equity transaction. With that minority interest in the subsidiary company. We will maintain full operating control of our entire network, including these assets that are involved in selling the minority equity stake. There are no RCI shares involved, RCIA or B, no dilution to our RCI shareholders. This is a minority interest being acquired in a portion of our wireless backhaul and there is no lease.

Speaker 2

Matthew, on the second part of your question relating to wireless competitive intensity getting into the Q4, it's always difficult to predict competitive market dynamics amongst the various brands that are in the market. But if we look to the Q3 in the back to school season, we were very focused on being disciplined with our promotions. We led with a bundled offer of Internet and wireless and stuck to that. And it executed well and resonated throughout the back to school period. You saw that we continue to focus on our primary brand strategy, Rogers 5 gs Premium.

Speaker 2

When you look at the 101,000 postpaid nets, the vast, vast majority of those are on the Rogers brand. So, the team is doing an excellent job of focusing on that segment and migrating customers from Fido and Chatter to the premium brand. And you saw us execute really well with the Chatter brand in the new to Canada and back to school category. There, what we saw was, as a result of a number of system changes we made, we've got a platform now on Chatter that is very good in terms of self serve and has dramatically lowered our cost to serve in the prepaid segment. And so we've consolidated all our prepaid into chatter and we discontinued prepaid on Rogers and Fido and that's working extremely well in the Q4 also.

Speaker 2

We like what we see in terms of the prepaid customers. They're predominantly on autopay. And so the behavior is very similar to a postpaid customer and they're coming in at very healthy ARPUs. And so the strategy is working well and we'll continue that into the Q4. Although you should expect prepaid to come down in the Q4, there's seasonality related to it in the Q3 and we expect the focus in the 4th to be on to postpaid.

Speaker 4

Got it. Thank you.

Speaker 1

The

Speaker 4

next

Operator

caller is Vince Valentini with TD Collins. Please go ahead.

Speaker 5

Thanks very much. I will sneak in 2 as well. 1, just if you can flush out that prepaid a bit more, healthy ARPU means like close to $30 close to what you were getting on low end flanker before Tony and I also note churn on prepaid way lower this year than it was last year and this quarter even better at 2.8%. So in your mind is there really any difference between a low end flanker and a prepaid customer anymore? So that's question 1.

Speaker 5

The other sorry, Glenn, but something just sounds too good to be true here. Who's going to give you $7,000,000 for no equity and no lease payments? Is there what is the buyer getting here? Are they getting some sort of like option to resell these assets back to you in the future? Or what's the angle here?

Speaker 5

There has to be something for somebody to want to pay for the minority interest in the infrastructure.

Speaker 3

We can turn to that. Do you want me to turn to that first, Tony? Okay. So the arrangement is obviously the wireless backhaul transports data from the towers to our core. And so the transport going from the edge of our towers to the edge of our core is a business of transporting data.

Speaker 3

And currently that business is 100% owned and controlled nationally from coast to coast by Rogers. This is a transaction that takes a portion, a regional portion of that national transport and creates a subsidiary that using wholesale rates will pay for the transport. And so it creates revenues. There are expenses and capital for maintaining that regional portion of the backhaul and that ultimately will drive net income within the subsidiary. It's a consolidated subsidiary, it won't affect EBITDA, but the minority interest holders will earn a portion of the net income within that subsidiary and there will be distributions paid from that net income and from the cash that settles between our operating company and at Rogers and the subsidiary carrying the backhaul in these regions or in this region.

Speaker 3

And that's the business model. So there's no lease. There will be periodic distributions of available cash. They'll settle up and that's the business model.

Speaker 5

That makes more sense. So Rogers pays an operating expense as opposed to a

Speaker 3

lease to you? It's a supply agreement, yes. Okay. And so that And a portion of it, a controlling portion of that will attribute to RCI and a minority portion of that will attribute to the minority investor.

Speaker 5

Sorry, then just a follow-up on that. Is this data transport backhaul significantly underutilized today so that there's excess capacity to grow those revenues? Is that the catch?

Speaker 3

Okay. So just to be very clear and to make sure there's no confusion, this is not a business that will sell backhaul to other carriers. This is a business that will continue to serve Rogers exclusively and will continue to consolidate up into Rogers. There is data revenue or data traffic growth going on today annually. Our data traffic grows by 40% to 50% as a result of increased data loading to each subscriber and as a result of subscriber growth from quarter to quarter.

Speaker 3

We will maintain the network as we always have. We'll continue to maintain it, invest in it. We control that investment. We control that operation of the infrastructure. This is simply setting up a supply agreement between the subsidiary and the operating company.

Speaker 3

The returns to the investor, the minority investor coming in are based on that traffic. And we have the forecast worked out based on historic and expected growth rates to set up that business and the volumes that it will drive, the revenue that will drive the expenses that are expected for operating it and the distributions out to the minority investor and back up to RCI as the controlling shareholder. Those distributions are forecast to be anticipated to be relatively stable within a known range based on our forecast.

Speaker 5

I guess you don't want to tell us about known range at this point?

Speaker 3

I'm not looking to disclose the financial terms. No offense. Thank you.

Speaker 5

Thank you, Glenn. That was much better.

Speaker 2

Thank you. Vince, on the first part of your question, we have been driving and we are seeing blurring of the lines between prepaid and postpaid. And it's been a very deliberate strategy for us and it's been very competitive, beneficially competitive for us in that segment of the market where chatter is participating. Customers are coming in, as I said earlier, largely on autopay. And so the behavior is very much like postpaid, and we're seeing very little difference.

Speaker 2

And the ARPU is very strong. Our prepaid ARPU is not that different than Quebec or ARPU, just to put it in perspective. We're not going to quote specific ARPU numbers by brand, but that will give you a sense of the value proposition and the strength of the pricing on the Chatter brand.

Speaker 6

Excellent.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Next question, Gaylene?

Operator

The next question is from Maher Yaghi with Scotiabank. Please go ahead.

Speaker 7

Great. Thank you for taking my question. So just a follow-up on this interesting transaction that you guys announced today. I'm trying to figure out what kind of effective rate the minority interest is getting on this deal. Trying to triangulate a little bit more the impact of this transaction on your future free cash flows.

Speaker 7

And what percent of your backhaul is included in this deal? You say that it's a regional part of your network, but if you can just ballpark a little bit how much of your current back hauling this represents? And are there minimum commitments that you need to provide your equity minority shareholder on this deal in the future that is set in advance or it's just pay for use? I'll have a follow-up on after that.

Speaker 3

So it's based on tiered wholesale rates, volume tiered. As the data traffic grows, the tiering adjusts. There is no specific term on the investment. There is no guaranteed minimum for the distributions. There is a theoretical maximum that we would reach or approach as you get into higher and higher tiers.

Speaker 3

Keep in mind, we've got a business that's growing data rates at 40% to 50%. And so if this were to run indefinitely that 40% to 50% annual growth would get quite high. And so the rates are adjusted accordingly in the tiering. The costs and the maintenance will all be factored in, in the distributions. The order of magnitude, Maher, I'm not going to quantify the annual distributions.

Speaker 3

What I would say on a business of approaching $10,000,000,000 of annual EBITDA, If you were to factor in the interest savings on $7,000,000,000 of debt repayment at our annual cost of just over 4.5%, that's roughly $300,000,000 a year. The distributions of the net income that apportion to the minority investor will be a little bit higher than those net after tax interest savings, but not materially higher. I expect well inside well inside

Speaker 8

$1,000,000,000

Speaker 3

of distributions coming out from the minority interest investment. And so let me give you that range and that is a very wide range deliberately so, so that I'm not steering to exact returns on the call. It's not fair to the investor and we're still working on completing the final documents. But this is an excellent opportunity for the company to delever. It's a structured equity transaction.

Speaker 3

We maintain control. We delever. And the impact on our free cash flow and ability to continue to invest in our business carries on unrestricted by this transaction.

Speaker 7

Great. It sounds like it's basically a bond on the backhauling. It's like selling a bond on your backhauling business.

Speaker 3

It's we're selling a I'm going to resist the that description and that this is an equity transaction and so it'll be considered as such. And so we're selling though a distribution stream.

Speaker 8

Yes. Okay.

Speaker 7

And do you have any option to repurchase that ownership over time?

Speaker 3

We will have full control over how long this investment remains in place and we'll determine that in the fullness of time with the needs of our balance sheet.

Speaker 8

Yes.

Speaker 7

One last one. Are the distributions to the equity partners of that entity tax deductible?

Speaker 3

No, they would be equity distributions and so they would be treated as such. And so that's the we will be repaying debt that has tax deductible interest. We will be paying distributions that are not tax deductible. But even with the effect of that, if I factor in the difference between what I expect will be the annual distribution amounts and the annual interest savings in the context of our free cash flow, it's not a significant increment to our obligations.

Speaker 1

Great. Thanks. Thank you, Maher. Galien, can we have the next question please?

Speaker 3

Thank you, Maher.

Operator

Certainly. The next question is from Drew McLemore with RBC. Please go ahead.

Speaker 9

Yes, thanks very much. Good morning. Sorry, I had trouble kind of climbing on. I'm sure the financing is being hashed to death here, but one follow-up there for you, Glenn. Just in terms of valuing that minority stake, obviously, you're not going to get into the details there specifically, but just what was the approach to how that came about?

Speaker 9

And then just switching gears here, on the wireless network revenue growth, you're tracking at 2%. You're going to be ahead of your large cap peers. As you look into kind of Q4 and 2025, we're seeing some incremental ARPU pressure. And obviously, today's an announcement on what could be even more modest market expansion next year just with some immigration tweaks. I'm just wondering how you are looking at network revenue growth in Q4.

Speaker 9

And are we at the trough? Can we climb back up to maybe not historical mid single digit, but where do you aspire to get to as you look through the medium term? Thank you.

Speaker 3

Sure. Thank you, Drew. On the question on valuation and how the valuations arrived at, Drew, the investors will would look at this as a stream of cash flows that they would work in their modeling and run as evaluation. We've done the same here. It's a fairly straightforward business.

Speaker 3

We've got growing data loading across infrastructure that we own and control. We've done so for decades. And so from our standpoint, we're pretty confident in our ability to determine over the near, mid term, long term horizon what it takes to operate a wireless network in the backhaul transport related to that. This is a transaction that when you own and control the entire national network, you can look at it, not have to worry about the arrangements with partners, not have to worry about the intricacies of that. We control it.

Speaker 3

We control the operating costs. And so we're able to forecast with a pretty good degree of confidence where the data loading traffic is going to go. We have a tiered rate structure that reflects that traffic today and the loading going out into the future. That generates the revenues with a good degree of confidence. We know the operating costs, the capital costs of maintaining that transport with a good degree of confidence.

Speaker 3

And then those forecasts, I'm sure the investors look at and run their own analysis and assessment based on their experience. And then it's just a financial valuation of what their hurdle rate returns are, how they value it, how they risk adjust it. And we have determined the value of their minority stake as being CAD7 billion. And so it's a significant valuation, but let's keep in mind, we carry a very significant volume of traffic on that network. And so that's the simplicity of it.

Speaker 3

And then in terms of your question around ARPU and revenue growth going into the Q4, I would anticipate that the Q4 will be competitive just as the Q3 was. We will continue to emphasize disciplined approach to going after our net adds, emphasizing our premium brand and you've seen us for, well, many quarters now, leading on net adds while being disciplined around the impact on ARPU and sustaining revenue growth. I expect what you've seen in the Q3 and a competitive quarter will carry into the 4th.

Speaker 2

Drew, if I could add to that, just to bring it back to the macro revenue outlook. Besides ARPU, I think it's important to look at the size of the market. The Canadian landscape continues to have healthy growth. We expect the industry, once everyone's reported, continues to grow somewhere between 4% to 4.5%. We certainly saw lower volumes and size of market in the Q3 as a result of government limitations on foreign students, temporary workers, and most recently have some impact in the 4th quarter is a limit or curbing of immigration.

Speaker 2

But notwithstanding that, we continue to see good growth in terms of penetration gains, as well as population growth. And so against that backdrop of healthy growth in the marketplace, the team has been doing an excellent job of base management, upselling customers from Chatto and Fido into the Rogers premium brand and focusing on a value proposition that is beyond just price and that seems to be resonating as well. We've said we're committed to ARPU growth and the strategy we have seems to be resonating. And right now, we reported in Q3 stable ARPUs, but we continue to see the opportunity through the various execution tactics we have to grow ARPU into next year.

Speaker 8

Thank you, both.

Speaker 1

Great. Thank you, Drew. Next question, Gaylene?

Operator

The next question is from Sebastiano Petti with JPMorgan. Please go ahead.

Speaker 10

Hi. Thank you for taking the question. Just wanted to maybe touch on the MLSE announcement earlier last month, just to see if you can provide additional color about the structure and how we should be thinking about that, particularly the language about, I think, in the press release today that Rogers will be the largest owner of MLSE with a controlling interest in the 75%. So when can we perhaps expect to see additional details of what that structure might look like given commentary previously that it will not be a leveraging transaction? And so that's my first question.

Speaker 3

Thanks, Sebastiano. We stand by the statement that we will manage this, that we will continue to emphasize our delevering. We'll continue to manage our balance sheet with the closing of that MLSE investment. And particularly, the this structured equity transaction gives us some optionality and some leeway on how we structure that to continue to hold the gains from this transaction and look to how we fund MLSE between now and when we close, which I expect will be out in 2025. There's a number of different ways we could do that.

Speaker 3

I expect on closing, we will own and control a majority stake in MLSE. It could be as high as 75% if we bring in outside partners over time, whether it's at closing or subsequent or whatever, we'll determine all that in the fullness of time. This structured equity transaction though provides us with a substantial delevering. We will close 2024 in the range of 3.7 times. I anticipate with the MLSE transaction, we will close 2025 in a similar range.

Speaker 3

And maybe I'll just leave the comments at that, Sebastiano.

Speaker 10

Similar range to 3.7 that you anticipate exiting 2024 with Glenn, is that what you're implying? Yes.

Speaker 3

Yes, sorry. Yes.

Speaker 10

Okay.

Speaker 6

And then, I mean, just

Speaker 10

zooming back, as we think about the delevering overall, I mean, I think the strategy or the stated plan was to delever by half a churn before asset sales entering the year. We now have on an organic basis the things that will probably not be coming in even with there's no asset sales that are coming through. So we're not necessarily delevering half a turn on an organic basis. If you look at the pressures across the ecosystem, I mean, and implied guidance. And I understand the improvements on an operational basis that Rogers is currently executing against.

Speaker 10

But as you think about the path for delevering over the next several years, I mean, the question we're getting from investors, I mean, what is the strategic equity transaction announced today? I mean, what does that imply about the cash generation of the business? I mean, is the company still looking, as management still look at Roger's ability to delever over the next several years? And has that materially changed as we think about the backdrop of the ecosystem? Thank you.

Speaker 3

Well, we remain extremely confident in our ability to generate cash from operations. So to the extent it's changed, I'm more confident. We announced we would hit $1,000,000,000 of cost synergies in 24 months and we hit it within 12 months. We will realize $1,000,000,000 of cost synergy savings realized in year in 2024. And so I'm confident in our ability to drive earnings growth, cost synergies, cost efficiencies, improved margins.

Speaker 3

That helps lift our EBITDA, helps lift our free cash flow. We will generate $3,000,000,000 of free cash flow in 2024 and we hold a very substantial portion of that free cash flow after dividends to pay down debt. So to the extent it's changed, I'm more confident at the end of 2024 than it was going into 2024 and our ability to hold cash from operations and pay down debt, we are doing that. So I remain confident and very satisfied. We announced when we went into this transaction with Shaw that within 36 months we would delever back down to in the range of where we were pre Shaw.

Speaker 3

Well, pre Shaw, we were a little bit over 3 times. With this transaction, we are approaching the mid 3 times range and we're not yet at the 2nd anniversary of the Shaw transaction. I appreciate we haven't sold the targeted $1,000,000,000 of non core assets and that's just your question. I acknowledge that, but we're not desperate, wasn't ever going to be a fire sale in the interest rate environment. We've had to take a pause on that.

Speaker 3

I think what we've shown is strong flexibility around adjusting our strategy. We were going to sell non core assets and then get to our Cogeco shares. Last year, we realized the non core assets would be delayed. And so we flipped and we sold our Cogeco stake, delevered at the end of 'twenty 3 from that substantially. This year, we found an opportunity.

Speaker 3

I appreciate you said we haven't sold assets. We've sold $7,000,000,000 in an equity interest in assets that if you were to look to our balance sheet and find the net book value for those assets, dollars 7,000,000,000 far outstrips the net book value of those assets and this is a portion of our wireless backhaul. This is not even the majority of our wireless backhaul infrastructure on our balance sheet and we sold it for $7,000,000,000 of equity interest. We control the operations. You're right to acknowledge these assets aren't non core, they're core.

Speaker 3

And that's why we will maintain control. But I think we're showing a very dedicated driven intent to delever and continue to invest and grow. Maybe I'll pause there.

Speaker 1

That's Sebastien. Thanks Sebastien. We'll next question, Galen.

Operator

The next question is from David Barden with Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Speaker 8

Hey, guys. Thanks so much for taking the question. I'm going to have to ask one more on the securitization thing. And then I'll ask one about the business. But so Glenn, I think that the word that we want to use I would use is securitization, right?

Speaker 8

That you've taken you've created this subsidiary, this intercompany payment system. There's a forward stream of these payments, you're front end loading the receipt of these payments into your balance sheet and $7,000,000,000 And my question a little bit is, the original plan was we would delever and our cash outflows would go down. But here with this setup where the payments out to the minority holder are greater than the interest savings from paying down $7,000,000,000 of debt, you're delevering, but your payments are going up. And so I guess the question is, what's the point of that? Like why is it so important to have a lower numerator divided by a denominator if your cash outflows are actually going up instead of down?

Speaker 8

And then Tony, I guess, one of the big conversations we've been having has been how the impact of the government's new immigration policies or posture are going to impact industry growth and how is that does impact industry growth, how the industry will react? And you guys have been probably the biggest beneficiary of new Canadian market net additions. I'd love to kind of get your perspective on that. Thank you, guys.

Speaker 3

Let me answer the first question first. Your reference to securitization, I'll just highlight a securitization transaction would be debt. And this isn't debt. The second part of your question around how does this make sense because you're saving on interest, but you're paying out more on distributions. I've been careful not to enumerate what we are paying out in distributions.

Speaker 3

And so I would just suggest to you that this is an excellent opportunity for the company because on the balance we are very pleased with where we anticipate that balance to go over the future. And I'll just leave it at that.

Speaker 2

2nd part of your question, David, relating to really relating to the size of the market, I think a couple of things I would say. The government curbing of the new to Canada category, look at the foreign students, our estimate, it's corroborated by some other reports that have been prepared externally. That category is down in the Q3 40% year on year. Temporary workers, foreign temporary workers is down 20% to 25%. And so in the new to Canada category, that has impacted it.

Speaker 2

And as you say, we've traditionally done extremely well in that category. But what you see in our results for the Q3 is that we execute across all segments of the market and perform extremely well. Our estimate is that we once again have leading market share in the Q3 in both postpaid and total mobile phones. And so that's really attributed to, again, our focus on the Rogers Premium brand. As I said, the vast, vast majority of our net adds is on the Rogers Premium brand, and now increasingly good share on chatter.

Speaker 2

In terms of the size of the market outside of the new to Canada category, we've traditionally seen over the last year and a bit, if we look at that trend line, excluding new to Canada, we're seeing organic growth in the 2.5% to 3% as a result of penetration growth, which is now at 88% and going up to 90% very soon and still lagging other countries on that key metric. So good opportunity for growth in terms of size of market.

Speaker 5

Great.

Speaker 1

Thanks, David. Next question, Gaylene?

Operator

The next question is from Jerome DeBruhe with Desjardins. Please go ahead.

Speaker 9

Hi, good morning. Thanks for taking my question. The first one is on the equity sale in the backhaul there. Just trying to bridge the gap with the leverage guidance that you have provided. If you can maybe clarify the tax impact on the sale of those shares, what's the net value of the 7,000,000,000 dollars That is question number 1.

Speaker 9

And question number 2 is on the CapEx kind of longer term for Rogers. I appreciate there's no real change from the deal you announced this morning. But I'm wondering if 2024 is a year with high CapEx, normal CapEx or low CapEx, I appreciate you've been seeing mid and high split, mid band deployment, microwave backhaul replacement. Just looking if this year is a high CapEx year in general? Thank you.

Speaker 3

Thank you for the questions, Jerome. The tax impact, I mean, just put that in the context of $7,000,000,000 of debt repayment. Our average cost of debt is just over 4.5%. So the pre tax or the available tax expense on interest expense would be around $300,000,000 Think of the net after tax or additional tax cost to that takes your net savings down to about $250,000,000 roughly. And that will give you the order of magnitude on the net savings from the repayment of debt.

Speaker 3

And I'm sorry, your second question on the CapEx. Yes, I think I've been consistent in signaling that if you're modeling and I'm not going to start guiding for $25,000,000 yet, but I think I've been consistent in my comments that if you were to model of continuing our range of spend of around $4,000,000,000 If you're going out, assume some inflationary impact, but keep it in the range of $4,000,000,000 We will manage our priorities within that band. As we grow revenues, the intensity will mediate or soften, but we're not looking to step down. We're investing from roughly that $4,000,000,000 range. We have a number of priorities to get to.

Speaker 3

Our businesses are all growing and that is a sufficient envelope for us to drive the business growth in that order of magnitude.

Speaker 9

Thanks. Just to clarify that the

Speaker 1

sorry, Jerome, just so we can get a couple of your peers in as well. That's fine. Okay. Thanks. We can follow-up later.

Speaker 1

Galien, time for 2 more quick questions, please.

Operator

Thank you. The next caller is Simon Flannery with Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.

Speaker 6

Great. Thank you very much. Good morning. Tony, the CRTC recently put out a strategic plan. I just love a general commentary on the regulatory environment and how you see that evolving over time.

Speaker 6

And in particular, they had a recent comment on the roaming rates. They want some replies for you in the next few days. Perhaps you could just comment on that? And then also just give us a little bit more color about how big roaming is for you in the wireless business currently? Thanks.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Simon. In terms of I'll first start with the roaming side of it. What we have seen is a decline year on year on total roaming revenue. We'll disclose the amount of it. But if you're to look at the negative impacts on ARPU, that'd be the single biggest one for us in the Q3.

Speaker 2

And so we've evolved in our have and you'll see in the Q4 evolve our value proposition on roaming, so that we accelerate and increase the number of unique roamers. We've seen the actual number decline. And so we're adjusting the value proposition as we compete with alternatives that customers have when they're outside of Canada. Early indications are good on that. And so we like what we see.

Speaker 2

In terms of the CRTC's commentary in looking at it, it's not a surprise. They had indicated that earlier in the spring as they were looking at various fees in the industry and we'll obviously participate and cooperate in providing all the information that they need. But as I said, we've already evolved in terms of our value proposition on roaming.

Speaker 7

Great.

Speaker 5

Thank you.

Speaker 1

Thank you. Thanks, Simon. And our last question, Gaylene, please.

Operator

The next question is from Aravinda Galappatthige with Canaccord Genuity. Please go ahead.

Speaker 11

Good morning. Thanks for fitting me in. Two quick ones. I want to follow-up obviously. First of all, Glenn, you mentioned sort of in the vicinity of 3.7x leverage even exiting 2025.

Speaker 11

Just wanted to clarify, does that envision the non core real estate sales or does that exclude that? And the second question is, obviously, on guidance, when you can look at the 12% to 15% guide, that does require an uptick in Q4. Perhaps maybe talk to what could drive that? I know there'd be some pricing action that you've taken. Anything that would kind of change the trajectory that we've seen in Q2 and Q3?

Speaker 11

Thank you.

Speaker 3

Thank you, Aravinda. The on the revenue, we're going into an active quarter. It's a strong quarter for us across our businesses. We remain determined to meet those guidance ranges as I've indicated. And so I'll leave the answer at that.

Speaker 3

You've hit on some of the elements of that in terms of some pricing initiatives. The vast portion of our growth is driven on the growth in our subscribers. We've had strong contributions from that through the 1st 3 quarters of the year and that obviously helps drive the Q4 as well. And so it's a balance across all of those elements. In terms of your question on the non core real estate assets, that remains a work in progress.

Speaker 3

I've grown weary of explaining each quarter that we're on it and it'll come, interest rates are high. And so we've pivoted. Keep in mind a full success on selling all of those targeted non core assets would be somewhere in the range of $1,000,000,000 and that would be in the range of a 0.1 impact on our leverage. If there is any opportunity to fill those in, we will fill them in at the first opportunity. I'm not desperate to do it and I'm not chasing a market that's disinterested.

Speaker 3

And so we will adjust accordingly. But the 3.7x range does not specifically say if we sell this or that, if we do this or that, we've got about a year and a bit to go before I close out 2025. We've got many options on how we grow the business, how we generate free cash flow, how we apply that free cash flow generation to paying down debt and how we meet the investment in our increased stake in MLSE. To be clear, that is factored into the 3.7x and I've got a number of different avenues to fund that acquisition that will help in our delevering.

Speaker 1

That's great. Thanks Aravinda and thanks everyone for joining us on the call today. If there's any follow ups, please reach out to the IR team. Thank you very much.

Operator

This concludes today's conference call. You may disconnect your lines. Thank you for participating and have a pleasant day.

Remove Ads
Powered by Quartr
Earnings Conference Call
Papa Johns International Q3 2024
00:00 / 00:00
Remove Ads