W.W. Grainger Q4 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

Quartr
Provided by Quartr
February 2, 2024

There are 13 speakers on the call.

Operator

Greetings. Welcome to the W. W. Grainger Fourth Quarter 2023 Earnings Conference Call. At this time, all participants are in a listen only mode.

Operator

A question and answer session will follow the formal presentation. Please note this conference is being recorded. I'll now turn the conference over to Kyle Bland, Vice President of Investor Relations. Thank you. You may begin.

Speaker 1

Good morning. Welcome to Grainger's 4th Quarter and Full Year 2023 Earnings Call. With me are D. J. Macpherson, Chairman and CEO and Dee Merriwether, Senior Vice President CFO.

Speaker 1

As a reminder, some of our comments today may include forward looking statements that are subject to various risks and uncertainties. Additional information regarding factors that could cause actual results to differ materially is included in the company's most recent Form 8 ks and periodic reports filed with the SEC. This morning's call will focus on our adjusted earnings for the Q4 and full year 2023, which exclude the loss on the divestiture of our ENR industrial sales subsidiary. We have also included a daily organic constant currency growth to normalize for the impact on revenue. Definitions and full reconciliations of these non GAAP financial measures with their corresponding GAAP measures are found in the tables at the end of this presentation and in our earnings release, both of which are available on our IR website.

Speaker 1

We will also share results related to Monotaro. Please remember that Monotaro is a public company and followed Japanese GAAP, which differs from U. S. GAAP as reported in our results 1 month in arrears. As a result, the numbers disclosed will differ from Monitaro's public statements.

Speaker 1

Now, I'll turn it over to DG.

Speaker 2

Thanks, Kyle. Good morning and thanks for joining the call. In 2023, the Grainger team continued to drive our strategy forward by remaining focused on what matters most, Providing our customers with a great experience and exceptional service. The customers we serve play a vital role in keeping their businesses and institutions running and everything we do is focused on making their jobs easier. We made meaningful progress this year in building new capabilities in both segments to help our customers and team members support the work they do.

Speaker 2

We've done this by investing in technology, our supply chain network and our high touch growth engines to ensure we can provide the best experience as possible. As a result of this focus, we delivered record sales and earnings for the year. I'm incredibly proud of the progress we've made and want to take a few minutes to highlight some of this progress in more detail. The Grainger HiTouch solutions model has undergone a digital transformation over the past several years with strategic investments in our infrastructure, talent and the development of custom capabilities to support our customers. We have built key technology infrastructure capabilities focused on 2 main domains that affect customer experience.

Speaker 2

1, knowing our products better than anyone else and 2, knowing our customers better than anyone else. These endeavors include the development of homegrown software assets around product management or PIM and customer information management or KIM, which allow us to store, codify and scale our data assets. These investments may seem simple and obvious, but in the MRO industry context, product and customer integration is very challenging. We offer millions of products many technical attributes unique to each product category and then deliver these products to millions of customers across a wide range of industries. Have made great progress here, but the exciting part is that we still have a long way to go.

Speaker 2

We have invested in additional technology talent that could partner with our MRO subject matter experts bring Grainger's industry know how to life. This partnership of talent is yielding significant benefits and helping us generate high quality proprietary data insights through PIM and KIM. These insights are fueling our growth engines and helping us drive share. For example, our ability to capture detailed product attributes allows us to bid on more relevant keywords that could ultimately yield higher returns on our marketing spend. In addition, having this detailed product information coupled with customized workflows Processes means we're able to work with more granularity to gain confidence that our products are competitively priced and we can do that at scale.

Speaker 2

Harnessing what we know about our customers' business operations through Kym alongside our detailed product data allows us to better match products to customers saving them time and increasing confidence in their purchase. These are just a few examples where we have leveraged our data investments in an ecosystem where talent and technology work together to drive great outcomes. This work is serving as a great foundation for the value we deliver through our high touch strategic growth engines. Starting with merchandising, we've reviewed roughly 80% of the overall product portfolio at once and plan to finish collectively reviewing the entire assortment by the time we close out 2024. We continue to see strong revenue lift equating to several 100 basis points per remerchandise category.

Speaker 2

Our second and third passes through the assortment have a broader lens category. Our second and third passes through the assortment have a broader lens than the first pass as we continue to leverage learnings, evolve our PIM capabilities as we add other relevant areas to our review process. We are seeing strong results from this Evergreen initiative, which we believe sets us up well to continue to drive share gain through this work stream in the future. Shifting to marketing, we continue to make progress through this initiative. This year, we've put a particular emphasis on leveraging Kim and expanding top of funnel marketing efforts to TV and streaming channels to increase brand awareness.

Speaker 2

We've seen positive results in many areas and plan to continue to increase investment at attractive returns going forward. Our sales force remains an important demand generator for Grainger. As mentioned at Investor Day, we're piloting the use of our enhanced chem data to redraw seller territories to better serve underpenetrated customer locations. With this for the first time in several years, we've added about 200 salespeople to the organization over the last year and a half. It takes anywhere from 18 to 24 months for these new TIM members to ramp to a profitable level.

Speaker 2

But with the results we've seen so far, we are on the right path and expect this initiative to contribute to outgrowth over the next few years. To ensure that our sales force is most effective, we're investing in tools and technology, which leverage information from PIM and Kim to provide insights to our sellers at scale to help them better plan their day to day interactions with customers. We are piloting several different capabilities here in 2024. Lastly, with our enhanced customer information, we are finding additional opportunities to better solutions and reinforce the value we bring to customers. This includes bolstering our value added services offering and advancing our inventory management capabilities to improve keep stock processes and technology, both of which increase stickiness with customers, improve our productivity and drive share.

Speaker 2

This has been a multi year journey, which is creating a significant competitive advantage for our As we layer on further enhancements and leverage machine learning and AI capabilities, we will continue to power our growth engines, drive share and deliver customer value. Moving to the endless assortment model, despite more muted top line growth in 2023, the proven flywheel continues to propel forward. Monatara continues to execute well. They've seen strong growth with enterprise customers, continue to expand with small and midsize customers are gaining operating leverage as they ramp into their distribution center in Gawa. In January, I had the opportunity to visit Monotaro and was able to see the progress in Inagawa, which has been supported by a tight partnership between our U.

Speaker 2

S. Supply chain organization and our Japanese counterparts. The Zuora team has progressed on their strategy, expanding their assortment, attracting new customers, B2B customer retention. While repeat rates improved in 2023, the team continues to focus on this evergreen initiative. This includes presenting and personalizing our most advantaged assortment, assessing our price competitiveness and proactively communicating delivery times to highlight where we are advantaged.

Speaker 2

For many of these efforts, the team continues to work with their monetar peers to share best practices that work together to move the business forward. Now let's turn to Grainger's Advantage Supply Chain. We've made great progress to return service back to near normal levels following the unprecedented global supply chain disruption that our industry experienced over the last few years. We continue to hear that Granger's product availability and our next day order complete shipping capabilities greatly set us apart from our competitors, allowing us to show up well and win with customers. As I mentioned at our 2022 Investor Day, we set out to accelerate our investment capacity, automation and sustainability initiatives to further strengthen our service advantage.

Speaker 2

We are well on that path as we add new square footage to the network, including the following: 3 new bulk warehouses including a 525,000 square foot facility in Pineville, North Carolina is scheduled to open later this year. A 535,000 Square Foot Distribution Center currently under construction in Gresham, Oregon, which is on track to open in 2025. And as shared earlier this week, a new 1,200,000 square foot distribution center near Houston, Texas. With the addition of these facilities, we're adding 3,500,000 square feet to our supply chain in total, representing more than a 35% increase from where we began 2023. These latest investments will only strengthen our promise to customers Count on us to provide next day complete orders to keep their operations running and people safe.

Speaker 2

Finally, I think it's important to reinforce how the Grainger Edge is truly the key to all the success that I just mentioned. Everyday our purpose, we keep the world working, motivates us to do our best for customers, communities and each other. That commitment has driven a culture we are very proud of and one that's continually being noticed externally. Recently Granger ranked 3rd out of 400 of America's largest companies in the American Opportunity Index for our commitment to developing internal talent, drive business performance and individual growth. The index primarily focuses on the experience of workers in non college degree roles and the company's ability to offer them growth and development no matter their career Additionally, Grainger was named Glassdoor's 2024 Best Places to Work.

Speaker 2

Glassdoor has more than 50,000,000 unique monthly visitors and this recognition is particularly special is the first time Grainger was named Glassdoor's U. S. Large Employer List. Both of these awards are based on 3rd party facts or proprietary career databases, not surveys. So they eliminate subjectivity and serve as a testament to the ways that Grainger Edge strengthen our team member experience and employer brand.

Speaker 2

Lastly, before switching to the financials, I want to take a second to announce an update to our 2,030 sustainability target. Our target approved by the Board early in the Q4 of 2023 seeks to reduce absolute scope 1 and 2 emissions by 50% from a 2018 baseline, up from the previous 30% target. This new goal aligns with the level required to reduce scope 1 and 2 emissions to limit global temperature rise to 1.5 degrees Celsius. Environmental stewardship, which has long been a standing focus for Grainger remains a key component of our culture and is embedded with the Grainger edge in everything we do. To be clear, our investments in sustainability are profitable as our team has been very resourceful at finding ways to improve our emissions, while also supporting results.

Speaker 2

Turning to Slide 9, we finished the year with over $16,500,000,000 in sales, up 8.6% on a daily basis or 9.5% in daily organic constant currency Amidst the normalizing demand environment, growth for the year is highlighted by our High Touch Solutions U. S. Business, which continued to gain profitable share finishing the year with 5 25 basis points market outgrowth exceeding our annual target of 400 to 500 basis points. Alongside the strong top line, the team also did a great job of managing profitability through the year with operating margins up 130 basis points in 2023, finishing the year at 15.7%. Together, these strong results fueled record earnings, ROIC and cash flow.

Speaker 2

For the year adjusted EPS was up over 23 percent to $36.67 per share. ROIC finished at 42.8 percent and operating cash flow is over $2,000,000,000 which allowed us to return $1,200,000,000 to shareholders through dividends and share repurchases. Overall, these strong results for 2023 are the byproduct of a lot of hard work from our entire team and I'm very proud of what we've been able to accomplish. We embark on another year, regardless of what market we face, we are well positioned to continue our momentum and expect to drive great results for our stakeholders in 2024 and beyond. With that, I will turn it over to Dee.

Speaker 3

Thanks, DG. And I apologize upfront, everyone, I'm a little hoarse today, so please bear with me. Turning to our Q4 results, we had a solid quarter to finish out the year, with profitability coming in stronger than expected, but also reflected some top line softness as we exited the year. For the total company results, mainly sales grew 5.1% or 5.5% on a daily organic constant currency basis, which was driven by growth across both segments. Consistent with what we've seen all year, year over year top line growth rates continue to moderate as we wrap price past in the prior year.

Speaker 3

While sales finished within our implied guidance range for the quarter, we did see more holiday related softness than anticipated as we ended the quarter. The total company gross margin for the quarter finished at 39.1%, declining by 50 basis points over the prior year period. Both segments saw a slight year over year margin contraction as expected, which I will detail in the coming slides, but in total finished the quarter at the top end of our implied 4th quarter guide. Total company operating margin was up 80 basis points, which was aided by a lap of roughly $35,000,000 of one time expenses in the prior year period. When excluding this impact, SG and A as a percentage of sales was still favorable versus prior year by roughly 40 basis points.

Speaker 3

In total, we delivered diluted EPS for the quarter of $8.33 which was up over 16% versus the Q4 of 2022. Moving on to segment level results. The Hi Tec Solutions segment continues to perform well with sales up 4.7% on both a reported and daily organic constant currency basis, fueled by growth across all geographies. Volume growth remains strong and accounts for a vast majority of the overall year over year expansion. In the U.

Speaker 3

S, Almost all customer end markets continue to see growth in the Q4 with government, contractors and healthcare seeing the strongest year over year performance. Canada grew slowly in Q4 driven by a softening macro, but the business remained solidly profitable in the quarter and finished 2023 with their most profitable year in over half a decade. For the segment, gross profit margin finished the quarter at 41.4%, down 50 basis points versus the prior year due to negative price cost spread and year end inventory cost adjustment, which included the lap of a prior year LIFO inventory benefit that we did not repeat in 2023. These headwinds were partially offset by the continued supply chain tailwinds we've seen all year as improved product availability and lower fuel and Tanner costs drove year over year favorability. Although we were price cost negative in the quarter and for the full year of 2023, We are nearly neutral on a 2 year stack as the timing favorability captured in 2022 has Fully unwound, and we enter 2024 on a neutral footing.

Speaker 3

At the operating margin line, we saw improvement of 90 basis points year over year as the slight GP decline was offset by leverage in the business, despite continued investment in marketing and headcount to drive long term growth. As mentioned, year over year SG and A leverage was aided by roughly 90 basis points due to the lap of one time expenses the prior year period. Overall, it was another solid quarter for the Hi Tec Solutions North American segment, wrapping up a great year. Looking at market outgrowth on Slide 13, we estimate that the U. S.

Speaker 3

MRO market grew in the quarter between 2 point 5% 3%, largely driven by price with industrial production, our proxy for volume, remaining roughly flat year over year. This indicates that the Hi Tec Solutions U. S. Business achieved roughly 2 25 basis points of outgrowth in the 4th quarter in total. This more muted quarterly outgrowth reflects higher market based inflation and Granger's Q4 price contribution due to the timing of when we pass price versus the market.

Speaker 3

On a pure volume basis, when looking at our volume contribution versus IP growth, our market outlook growth was closer to 475 In any case, as DG mentioned, looking at the full year, we achieved an annual outgrowth target by capturing approximately 525 basis points of growth above the market and remain poised to deliver against our target again in 2024. Moving to our endless assortment segment. Sales increased 6% or 8.2% on a daily constant currency basis, which adjusts for the impact of the depreciated Japanese yen. Zoro U. S.

Speaker 3

Was up 2.6%, while Minutaro achieved 9.9% growth in local days local currency. At a business level, Zohr's growth reflects the continuation of headwinds they've experienced all year with declines in non core B2C volume a slowing macro environment impacting its B2B customers. B2B customer growth remained steady in the high single digits for the quarter, While non core B2C and B2C Lite customer performance remained down over 20% year over year. At Monitaro, macro related headwinds continued to impact results. However, the business still drove strong growth increased sales to new and enterprise customers, while also maintaining strong repeat purchase rates.

Speaker 3

From a profitability perspective, gross margin for the segment declined 60 basis points versus the prior year as Monitaro's favorability was offset year over year declines at Zurow. As in the prior quarters, auditorium results reflect continued freight efficiencies, while the ZURO decline was driven by negative product mix and the impact of unfavorable timing from prior year price increases. Operating margins for this segment expanded by 50 basis points to 7.8% as the unfavorable gross margin was offset by SG and A leverage aided by the lack of one time distribution center and commissioning costs in the prior year. Now looking forward to 2024, we expect to deliver another solid year of performance in more muted MRO market. Our outlook for the year includes revenue to be between $17,200,000,000 $17,700,000,000 at the total company level were daily organic constant currency sales growth between 4% and 7%, driven by top line growth in both segments.

Speaker 3

With our Hi Tec Solutions segment, we expect daily organic constant currency sales growth between 3.5% and 6.5%. In the U. S, we're planning for the total MRO market growth to be largely flat with a range of down 0.5% to plus 1.5%. This is still the flattish volume range coupled with price inflation between 0% 1%. On top of this market outlook, expect to continue executing against our strategic growth engines to achieve 400 to 500 basis points of U.

Speaker 3

S. Market outgrowth in 2024. In the endless assortment segment, we anticipate daily constant currency sales to grow between 7% 10%, which normalizes for the impact of 2 additional business days and expected foreign currency exchange headwinds. Minotaro is expected to grow in the low double digits in local currency and local gains as they continue to ramp new and enterprise customers amidst an expected slower macro demand environment. Rural is anticipated to grow in the mid single digits as we anticipate that many of the macro related headwinds impacting their core B2B customers hold over into 2024.

Speaker 3

We also expect to continue to unwind of B2C and B2C like customers, which include resellers and marketplaces to impact results, especially in the first half of the year. In 2024, the team will focus on growing long term relationships with its core B2B customers, including work to improve targeted marketing, fine tune their pricing model and drive consistent service for all of their customers. Moving to our margin expectations. Even after normalizing for some one time gross margin benefits we realized in 2023, We expect total company operating margins to remain quite healthy in 2024. In the HiJET Solutions segment, Operating margins will stay relatively flat year over year between 17.4% 17.9%.

Speaker 3

We expect gross profit margins to be down in 2024 after lapping roughly 50 basis points of onetime benefits in 2023. We anticipate price cost per year will be yearly neutral as we have worked our way through the timing discrepancies we've seen over the last couple of years. On the SG and A side, we expect modest leverage, while we continue to make incremental investments toward our strategic initiatives to fuel our growth. In Illus Assortment, we are modeling operating margins to be roughly consistent to what we've seen in the back half of twenty twenty three in the 7.3% to 7.8% range as the segment reads baseline following Zuul's revenue declines with their non core B2C and B2C like customers. At the business unit level, total operating margins are expected to decline, while Militaro's operating margins are expected to be roughly neutral for the year.

Speaker 3

Turning now to capital allocation. We expect the business will continue to generate strong cash flow in the year with an expected range of $1,900,000,000 to $2,100,000,000 implying operating cash conversion around 100%. We plan to continue to execute a consistent return driven approach to our capital allocation strategy, meaning our priorities remain largely unchanged from prior years. First, we look at investing in the business in both organic investment and opportunistic M and A. For 2024, we expect capital spending in the range of $400,000,000 to $500,000,000 Spending here includes continued supply chain expansion in the as we work to stand up facilities in the Pacific Northwest and the Houston area.

Speaker 3

We also plan to further invest in homegrown data and technology capabilities help empower our growth engines and further our customer value proposition. Lastly, sustainability related spend remains a priority. We will continue to invest in projects with solid returns to help achieve our emissions targets. On M and A, we remain highly selective, but are also open to investing in capabilities and acquiring right assets to further our strategy, and we have a small dedicated team who continually evaluate opportunities in this area. Secondly, we expect to return the balance of our excess cash to shareholders in the form of dividends and share repurchases.

Speaker 3

As always, we'll formally set our 2024 dividend in the Q2, but I can say we remain proud of our history and increasing the dividend for 52 consecutive years and expect to do so again this year. We do not tie our dividend payout to specific metrics. However, we anticipate consistent annual dividend increases in the high single digit to low double digit percentage range every year. Lastly, we expect to allocate the balance of our cash flow to share repurchases and anticipate the amount to be between $900,000,000 $1,100,000,000 in 2024. We think this return focused allocation philosophy provides the organization optimal flexibility to efficiently manage investment while maximizing shareholder returns.

Speaker 3

In summary, Rolling all this up at the total company level, as mentioned, we plan to grow top line by roughly 4% to 7% on a daily organic constant currency basis. Note that reported sales growth is a bit higher than our daily organic constant currency range as we are normalizing for divestiture of our E and R subsidiaries, FX changes and the impact of 2 additional selling days in 2020 compared to the prior year. A reconciliation of these impacts is provided in the appendix of this presentation. Operating margin, as we discussed, range from 15.3% to 15.8%, leading to expected EPS growth of 3.6% to 10.5 percent or $38 to $40.50 per share. From a seasonality perspective, we do expect both revenue and profitability to be more back half weighted as we move through the year.

Speaker 3

This includes a softer start in January from the timing of the New Year's holiday and cold weather disruptions experienced mid month across a large portion of the U. S. With this, January sales started slowly but picked up momentum as the month progressed with preliminary results up 4.4% on a daily organic constant currency basis. On profitability, with more muted inflation in the year, we won't see the pricing price timing and favorability we normally capture in the Q1. With this, gross margins will show very little seasonality and remain reasonably consistent with our full year gross margin outlook throughout the year.

Speaker 3

For SG and A, we expect year over year deleverage in the Q1 as we ramp up investment spending in 2024. Leverage will improve each quarter, slipping to a tailwind in the back half of the year. Altogether, this will drive EPS growth to be flat to slightly down in the Q1 and will ramp thereafter as the year continues. Before I hand it back to DiGi, I wanted to quickly touch on our long term outlook and where we expect to take the business over the next several years. As we discussed in our last call, we've made great progress towards the 2025 targets we rolled out at our Investor Day in September 2022.

Speaker 3

We remain on track to hit our revenue goals, but are meaningfully ahead on most of our profitability targets. With this, we're replacing our 2025 targets with an updated long term earnings framework. The framework is actually quite similar to what we've discussed previously as we continue to target double digit annual EPS growth in a normalized MRO market, driven by continued strong top line growth, including 400 to 500 basis points of annual market outgrowth in the high touch U. S. Business and annual growth in the teens for endless assortment.

Speaker 3

Generally stable gross profit margins, which should normalize from a 2024 baseline and SG and A growing floorless sales while still investing in demand generation activities to drive sustainable long term growth. You will notice we made a few tweaks the earnings framework, which largely offset. First, we've widened the top line outlook for analyst assortment as each business there facing dynamics making it harder to achieve historical growth rates. With Monitaro, at this stage of their maturity, The business has onboarded most of the large and mid sized businesses in their market. With this, the team is pivoting its marketing strategy from firm level acquisition to end user penetration in an effort to expand total customer share of wallet.

Speaker 3

At Zoro, following the post pandemic volume declines in B2C and B2C Lite customers, the business is refocusing their efforts on B2B customers as they work to build long term profitable relationships with these core customers there. As the business refocus, we think it's prudent to widen the range of growth outcomes for this segment over the next few years. Regardless, we still expect to deliver very strong growth through this segment and remain confident in the model's ability to continue to take share and drive profitable operating scale to the total business overall. 2nd, as we foreshadowed last quarter, We expect to maintain elevated gross margins in the Hi Tec Solutions segment, which is underpinned by the confidence we have in executing against our 2 core pricing remaining market price competitive while maintaining price cost neutrality. Adding these together, net net, we end at roughly the same outlook as we discussed at Investor Day, strong earnings growing in double digits annually.

Speaker 3

When we drive these results, the business will draw considerable amounts of cash, which we will allocate through a consistent and return driven approach. This includes continuing to invest in the business at an elevated level next few years as we add incremental supply chain capacity and continue to build out our technology capabilities. Add all this up and we think this represents an attractive return profile, we remain well positioned to drive significant value creation for our shareholders. With that, I'll turn it back to DG for some closing remarks.

Speaker 2

Thank you, Dee. Grainger continues to build deep trust with our customers as we partner with them to fulfill their MRO needs. While we expect the market in 2024 to be more muted, the Grainger team will continue to focus on what matters, advancing our growth drivers to improve the customer experience and providing the exceptional service we are known for. When we live our principles, we can be successful in the matter of the cycle. I have full confidence that we will deliver strong results again this year.

Speaker 2

With that, we will open up the line for questions.

Operator

Thank you. We will now be conducting a question and answer session. Our first questions come from the line of Ryan Merkel with William Blair. Please proceed with your question.

Speaker 4

Hi, everyone. Thanks for taking the questions. I wanted to start with gross margin and I guess it's a 2 parter. Your gross margins are up about 100 basis points since 2019. And I'm just curious what the drivers are?

Speaker 4

And then for the 2024 guide, at the high end, you're holding gross margins flat. But I think, Dee, you mentioned 50 basis points of onetime price cost that you're going to have to lap. So what backfills that?

Speaker 3

Let me start with the first question first and then maybe I'll have you re ask the second part of it to make sure I don't forget anything. So when we go back to 2019, I think we've done a pretty good job on Just product gross margins in general and being able to profitize customers based upon the services that we provide from the high touch solutions business. In addition to that, The pricing strategy change has taken a while to be completely executed as we said over a number of years. And that included making sure that we could get pricing right on all of our for all of our customers. So some of that evidence also flows into our product GP.

Speaker 3

And then as of late, we've continued to gain quite a bit of supply chain efficiencies from coming out of the pandemic, as well as some other cost efficiencies related to supplier rebates, related to negotiations. Those would be some of the key differences between where we are today and where we were in 2019. So can you repeat your second part of the question for me, please?

Speaker 4

Yes. The guidance for gross margins in 24, it's flat at the high end at 39.4. I think you mentioned you'll be lapping 50 basis points of one time price cost helped in 2023. So what are the offsets?

Speaker 3

Yes. So some of the offsets relate to the fact that as we go into this year, we're going to have a softer pricing environment. And based upon that, We want to make sure that we're providing a range such that it's realistic for us to hit also in a softer volume environment for the overall business. And so those are some of the two primary reasons why being essentially flat, We would expect to be closer to that high end. We've got some tailwinds that will continue to normalize after some of the disruptions that we've had over the past few years, specifically supply chain and mix, and that will help us out as well.

Speaker 4

Very helpful. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Tommy Moll with Stephens, please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 5

Good morning and thank you for taking my questions.

Speaker 2

Good morning.

Speaker 5

I wanted to expand on the gross margin conversation with what's perhaps the obligatory question here. But I just want to make sure That I'm tracking the message correctly over time. So if we go back to your Investor Day, the anchor for your high touch business was in that 40 range since that time you've outperformed it significantly and indicated that maybe that was too low a number. And if I'm hearing the message correctly today, In 2024 at the midpoint you're somewhere a little bit north of 41% and 25% and thereafter stable around that range. So I just want to make sure I've tracked all that correctly or if there's anything you'd like to amend there?

Speaker 5

Thank you.

Speaker 2

You've tracked that. I think you tracked that correctly. The only other thing I would add is When we during the Investor Day, when we said 40%, I think we probably knew that there was the supply chain Efficiency is a big bucket. We probably knew that there was a lot of inefficiency. I think we probably maybe have been surprised at how much As we've gotten back to normal, that's been a big tailwind for us.

Speaker 2

And so we probably if we had known, it was just difficult to see all that, we probably would have had a higher number back then Sure.

Speaker 5

Pivoting to the commentary you offered today on service levels Earlier in your remarks, DG, so it sounds like you're back to roughly your own pre pandemic service levels. You've invested and will invest substantially in the capacity and automation and other areas as well. So I'm just curious Strategically, do you feel more confident in leaning into these forms of investment and versus what you've communicated in the past, should we read from today that with that increased confidence, you see this as a repeatable and sustainable advantage that you can repeat pretty consistently to take share? Thank you.

Speaker 2

Yes. And I appreciate the question. In terms of returning to near normal service sales, I would say everything that we directly control is back to normal in terms of our own internal cycle times. Transportation is back to normal. There's still some elongated supplier lead times, which is the reason we're Still probably a little shy of where we were, but from a competitive standpoint, that's all that really matters is a competitive standpoint.

Speaker 2

We're doing quite well. In terms of the investments we're making, We're filling in gaps where we've grown to the point where having buildings in those locations makes sense. And they make sense not only to improve service, but to improve cost in some perspective. So if you think about the Northwest, most of our product today comes out of California, has to clear the mountains and get in there and long haul. We now have enough volume to be able to improve the service dramatically in the Northwest and actually lower transportation costs pretty substantially.

Speaker 2

So we look at all those factors, service and cost and when we make these decisions, but we're very confident And what we've outlined and announced so far that those are the right things to do for the health of the business.

Speaker 5

Thank you, D. G. I'll turn it back.

Speaker 2

Thanks.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Jake Levenson with Melius Research. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 6

Good morning, everyone.

Speaker 2

Good morning, Dick.

Speaker 6

I know You have some margin headwinds here in 'twenty four and there's been obviously a lot of improvement in the last couple of years. But Just on the productivity side, I know, D. J, you touched on a couple of levers Earlier in your prepared remarks, but can you just help us get a sense of the levers that you have or maybe where you're most focused here in 'twenty four that can help offset some of those headwinds?

Speaker 2

Yes. I mean, I'll start and D. If you want to add in, you can. I think the thing to note is that we tend to look at productivity From a core productivity standpoint, so distribution centers, contact centers, seller productivity, all those levers and we really see opportunity across the business. And I think we're going to see really nice core productivity this year.

Speaker 2

The headwinds are more around The growth investments, which we think are absolutely the right thing to do, they're high return growth investments. But we are spending more money in marketing and we're investing in the sales force. And so Those things make it the headline number look a little more challenging. And it's a time and place when we are investing in those things and believe that's right to do, but we're going to continue to get core productivity. It's an evergreen initiative for us to look everywhere in the business.

Speaker 2

And I think We've got a whole bunch of things teed up to improve the productivity of the core of the business.

Speaker 6

Okay. That makes sense. And your comment about the 35% expansion in the square footage in your supply chain, I know Square footage isn't everything, maybe that's not the best way to measure it. But is that really You guys catching up to the growth you've seen over the last couple of years or preparing for the next couple of years or maybe it's a mix, but

Speaker 2

It's a mix. And you think it's just practically if you thought about it, we're a lot bigger than we were in 2019. There was almost no way to actually build buildings productively during the pandemic. You couldn't get things going. And so we were a little bit behind.

Speaker 2

We talked about that in 2022. So part of it's catch up, but a part of it's planning for the future growth as well. And I would say the square footage isn't exactly Capacity because the bulk warehouse portion of those is lower cost and doesn't quite give you as much capacity The other buildings, but certainly Houston and Portland are added capacity similar to the other capacity in the North.

Speaker 6

Great. Thank you. Good luck this year.

Speaker 2

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of David Manthey with Baird, please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 2

Thank you. Good morning, everyone. First off, a couple of quick ones for Dee. What specifically is the range of price expectations you're baking into the 2024 guidance range? And second, on Slide 20, You talk about stable gross margins.

Speaker 2

I'm not clear if you're referring to segment gross margins or consolidated. Could you help me with that?

Speaker 3

Yes. So, hi, Dave. I will start with the U. S. Price that we're focusing on.

Speaker 3

When you think about that, When you think about that outline of flattish, we're expecting price to be between 0% to 1% For the year in the U. S. And on Slide 20 specifically, Stable gross margins really is applying to the total company, and you can also apply that to high touch in some ways as well.

Speaker 2

Okay. And then DG, could you talk about what opportunistic M and A would look like to Grainger today? Yes. I mean, 1st and foremost, I would reiterate that we are an organic growth company and that's where we are focused on most of our energy. We get a lot of looks at things and opportunities.

Speaker 2

I would say that we get 2 types of looks, other distributors, which probably haven't been as interesting to us. And then there are some potential technology investments and things that might be more interesting to us. So we continue to look at A wide range of opportunities in areas that we think are really important to the success of the business, particularly some specific domains that we think We need to be really good at going forward and we might invest in those areas. But as I said, we are primarily an organic growth company at this point. Good to hear.

Speaker 2

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Chris Snyder with UBS. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 7

Thank you. I wanted to ask on the investments that the company are making and D. G, I appreciate All the color that you provided and there's a lot going on. But is there any way that you could maybe bucket Or talk about the investments between the capacity additions and the efficiency drivers that you're making versus The more demand generative investments like the sales coverage and the marketing, anyway just kind of think of those 2 respective buckets? Thank you.

Speaker 2

Yes. So, without getting overly detailed, I would say that the demand generation investments are Typically, SG and A investments, so marketing and seller ads or SG and A investments. Whereas a lot of the capacity investments we're making, productivity investments Or AI investments or technology investments, most of those show up in capital, some show up in expense for sure. But if you think about when we talk about spending $450,000,000 $550,000,000 in capital, the vast majority of that comes from supply chain investments and capacity increases and in technology. And so I would think of it in those terms.

Speaker 2

And technology is building capabilities and advantage in information assets and supporting the growth initiatives in the core business as well, versus marketing and seller more direct spend that go into demand generation.

Speaker 7

Thank you. I appreciate that. And then If we think of the SG and A investments that are kind of more of that demand generation, Can you just maybe talk about the ability to leverage those and grow operating margin over time? Because 2024 is guided to be a pretty supportive year for gross margin, but operating margin is kind of flattish despite the line growth and the stable gross margin because it seems like in some capacity these investments that you're making. Do you think that over time you will leverage those and grow operating margin and maybe 24% is just kind of a pause here?

Speaker 2

Thank you. Yes, Deid talked about it. Yes, we do expecting an SG and A leverage over time and we are probably making more incremental investments in this year than others. So that is probably true. We're also just I would just point out in a fairly flat price environment That SG and A is it's a bit more difficult to get SG and A leverage as well.

Speaker 2

So there's a number of factors going on. But Deedee, do you have any

Speaker 3

The other thing I would point to is just our improvement in return on invested capital. I think that one of the reasons why that's one of the metrics that we talk about, track and are focused on is ensuring that the investments we make, whether they are CapEx Investments or SG and A, based upon how we calculate ROIC, We're very focused on ensuring that they help us deliver and grow at least, It's not operating margin, operating dollar growth as well for us.

Speaker 2

Yes. And the other thing I'd add to that is that Yes, both in marketing and seller coverage, we are very well measured. So we are everything is tested. We don't make the investments slightly. We know exactly what returns are getting.

Speaker 2

So if they're positive return, we will make them even if in the year they might down our SG and A leverage because it's the right thing to do for the overall profitability of the business.

Speaker 7

I appreciate that. All makes sense. If I could just squeeze one last one in. When I look at price mix in the quarter for HiTouch, I think it was only up 40 basis points. I have to think that customer mix was a drag on that.

Speaker 7

I guess any color on what that customer mix headwind was and any way to maybe think about What price as a standalone was in Q4? Thank you, guys.

Speaker 3

Yes. I mean, it was really small. And I think if you go back to We forecasted and should be no surprise what our price cost Outcome will be in Q4. We've been looking at this and talking about it for the last 2 years. If you go back to 2022, We noted that we were going to be significantly price cost positive in that year and it would unwind in 2023, and it did.

Speaker 3

And you saw that and experienced that in the second half of 2023. And so a lot of it is timing. As we know, we talked about price and cost in our business is very lumpy being north of 70% of our business with contract customers and the timing of those things. And so And on a 2 year stack, big essentially neutral and exiting this year, and starting 2024 in a neutral footing, I think is was really important.

Speaker 7

Thank you. I really appreciate that.

Operator

Thank you. Our next comes from the line of Deane Dray with RBC Capital Markets. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 8

Thank you. Good morning, everyone.

Speaker 9

Good morning.

Speaker 8

I'd love to go a little bit deeper on the comments about January getting off to a slower start and we've heard this Recently from a number of companies pointing to the weather as really hampering some of the activity. So if you could size for us what you think that weather impact was? And a related question is the Underlying assumption of MRO for activity for 2024, the Down 0.5% to up 1.5%. Just given the trends we're seeing now in the ISM coming back, new orders going back above 50%. Just It seems like you could see a risk of the upside in that and maybe that's a bit conservative.

Speaker 8

And just take us through that assumption as well, please.

Speaker 2

Yes, sure. So I can take the I mean, I can try to take both of them. I guess the first one, I think there were two factors that made January a slow start. One was that most of the schools were shut, which shows some activity in the 1st week of January, which last year schools opened in mid week. And we noticed that and we noticed that In some of the schools we serve as well as just the broader economy and then obviously cold weather week.

Speaker 2

What I would say is that the last 2 weeks January were very normal for us. And so while there was some slowness, it wasn't in the course of the quarter, it will be very, very small in terms of the impact, but noticeable in a month of course, because it's many weeks, but it's not huge in the grand scheme of things, it's just noise. And so we don't we won't focus too much on that. I think any forecast for the MRO market any year, I think you could argue you could be Risk to the upside or downside, I don't know. This is our current forecast and we have economist internally and externally that we look at and this is the forecast have right now.

Speaker 2

So that's what we're going with. But that too will always change and it will never be right until we know that. So Again, we won't over index on the forecast.

Speaker 8

Got it. And then for D or actually or DG either The outlook for an expected increase in buybacks for 2024, the uptick there, Just what's the expectation in terms of the pace of the buybacks through the year?

Speaker 3

Yes. We've been fairly consistent for a number of years in our buyback Practice is generally under the veil of overall capital allocation strategy, and we look to be in the market all the time Based upon what the price of shares are, we don't try to time the market from a price perspective that always looking to be into the market buying shares. And so generally, we have pretty stable pace across the year for the share buyback. Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Christopher Glynn with Oppenheimer. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 10

Thanks. Good morning and congrats on all the significant workplace culture recognitions, Good indicator of your durability. So I was curious what you're seeing in In terms of product cost deflation that you always try to drive, as distinctive from I think you called out there's Some continuing benefits from the macro level supply chain normalization.

Speaker 3

So, this is Dee. We've gone from a, As you know, over the last year or so, highly cost inflationary environment, so something that is much more muted Today, we're coming down today a much more reasonable or normalized term I would use is what we're seeing. I will say our product management team utilizes the same sets of strategic and tactical activities with our supply base, we want to remain to be a customer of choice for them. And so we're working to ensure that we continue to have advantage price and advantage access to products at the best price possible. So things are getting to more normal level for us today.

Speaker 10

Great. Thanks. And then on the B2C side of Zoro, I think you Mentioned that the unwind there, the headwind would be first half weighted And suggests more neutral comps in the back half. So does that mean you're exiting 23% at about the Sustainable mix?

Speaker 2

Yes. So I think what I would say there is that, obviously as the B2C and B2C like volume shrinks, it becomes less of an impact on the rest of the business and our business customer activity has actually been reasonably healthy through the entire quarter. We do expect some of the decline to be less impactful in the back half of the year. So we should have less drag in the back half of the year than we have in the first of the year from the decline in BDC lifeline.

Speaker 10

That makes sense. Thank you, guys.

Speaker 4

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Ken Newman with KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 11

Hey, good morning guys. Thanks for squeezing me in.

Speaker 2

Good morning.

Speaker 11

I know there's a lot of moving pieces here, But I am wondering if you are seeing or have seen any impacts from some of the Red Sea shipping dynamics? And How are you thinking about shipping and freight expenses in 2024 and how that flows through your OpEx guide for the year?

Speaker 2

So on the Red Sea, we don't have much volume going through that those lanes. Most of our shipping volume comes out of Asia through to the West Coast and then is railed to our network. And so that has often impacted. So we've really seen nothing there. Could you repeat the second half of your question?

Speaker 11

Yes. Just curious as a follow-up to that, How you're thinking about freight expenses in general? I feel I think most companies are seeing those kind of come up here. And How did you see that flowing through your OpEx line as it relates to your guide for the year?

Speaker 2

Yes. I mean, much of our freight most of our freight She goes into our gross profit line. And but we our forecasts haven't changed much given the activity we've seen given the lanes we're in. Certainly things like fuel increases can have an impact And who knows how that's going to play out. But right now, we're actually still in a favorable position relative to a year ago on certainly on ocean freight at this point.

Speaker 2

So we expect that to continue through the 1st part of the year and then we'll see what happens.

Speaker 9

Got it. And then if

Speaker 11

I could just squeeze one more in here. I think you mentioned in the new framework that you expect Zoro and Monotaro I get back to that low teen type of growth range, it's been a tougher couple of years here recently. As I think about The seasonality comments on the first half here kind of unwinding in the first half, is it reasonable to think could you get back to that Low double digit range here within the back half of 'twenty four or is that more of a 'twenty five type of aspirational target?

Speaker 2

Yes, it's probably more of a 25 so to be clear, Monotaro this year will be hitting That already we think it's low double digits, low teens. So that will be close to that for the year and then Zoro will start the year lower than that and we expect them to get a bit better as the year goes along. We probably won't get there by this year, but that be more in out years we think that's the target.

Speaker 11

Very helpful. Thanks.

Operator

Thank you. Our next questions come from the line of Patrick Baumann with JPMorgan. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 12

Good morning, DJ. Dea, congrats on the great year. Just had a couple of questions for Dee on the price timing comments that you noted. Maybe if you could help us better understand first, What you said with respect to Slide 13, did the market take up price in the 4th and you waited for the New Year? Or was this something like in the comps that caused that disparity?

Speaker 2

No.

Speaker 3

I think your Slide 13, you're kind of looking at what we have listed as what we think the market performance has been by quarter?

Speaker 12

It was about the Q4 you had like you noted like a volume share gain of $475,000,000 and that's the same.

Speaker 3

$475,000,000 yes. And so that difference is really that our price in the quarter was lower than the PMI print in the quarter. And so we were just highlighting for you that if you just look at the volume for IP versus our volume, then our share gain would have been $4.75 So there's a difference in the market price As published today, in Q4 versus what we realized, from a price perspective. And the comments I was making earlier about timing is that our timing is not always going to be in line with the timing of price in the market and this quarter was just one example of that. But you also have other examples if you look back over the course of several other quarters, as we've outperformed the market.

Speaker 3

So we try to look at it on a 2 year stack, trying to get to neutral over a longer period of time.

Speaker 12

Okay. And then my follow-up as it relates to the first I think you also mentioned something about price timing as a factor for gross margins being kind of down year over year. So curious if you can give some more color on that To like, did you put through price early last year and you're not doing the same thing this year? Or is it something else?

Speaker 3

Yes. So Yes. No, we always put through price, if price is warranted, early in the year, But it's more like a seasonality question, so I'll probably respond to it in that way. We do expect a lot of The outlook that we've given for 2024 to be back end weighted, we talked a little bit about pieces of it, which was sales starting slower, Tougher comp. Q1 last year was a very strong year for us, which included a whole lot of price in that quarter.

Speaker 3

With a price outlook of 0 to 1, of course, our price for this year, the quarter will be more muted versus that. And we expect price to become more favorable throughout the year and for gross margins to be Relatively stable versus the outlook that we have given. And so that's what I mean when you

Speaker 2

The reality was that if you think back to 2022, we took a budget price mid year that from a 2023 Q1 to 2022 Q1 comparison made 2023 have very high price increases relative to the year before, because we took them in the middle of the year and those so it wasn't all taken January 1 last year, but all the inflation run up in 2022 made last year look a little unusual from a Q1 price increase.

Speaker 3

Okay. Makes sense. Thanks. Yes. Q1 and full year.

Speaker 2

Q1 and full year. Yes, absolutely.

Speaker 3

Great. Thanks a lot.

Operator

Thank you. Our final questions will come from the line of Nigel Coe with Wolfe Research. Please proceed with your questions.

Speaker 9

Thanks. Good afternoon. Dee, you sound like you're suffering. So I feel a little bit guilty if you repeat yourself here. But on the seasonality comment, are you saying gross margins much flatter from quarter to quarter through the year?

Speaker 9

Obviously, normally we see a bit of a seasonal pattern there. So is that the comment? And does that therefore imply that as we go from 4Q to 1Q, we've got a pretty flat Q2Q gross margin structure then. And if it is flat, I just want to understand why that is. I mean, I get the fact that price is coming a bit stronger to the year, but any other factors we need to consider?

Speaker 3

Well, like we've talked a little about freight, we'll continue to get freight and supply chain efficiencies and some product mix. But again, it all starts with the fact We don't expect to have a lot of price in the market this year, just generally so. We expect gross margins to be reasonably consistent from what we talked about all through the year. So that's the basic reason for that, Muted price.

Speaker 9

Okay. Okay. That's clear. And then the comment you made about SG and A, I think you mentioned some SG and A deleverage in the Q1. So Again, it sounds like the model this year is going to be pretty clean in terms of it sounds like SG and A is going to be pretty flat across the quarters.

Speaker 9

Maybe Is that the way you're seeing it? We've got some fundamental investments this year.

Speaker 3

So yes, and A is going to deleverage in the Q1 because we're going to continue, as D. G. Noted, to ramp our investments in marketing and sellers and others and the like. But we do expect leverage will improve as the year progress, flipping to more of a tailwind in the back half of the year for us. And then just if you kind of move down a little bit, we think operating margin in Q1 will be at its lowest point as well.

Speaker 3

And EPS will be flattish year over year in the Q1 as well.

Speaker 9

Splatter year over year. Okay, got it. And since I'm in the last question, I feel like maybe I can just squeeze one more in if I can. The just I want to just clarify the customer mix comment from earlier on in the call. I mean, I noticed the medium sized customers outgrew large customers, so I'd assume that mix would have been positive.

Speaker 9

But if I'm wrong, may I please say that now?

Speaker 3

I missed that last part. I heard you say that. Can you repeat it?

Speaker 9

The customer mix, I'd assume that the maybe customer mix slightly positive, given that medium sized versus large sized dynamic, but if I'm wrong there, please let me know.

Speaker 2

Yes. I think it was basically neutral. We did have you're right, mid sized customers did grow faster than the largest customers. Overall, it was not a meaningful impact as I understand it. Is that right?

Speaker 2

Hi,

Speaker 9

Steve. Yes. Yes.

Speaker 11

Okay. D and I are in different rooms

Speaker 2

and she's sequestered. So we're looking at each other through Okay.

Speaker 9

All right. Thanks guys. Appreciate it.

Speaker 2

Thank you.

Operator

Thank you. We have reached the end of our question answer session. I would now like to turn the floor back over to D. G. Macpherson for closing remarks.

Speaker 2

All right. Sorry, we're a few minutes over. Thanks for joining the call. What I would say is that and we're certainly proud of the results we had in 2023. We are very focused on continuing to drive forward and create value for our customers in 20 24.

Speaker 2

And a lot of that's really the same despite the more muted growth in the market that a lot of that's just a continuation of driving forward the initiatives that matter both a growth perspective and a productivity perspective. And we remain very positive about the outlook and our ability to gain share profitably for years to come. Thanks for the time. Hope you all have a great weekend. Take care.

Operator

Thank you. This does conclude today's teleconference. We appreciate your participation.

Powered by Quartr
Earnings Conference Call
W.W. Grainger Q4 2023
00:00 / 00:00