Booking Q1 2024 Earnings Call Transcript

AlphaStreet
Provided by AlphaStreet
May 2, 2024
Skip to Questions & Answers
Operator

Welcome to the Booking Holdings First Quarter 2024 Conference Call. Booking Holdings would like to remind everyone that this call may contain forward-looking statements which are made pursuant to the safe harbor provisions of the Private Securities Litigation Reform Act of 1995. These forward-looking statements are not guaranteed of future performance and are subject to certain risk, uncertainties and assumptions that are difficult to predict. Therefore, actual results may differ materially from those expressed, implied and forecasted in any such forward-looking statements.

Expressions of future goals or expectations and similar expressions reflecting something other than historical fact are intended to identify forward-looking statements. For a list of factors that could cause Booking Holdings actual results to differ materially from those described in the forward-looking statements, please refer to the safe harbor statements at the end of the Booking Holdings earnings press release, as well as Booking Holdings most recent filings with the Securities and Exchange Commission. Unless required by law, Booking Holdings undertakes no obligation to update publicly any forward-looking statements, whether as a result of new information, future events or otherwise.

A copy of Booking Holdings earnings press release, together with an accompanying financial and statistical supplement is available in the For Investors section of Booking Holdings website, www.bookingholdings.com.

And now, I'd like to introduce Booking Holdings speakers for this afternoon, Glenn Fogel and Ewout Steenbergen. Go ahead, gentlemen.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Thank you and welcome to Booking Holdings first quarter conference call. I'm joined this afternoon by our CFO, Ewout Steenbergen. I am pleased to report a strong start to 2024. Our travelers booked nearly 300 million room nights crossed our platforms in the first quarter, which exceeded our expectations and grew 9% year-over-year. First quarter revenue of $4.4 billion grew 17% year-over-year, an adjusted EBITDA of about $900 million increased 53% year-over-year. Both revenue and adjusted EBITDA were ahead of our first quarter expectations.

Finally, adjusted earnings per share in the first quarter grew 76% year-over-year, helped by improved profit levels, as well as our strong capital return program, which reduced our average share count by 9% versus the first quarter last year. We continue to see resiliency in global leisure travel demand, including healthy growth for travel on the books that's scheduled to take place during our peak summer travel season. Although, a high percentage of these bookings are cancelable and what is on the books today represents a modest percentage of the expected total summer bookings.

As we look ahead to the second quarter, room night growth compared to last year will benefit from the shift in Easter timing.

However, we expect that this will be offset by a less expansion of the booking window and an increased impact from the geopolitical situation in the Middle East. We believe this will result in some deceleration in moonlight growth versus Q1. Ewout will provide further details on our first quarter results and our thoughts about the second quarter.

Over the last few years, we have talked quite a bit about our key strategic priorities, which include building towards our connected trip vision, expanding our merchant offering at Booking.com, developing our AI capabilities and enhancing our Genius loyalty program. These initiatives may seem to be distinct efforts, but I'd like to emphasize they actually all fit together in our ongoing effort to deliver a much better planning, booking and traveling experience for our travelers, while also benefiting our supplier partners.

By creating a much better experience for our travelers and solving more of the challenges they face when planning, booking and experiencing a trip, we believe travelers will choose to book directly and more frequently with us, resulting in increased loyalty over time. We see encouraging early proof points at Booking.com as we have grown the number of total active travelers, while experiencing higher growth in repeat travelers, which speaks to the progress we are making in encouraging customers to book again with us.

In addition, we are seeing increases in the average number of trips booked per traveler, as well as an increasing mix of our room nights that are booked directly with us on direct mix. We are pleased to see the direct booking channel continues to grow faster than room nights acquired through paid marketing channels. While we see paid marketing channels becoming a gradually smaller proportion of our business over time, we think it's important for us to remain proactive in these channels in order to bring new travelers to our platforms, so long as we're able to do so at attractive ROIs.

We believe continuing to improve the experience for our travelers by advancing towards our connected trip vision will help to further drive these positive proof points around loyalty, frequency and direct booking behavior. I'm encouraged to see strong growth in transactions that are connected to another booking from a different travel vertical in a trip. These connected transactions increased by just over 50% year-over-year in the first quarter, though it's important to note that this growth is off of last year's small base.

Connected transactions represented a high single digit percentage of Booking.com's total transactions in Q1. It's great to see more of our travelers choosing to book connected transactions and we believe by providing more value and a better overall experience to those travelers, they may choose to book more trips with us and have a higher likelihood of booking directly with us in the future. Flight is the most frequently booked vertical in a connected transaction outside of accommodations and it is an important component of many of the trips our travelers are booking.

In the first quarter, air tickets booked on our platforms increased 33% year-over-year, driven primarily by the growth of Booking.com's flight offering. We continue to see a healthy number of new customers to Booking.com through the flight vertical and are encouraged by the rate that these customers and returning customers see the value of the other services on our platform.

Winning a traveler's business is never easy because of the high level of competition in our industry, but we are pleased to see that by providing a better way to do it, less friction, better value, a broader selection and great customer service, we are building a customer base that is more likely to choose us. Outside of flights and accommodations, we are seeing strong growth from rental cars and attraction bookings that are part of a connected transaction.

We believe continuing to enhance and expand the attractions vertical has the ability to increase traveler engagement with the app while travelers are in destination and looking for something to do. And we believe that over time, travelers who experience the value we provide for in destination services like attractions will choose to use us more in the future. Bringing all these elements of travel together in a seamless booking experience and unlocking the ability to merchandise across verticals is a capability we have been building at Booking.com over the last several years.

In addition to being a foundational element to our connected trip vision, our merchant offering brings many other benefits to our travelers and partners. For travelers, we provide the ability to pay in many different payment methods and we can offer discounts, incentives and other merchandising opportunities for our supplier partners, our merchant offering enables us to take fraud liability from our partners as part of the services we provide, reduces cancellation rates versus the agency model and over time, we believe we can help to lower payment costs for our partners.

In order to achieve the easier and more personalized experience of the connected trip, we have always envisioned AI technology playing a central role. We believe we are well positioned to leverage this technology given we have built strong teams of AI experts and gained valuable experience from using AI extensively for many years.

In addition, we have proprietary data that can be used to train specific use case models or fine tune large AI models and have the resources and scale required to help build AI powered offerings. As we have discussed before, our teams continue to work hard to integrate generative AI into our offerings in innovative ways, including Booking.com's AI Trip Planner, Pricewise Generative AI travel assistant named Penny and KAYAK's recent release of generative AI powered features and tools.

We will continue to learn from traveler interactions with these tools and enhance our offerings over time. In addition, customer service, which is a critical function that we provide to both our travelers and partners is an area we believe will be meaningfully enhanced by AI advancements. At each of our OTA brands, our teams are actively exploring ways to leverage generative AI technology to improve self service tools, which we believe will reduce live agent contact rates and enable us to answer traveler questions faster. When customers still need to speak with a live agent, we believe that this technology will improve our live agents efficiency by making it easier to access information and document the conversations.

In sum, we believe GenAI will lower our customer service costs per transaction over time and improve the customer experience. Our Genius loyalty program Booking.com also plays an increasingly important role in the multiple elements of travel that we offer, as we expect our travelers will be able to experience the benefits of Genius in each of our travel verticals over time. In addition, bookings in travel verticals outside of accommodations will contribute to a traveler's genius level tier.

We have seen an encouraging number of our rental car supplier partners choosing to adopt the Genius program and we have just begun to test the program in flights and attractions. We are seeing success in moving more of our travelers into the higher Genius tiers of levels two and level three, which require five and 15 bookings in a two year period respectively. We see encouraging behavior from our Genius level two and three travelers, including higher frequency and a higher rate of direct booking than what we see for our overall business.

We will continue to explore opportunities to enhance our Genius loyalty program and deliver more benefits to our travelers with more of our supplier partners electing to participate. What we have mostly been discussing are about our traveler customers. We operate a two sided marketplace and our supplier partners are equally important to us. The success of our business is built on a mutually beneficial and balanced partnership with our millions of hotels, alternative accommodations and other supplier partners around the world.

We strive to be a trusted and valuable partner for all accommodation types on our platform, the majority of which are small independent businesses. We believe that improving the competitiveness and profitability of our smaller partners contributes to the long-term economic health of our sector. And we continue to onboard more, small independent businesses through our alternative accommodation offering at Booking.com and we are benefiting from having more listings available on our platform for travelers to choose from. At the end of Q1, our global alternative accommodation listings were about 7.4 million, which is about a 11% higher than Q1 last year. We are focused on continuing to build on this progress by further improving the product for our supply partners and travelers, particularly in the US.

In conclusion, I am encouraged by the strong first quarter results and the continued long term resilience of leisure travel demand. We continue our work to deliver a better offering and experience for our supply partners and our travelers. We remain confident in our long-term outlook for the travel industry. We are positive about our future and we believe we are well positioned to deliver attractive growth across our key metrics in the coming years.

I will now turn the call over to our CFO, Ewout Steenbergen.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Thank you, Glenn and good afternoon. I'm very excited to join the Booking Holdings team. I look forward to continuing to work with you and David in his new role and the rest of the leadership team to help drive continued future success for our investors, employees, traveler customers and supplier partners.

I will now review our results for the first quarter and provide our thoughts for the second quarter. All growth rates are on a year-over-year basis. Information regarding reconciliation of non-GAAP results to GAAP results can be found on our earnings release. We'll post our prepared remarks to the Booking Holdings investor relations website after the conclusion of the earnings call. Now let's move to the first quarter results.

Our Room nights in the first quarter grew 9%, which exceeded the high end of our guidance by about 3 percentage points,

The higher than expected room night growth was driven by a continued expansion of the booking window, as well as healthy underlying demand with better-than-expected performance in Europe and less of a negative impact from the war in the Middle East than expected.

Looking at our room night growth by region, in the first quarter, Asia was up mid teens, Europe and the rest of the world were up high single digits and US was up low single digit. We're encouraged by the continued progress we are making in strengthening the direct relationships with our travelers.

Over the last four quarters, the mix of our total room nights coming to us through the direct channel was in the mid 50% range and when we exclude our B2B business was in the low 60% range. We have seen both these mixes increase year-over-year in each of those four quarters. We're focused on continuing to increase our direct mix going forward, which we believe will benefit from our efforts to improve the experience for our travelers, including building towards our connected trip vision.

Increasing our direct mix benefits our P&L by driving higher efficiency of our marketing spend as a percentage of growth bookings, while reducing the mix of bookings resourced through paid marketing channels. In our mobile apps, the significant majority of bookings we receive are direct and we continue to see favorable repeat direct booking behavior from consumers in our mobile apps when compared to direct bookings on desktop or mobile web. The mobile apps also allow us more opportunities to engage directly with consumers.

In the first quarter, mobile app mix of about 51% was 5 percentage points higher than the first quarter of 2023. We continue to offer our travelers a broad selection of places to stay and are seeing an increasing mix of our room nights being booked in alternative accommodation properties. For our alternative accommodations at Booking.com, our first quarter room night growth was 13% and the global mix of alternative accommodation room nights was 36%, which was up versus 33% in the first quarter of 2023.

Outside of accommodations, we saw airline tickets booked on our platforms in the first quarter increased 33%, driven by the continued growth of Booking.com's flight offering. First quarter growth bookings increased 10%, which exceeded our expectations. The 10% increase in growth bookings was approximately 2 percentage points higher than the 9% room night growth on an unrounded basis due to about 1% higher accommodation ADRs, plus about one point of positive impact from flight bookings. There was an immaterial impact from changes in FX on our gross bookings growth rate.

Our ADR growth was negatively impacted by regional mix due to a higher mix of room nights from Asia. Excluding regional mix, ADRs were up about 2 percentage points. Similar to comments we have made in the past, we have not seen a change in the mix of hotel star rating levels being booked or changes in the length of stay that could indicate that consumers are trading down. We continue to watch these dynamics closely.

Revenue for the first quarter of $4.4 billion also exceeded our expectations, increasing 17% year-over-year. Revenue as a percentage of gross bookings was 10.1% and improved versus the first quarter of 2023, due mostly to the Easter timing shift, as well as the easier year-on-year take rate compare due to changes in the booking window last year, as mentioned on our first quarter 2023 earnings call. Marketing expense, which is a highly variable expense line increased 6% year over year.

Marketing expense as a percentage of growth bookings was 3.7%, about 15 basis points lower than the first quarter of 2023 due to higher ROIs in our paid channels and a higher mix of direct business. Performance marketing ROIs increased year-over-year helped by our ongoing efforts to improve the efficiency of our marketing spend.

First quarter sales and other expenses as a percentage of gross bookings was 1.6%, about 20 basis points higher than last year, due in large part to a higher merchant mix. Our more fixed expenses on an adjusted basis were up a 11%, which was below our expectation, due primarily to lower G&A expense. We recognize that this fixed expense growth is elevated as we invest in the business, but are fully focused on driving operating leverage from our more fixed expenses and targeting a much lower opex growth level in 2025.

Adjusted EBITDA of approximately $900 million was above our expectations, largely driven by stronger than expected bookings, as well as better than expected marketing efficiency. Adjusted EBITDA was up 53%, including about 20 percentage points of benefit from the shift in easter timing. Note that we expect the first quarter will be our seasonally lowest EBITDA quarter for the year. Adjusted net income of over $700 million resulted in adjusted EPS of $20.39 per share, which was up 76%. Our average share count in the first quarter was 9% below the first quarter of 2023. On a GAAP basis, we had net income of $776 million in the quarter.

Now onto our cash and liquidity position. Our first quarter ending cash and investments balance of $16.4 billion was up versus our fourth quarter ending balance of $13.1 billion, due to the $3 billion debt issuance in the first quarter and $2.6

Billion in free cash flow generated in the first quarter. This was partially offset by the $1.9 billion in capital return, including share repurchases and the dividend we initiated in the quarter, as well as $350 million in additional share repurchases to satisfy employee withholding tax obligations.

Now on to our thoughts for the second quarter. We expect second quarter room night growth to be between 4% and 6%, a deceleration from the fourth quarter, as the first quarter benefited more from the year-over-year expansion of the booking window. We expect the booking window to be closer to the prior year in the second quarter. Additionally, the impact from the ongoing war in the Middle East was less negative than we expected in the first quarter. However, we expect a more negative impact in the second quarter, given the geopolitical situation in April.

April room night growth rate was above the high end of that range and benefited by a couple points from Easter being in March this year versus April last year. Adjusting for Easter, April room night growth was about in line with the high end of that range.

We expect second quarter growth bookings growth to be between 3% and 5%, slightly below room night growth due to about 3 points of negative impact from changes in FX, offset by about 1% higher constant currency accommodation ADRs, plus about 1 point of positive impact from flight bookings. We expect second quarter revenue growth to be between 4% and 6% and for revenue growth to be impacted by about 2 points of negative impact from changes in FX.

Adjusted for the changes in FX, we expect second quarter revenue growth to be in line with second quarter growth bookings growth, as the negative impact from the shift in Easter timing is offset by increasing revenues associated with payments. We expect marketing to be a source of slight deleverage in the quarter, but if you adjust for Easter timing, we expect marketing as a percentage of revenue to be neutral year-over-year. We expect our sales and other expenses to grow faster than revenue in the second quarter, driven by a higher merchant mix.

We expect our more fixed opex to grow faster than revenue in the second quarter due primarily to faster IT expense growth, as we have been investing in new tech platforms and in line with the full year guidance we provided last quarter. We expect second quarter adjusted EBITDA to be between about $1.7 billion and $1.75 billion, down low single digits year-over-year due to about 7 points of pressure from the shift in Easter timing and about 2 points of negative impact on growth from changes in FX. Normalizing for Easter timing and changes in FX, our expectation for second quarter adjusted EBITDA would be for mid to high single digit growth.

In closing, we are pleased with our first quarter results and the healthy leisure demand environment we are seeing. In terms of our outlook for the full year, we're not updating our previous full year commentary at this time. We want to see how the next few months develop before considering any updated commentary. We continue to expect 2024 to be a strong year for the company.

Lastly, I would like to thank all my new colleagues across the company for their hard work and dedication to make these strong first quarter results possible and thank you for your continued commitment towards our shared vision of making it easier for everyone to experience the world.

We'll now move to Q&A and Kathleen, will you please open the lines?

Skip to Participants
Operator

Thank you. [Operator Instructions] Your first question comes from the line of Kevin Kopelman of TD Cowen. Please go ahead.

Kevin Kopelman
Analyst at TD Cowen

Great. Thanks a lot. So a quick one on the guidance. Can you talk about what changed in terms of the shape of the year that you're seeing versus what you expected on the February call and walk us through this kind of changing booking window trends that you're seeing. And then if you could comment on whether it's giving you any concern about the back half or you see it as more of a neutral change? Thanks.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Yes, good afternoon, Kevin. This is Ewout. If you think about the second quarter guidance that we have provided to you, I think a couple of elements that you have to take in consideration. One is, we are expecting a less expanded booking window in the second quarter than we have seen in the first quarter, so there has been a little bit of a pull forward of room nights from the second quarter into our first quarter results. We're expecting more of an impact from the Middle East from what we have seen so far, but in the opposite direction is that Easter is a slight benefit for the second quarter.

There is a little bit of noise so to say in the results quarter-by-quarter, particularly from Easter and the booking window. But if you look at the combined first half year results that we are expecting, so the actuals in the first quarter and the guidance for the second quarter, we believe that the results are really strong and very consistent with the full year guidance that we have provided.

In terms of the comps that you're referring, actually first quarter and second quarter comps are a bit tougher for us and the second half of the year the comps will become easier. So that is actually going to be a benefit during the course of 2024.

Kevin Kopelman
Analyst at TD Cowen

Excellent. Thank you very much.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Mark Mahaney of Evercore. Please go ahead.

Mark Mahaney
Analyst at Evercore ISI

Can I try two questions, please. First, why do you think the ROI is higher in paid marketing channels? Is that just efficiencies you found or you find that overall performance marketing channels, platforms that are out there or just providing a better return on ad spend to their -- to their customers in general? And then secondly, would you quantify at all what percentage of total transactions now are connected? Thank you very much.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

So why don't I say the first part, Mark and I'll let Ewout talk a little bit about why I think we gave away that a very generic term, I'll let him repeat it. So, look, we are pleased with what we're doing with our marketing programs all around everything. And you know, Mark, we've talked about this for many, many years. We view this all holistically and we're always looking for what is the best use of the money, what's the best way to put it to work. And when we find things that work, we put more into it and when we find things that are actually are not incremental and are actually duplicative, we pull it out and say, well, let's not spend the money there. And that's really what we've been doing and I'm not going to get into specific things because obviously it's a competitive advantage to have these things that are better.

But I definitely, definitely love the fact that we are producing some very nice ROIs on our marketing programs. It's really a lot of hard work by a lot of people. So I'm going to send a shout out to them because I know they've done some really good work.

And Ewout, do you want to give a repeat what we've already said once, but go ahead.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Sure. Mark, so the percentage of connected trip as a mix of total transactions at this moment is high single digit and that is growing very rapidly. I think the way we look at it is really in combination with multiple other elements. We're seeing that we're delivering more value for our customers. Therefore we see higher loyalty customers moving up to higher levels of Genius, more repeat customers coming to us. We can provide them more benefits over time. They're buying more from multiple verticals and therefore the connected trip is growing as well. So this is really a flying wheel that we're having here and we're seeing all of these metrics moving in the right direction and they're all interrelated. So we're actually really encouraged by the total pattern of what we're seeing in terms of the added value we deliver to the customer and how it is being recognized by those travelers.

Mark Mahaney
Analyst at Evercore ISI

Thank you, Ewout and thank you, Glenn.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Thanks, Mark.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Justin Post from Bank of America. Please go ahead.

Justin Post
Analyst at Bank of America

Great, thank you. I was wondering if you can give us any update of your regional mix. We get that question all the time and just how it's changed, any region growing faster than others at this point and how it's changed maybe since pre pandemic? And then second, the Digital Service Act in Europe has taken hold. And just wondering if you're seeing any changes in performance marketing channels around that or any disruptions or any opportunities? Thank you.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Thanks, Justin. I kind of missed the second part, let me start with the first part and then Ewout picking up on the other. So regional mix and one of the things that we've been talking about for some years because of the pandemic. The issue has been depending on when the pandemic was in its worst parts and then people coming out of it definitely impacted how we're doing different regional ways. So as we talked in the last year's calls last year, we talked about how Asia had been behind in coming out, but of course we're getting a good comp because they were farther behind and now we're still benefiting somewhat from that. The US if you recall, came out first.

So of course we had a harder comp, so to speak, when we were looking last year. Look, one of the things I've said though, in terms of regional mix and one of the things is, you know, we are very strong in Europe. You also know that I have prioritized that we should be better in the US and that is something that we have been spending money, time, energy and I am really pleased, I've mentioned a couple of times in our previous calls how well we have performed in the US, going back to pre pandemic numbers. And it's just wonderful to see that the effort that we put to work is actually producing result.

We are going to continue to put priority in the US, I said that and one of the areas where I think we've done extremely well is in our alternative accommodations. As you know, we have a very strong alternative accommodation on a global basis. But I've also talked in the past about us being a little bit further behind in the US in alternative accommodations, particularly in types of properties that I think will be helpful in the US. And we are making good progress and we're improving the product and it's giving you a reason that people have supply, the people own the homes such are willing to come now and put them onto our platform too. And you've seen some of our marketing where we've been mentioning more about the alternative accommodations. All those things together are things the reason I believe, we have a great opportunity to continue to increase our share in the US and so now I'm looking forward to.

Ewout, I'll let you pick the rest because I didn't catch the second part.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Yeah and quickly to give a couple of numbers around the regional mix. Europe, high single digit growth in the first quarter, that was above our expectations. Very important that we see even Europe continue to do better than our own internal expectations. Asia, mid teens growth, particularly very strong. China, Japan, Korea, India and Indonesia and then US low single digit growth, as Glenn already mentioned. But we believe that we have done better than the market in the first quarter with our US growth and are on a great trajectory and have many additional opportunities to grow faster in the future in the US.

With respect to your second question regarding the DMA changes, actually if we look at the higher ROIs for our paid channels and the marketing leverage that we're seeing in the first quarter, that is all coming from our own actions, from the improvements we're making, the continuous optimization of our paid marketing approach, as well as the growth of direct channels. We don't see really an impact from the Google DMA changes and I would say that is more neutral for us as a total effect.

Justin Post
Analyst at Bank of America

Thank you. Very, very helpful.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Thanks, Justin.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Doug Anmuth of JP Morgan. Please go ahead.

Douglas Anmuth
Analyst at JP Morgan Cazenove

Thanks for taking the questions. Glenn, just hoping you could perhaps quantify anything on Genius frequency or bookings versus non members. And maybe you can just help us understand what you see in the path of customers as they move into upper Genius loyalty tiers. And then Ewout just to follow-up on your US comments from a few minutes ago, the low single digit room night growth above market, is there anything to point to in that region in particular relative to the faster growth you've seen elsewhere? Thanks.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Hi, Doug. We don't give away numbers in our Genius membership. We don't talk about how many are in different tiers. I can say though how pleased I am and how the whole program continues to grow and that's why we are continuing to expand it.

As I mentioned in my prepared remarks about we are now testing additional verticals, flights, attractions. The idea is that to give more value to the traveler, but it also provides a great opportunity for our supplier partners to get incremental demand when they need it. It's really a symbiotic relationship here, we're working together with our partners to both increase the value of our business, but also increase the value of their business.

Genius is not something somebody has to do. A partner decides to participate and decides how they want to participate because they believe they are actually getting true value out of that and we're going to continue to experiment with it in terms of different ways and sometimes we'll even put value in ourselves to make sure that we are providing the best alternative for any traveler, they should come to us and then they start to come back. And we talked about that in my prepared remarks about as people and Ewout just mentioned it too. As people get more value, as they get more benefit, they see the reason to come back and then they come back not only again and again more frequently, but it's coming back direct and that's the great thing.

And I see this as another reason, I love Ewout using the term, I think he said flywheeling, I use flywheel, but it's the same thing. It's the idea that giving more value will get people to come back more often and that is something I see great opportunity for us.

And I'll let Ewout talk a little bit about the low single digit for the US any more comments he wants to make on that?

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Yeah, there are a couple of additional insights around the US. So what we like particularly is the sequential improvement from the fourth quarter in terms of our growth, particularly within the growth we saw the highest growth for alternative accommodations, which is really encouraging. If you look at US bookers, more international growth than domestic growth. And then again, we really very much believe that US is for us a growth market opportunity. It's fantastic with the skill that we have already today, with all the strategic expansions we're doing in multiple protocols and going more direct to connect the trip, generative AI and many of the other strategic initiatives that we're having, that we're actually having an opportunity to expand our position over the next few years in the US.

Douglas Anmuth
Analyst at JP Morgan Cazenove

Great. Thank you both.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Thanks, Doug.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of James Lee from Mizuho Securities. Oh, sorry, your next question comes from the line of Brian Nowak from Morgan Stanley.

Brian Nowak
Analyst at Morgan Stanley

Great. Thanks for taking my question. Maybe to come back to the last discussion you were having about the US, over the last sort of ten years or so, you've had a lot of strategies in the US between branded, spending, paid search spending, the merchant product and now AI. I guess maybe for either of you, as you sort of think about the next couple of years, what do you sort of think the largest unlock will be to differentiate yourself to drive continued outsized growth within the online travel category in the US?

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Hi, Brian. A couple interesting things about that question. It's interesting when you said online, you kind of limit it to online. I just had the benefit of looking at a research report by an industry report that talked about how much business there is that's not online yet. And seeing that saying, wow, this is still tremendous opportunity for us. I'm speaking specifically about US, but directly to your question. So you're right, we've been doing a lot of things and I will say they all have worked out fairly well given the numbers, the share that we've increased over the time, again going to pre pandemic and I love the way we're doing the way it keeps going. And we're going to continue to grind it out. I've talked about that, I've used that word a number of times in previous calls, now we're grinding it out, just doing incremental changes that are getting us a little bit more and it continues to grow on itself.

But I think your question more, is there going to be something down the road that is going to be transformational instead of just incremental? And I believe that is possible. I believe the things that we are doing with AI, the things that we can do with technology, the way we can do it so that really is different. And I think I hear in your question a little bit of, is there enough differentiation between us and our competitors? And I believe over time we will be doing that. And I believe the things that we can build will make it different. And I talked about how the frustration that travelers have nowadays, even though it's become so much better than it used to be, it's still not good enough. And I believe the use of AI, particularly GenAI and what I'm seeing down through, I'm seeing testing and things that are being done. I believe that over the next few years, it will become much better because of these technological advancements. Our job is to make sure we get it out fast and we are able to provide it to both sides of the marketplace to our supplier partners and our travelers, such as they see the value and they continue to come back and then we begin and I love it. I'm going to be using flywheeling from now on. Thank you.

Brian Nowak
Analyst at Morgan Stanley

Thanks, Glenn.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of James Lee of Mizuho Securities. Please go ahead.

James Lee
Analyst at Mizuho Securities

Thanks for taking my questions, two over here. Can you guys comment about ADR by region and kind of what you're seeing among different markets that you're operating? And also, can you update us on ADR expectation for 2024? Maybe any changes on your prior expectation? I guess lastly, any trend that you see in terms of summer travel season, I guess, especially in Europe, how is that compared to last year? Thanks.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

ADR by regions, James, in the first quarter, what we have seen is, ADRs were up in Europe and were flat in North America and in Asia. So therefore, on a constant currency basis, 1% overall growth in ADRs as we have reported today.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

And to the summer, we -- as I said earlier, I said that we have a healthy growth for travel on the books, that schedule take place during the peak summer. And that's where we're feeling -- I'm feeling pleased about the summer. I'm not going to quantify it though.

James Lee
Analyst at Mizuho Securities

Okay. Thank you.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Stephen Ju of UBS. Please go ahead.

Stephen Ju
Analyst at UBS Group

Okay. Hi, Glenn. Thank you. So, wondering if there is anything you can share about how the folks who have access to a trip planner might be behaving. It seems like there's a lot of potential application here because if they're doing research, then there's top of funnel implications. And then you can theoretically recommend other pieces of the trip as well, so this could theoretically drive greater connected trip activity. So just wondering, you know, this has been out, you know, for a little less than a year. So I'm just wondering what you guys are seeing so far? Thanks.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Yeah, so it's low numbers of people who are using in such and we're continuing to develop and learn all the time the interactions and see how people are using it. So it's a very small number of people compared to the number of people who use our services, but we are continuing to advance it. And I agree with you, this has tremendous potential down the road and I think a lot of people believe that too. In fact, it's very hard to read any article about generative AI and not have in the first paragraph the use case of travel.

It's always right there because we all see how complex the number of permutations, trying to understand what is the best way to do it and using GenAI to simplify it. It's really something that I believe will make a huge difference, albeit it's going to take time. You're not going to see tremendous changes over the next couple of quarters. But I do believe over time this will create a much better way for people to do their planning. They're booking, executing and helping them when they are in destination, which is a really important thing because nobody goes on travel so they can sit in the hotel, they want to do stuff and we want to be able to provide that to them too. And bring, as I said, about all the elements we've talked about, all the initiatives into one holistic system that enabled it to be a better experience for our traveler customers. I believe that just has tremendous opportunity for us.

Stephen Ju
Analyst at UBS Group

Thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Lee Horowitz of Deutsche Bank. Please go ahead.

Lee Horowitz
Analyst at Deutsche Bank Aktiengesellschaft

Great. Two if I could. Ewout, there remains sort of robust debate on sort of what the structural growth algorithm is for online travel at this point. I guess in your early experience of booking, what strikes you as perhaps the most compelling areas that you could put a dollar of investment to work in order to drive faster revenue growth for longer, that maybe comes in above investor expectations. And maybe one on fixed opex, obviously your fixed opex basis is up materially relative to 2019, particularly when you compare it to bookings growth relative to 2019. So I guess maybe what has shifted in the business that has perhaps made it a bit more capital intensive at this point or necessitating sort of greater headcount to sort of accomplish the goals that you guys want. Thanks so much.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Yes, thanks, Lee. So first, your question about structural growth. So I am really super positive about the outlook for the company, why this is of course a phenomenal company, super high quality, very successful and I very much believe that we will be able to grow in the future faster than GDP, shift of offline to online bookings, I think overall also consumers that will spend more on experiences than on material goods. And then a number of areas that I believe actually, in my view, now being six, seven weeks here in the position that are really underestimated for the company. So first, let me talk about direct.

I think this is a company now that is completely has a complete game changer with respect to the share of direct. We're not only dependent on paid channels anymore and that it is now in the low 60% range for the B2C business is really important. And we are keeping those customers with us and we have talked about it now before in previous questions of really adding more value and more of those travelers coming back to the app booking direct to us and the benefit we are having with that.

The other is the opportunity we have with respect to alternative accommodations. I think, again, this is completely not well understood and underestimated. We are actually, in terms of size, two-thirds of the largest player in this space and we're growing faster in most of the last eight quarters and we still have a lot of opportunity to further develop our offering.

But the fact that we are combining traditional accommodations and alternative accommodations on a platform and having travelers really being able to go from one to the other, sometimes to go in, I want to book one type of accommodation and they end up booking a completely different type of accommodation. And then the last is GenAI, Glenn, was just commenting on this. I have to say, I think the strategic benefit we have in terms of our capital investments we can make, as well as the quality of the data, because in generative AI, it's not so much about the language models.

The data that go into the language models is strategically probably the biggest differentiator. And we have a really advantage with respect to the data because of all the different ways that we touch travelers and partners and other stakeholders in the travel industry. So therefore, I'm really very positive and optimistic about the structural growth opportunities for the company over the next couple of years.

Quickly, about fixed opex, I think that has to do with a couple of strategic expansions that the company has done, multiple verticals moving in payments, but that is actually linked to your previous question that will help drive future growth for the company. So that's actually a good thing. But as we have said, we're targeting to lower the growth of fixed opex from 2025 onwards and you will see more operating leverage from that over the next few years.

So this year we'll still have some end finalization of some of the investments, for example, about some of the tech platforms. But then from next year you will see more operating leverage coming in from all of those investments we have been making.

Lee Horowitz
Analyst at Deutsche Bank Aktiengesellschaft

Helpful perspective. Thank you.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Thanks, Lee.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of John Colantuoni from Jefferies. Please go ahead.

John Colantuoni
Analyst at Jefferies Financial Group

Great. Thanks for taking my questions. Just wanted to ask about underlying room night trends. Just talk about in the first quarter, sort of the size of some of the transitory impacts that you called out, like Easter shift, geopolitical disruption and the booking window and sort of how that shakes out to how you think about underlying trends in the business. And second, on the attractions offering, can you talk about the investments that you've made so far and how your supply is today versus where you need it to be over time to sort of open up the full potential of that opportunity? And our understanding is that, attractions are often booked closer to the trip date, which requires getting the traveler back to the app. Talk about how you're sort of looking to drive a solution to that dynamic and how the connected trip offering could help drive that behavior over time? Thanks.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Great. Thanks for taking my questions. Just wanted to ask about underlying room night trends. Just talk about in the first quarter, sort of the size of some of the transitory impacts that you called out, like Easter shift, geopolitical disruption and the booking window and sort of how that shakes out to how you think about underlying trends in the business. And second, on the attractions offering, can you talk about the investments that you've made so far and how your supply is today versus where you need it to be over time to sort of open up the full potential of that opportunity? And our understanding is that, attractions are often booked closer to the trip date, which requires getting the traveler back to the app. Talk about how you're sort of looking to drive a solution to that dynamic and how the connected trip offering could help drive that behavior over time? Thanks.

John, with respect to your first question, room nights dynamics in the first quarter. So positives here compared to our original guidance for the first quarter were the fact that the booking window was expanding and that we're able to pull some room nights bookings from the second quarter into the first quarter. Healthy demand in Europe and Europe was stronger than we anticipated, as we mentioned before and less of an impact from the Middle East and you saw, excluding the Middle East impact, actually the result was exactly the same. So there was no material impact from the Middle East.

Easter was a negative, a small negative, but that was, of course anticipated in the guidance that we provided before.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

So on attractions, it's a good question to ask because we haven't talked about it a lot in the past. Attractions is mostly supplied through third parties. So we have arrangements with companies like Viator or Klug or Amusement and we get the supply that way. In addition and we don't talk about this much at all either, we also have FareHarbor which if you may recall we acquired that. Think of it as sort of the open table for a small and medium size attractions because good loop into those attractions. We have priorities though. We can be anything, but we can't be everything and we definitely can't be everything all at once. So the priorities have been get the flight stuff up, get that one, that's the biggest thing get that going well first and then we have making sure that we have the ground transportation, make sure all that stuff is.

Now our people attraction, they also want to have a lot of emphasis too and they are doing a great job building it out and we talked a little bit about that and that's going to come in as part of the overall connected trip because as you point out, people don't generally book their attractions far, far in advance. In fact, a lot of them want to book it when they're actually in destination and that's why I love the fact of the increased amount of use of our app, because that's like having your travel agent in your pocket and being able to -- we're able to send them great offers, great ideas, so they go right to it and check something out and can they get something better? And that's why we're bringing that into our Genius program for people who have an attraction business and want to get that incremental demand, we can push something to a customer who's in destination and give them something that will bring them to that particular supplier.

All over, it's a tremendous opportunity down the road. We have yet to even really scratch the possibilities with that and that's just another reason why I see just tremendous opportunity for us as we continue to roll on.

John Colantuoni
Analyst at Jefferies Financial Group

Thanks so much.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Ron Josey from Citi. Please go ahead.

Ron Josey
Analyst at Smith Barney Citigroup

Great. Thanks for taking the question. I want to ask maybe a follow-up on alternative accommodations here, just given how much faster overall room nights are growing. And Ewout, you talked a little bit about this as well as Glenn, but I wanted to hear more about the supply side, the 7.4 million properties on the site, are these higher quality than maybe what you've seen in the past? They differentiated from other platforms given that are available out there. And Ewout, you made a good mention earlier just that with booking offering both alternative accommodations and traditional, that's an advantage. I'd love to hear your thoughts on what you're seeing from a consumer perspective, those that book both and then the mix between that going forward between those two bookings. Thank you.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

So let me first take the second part of the question in terms of alternative and traditional accommodations. We're actually not so much separating in our thinking one versus the other because we believe that our unique proposition is that we're putting both in the same way on our platforms because it is an artificial separation, as we are seeing many consumers are looking for both. They want to alternate, look at different alternatives. They want to compare and often if they start to look for a traditional hotel, they maybe end up with an apartment they want to rent as an alternative accommodation or the other way around.

So actually, the way we look at it is, we think it's actually really strong to bring all of this proposition together and have really a combined offering to our traveler customers.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

In terms of quality and I like to think that the inventory we have is high quality, obviously comes at different price points. It is a complete range and you may not be surprised that lower priced things may not be as luxurious as the higher priced things. But I think we cover the gamut, but we don't have enough of certain types in certain areas and I've talked about this before. We're entering close to the summer and I look at, I live in the New York metropolitan area and I'm looking, do we have enough of these high end homes in the Hamptons? And I don't think we do and I look at some of our competitors, I see more, I look at that as opportunity for us, though, because we're doing so well, yet we don't have all the different types of accommodations and the quantity that I want to have it at.

It's great that we are as big as we are, but I absolutely see no reason. We shouldn't be significantly bigger throughout every geographical area. Look, our base was Europe, so we are very, very competitive. We have great inventory, all types there. But I've talked about the US and that's an area we continue to do more work and I mentioned earlier, I see us making great progress there.

Ron Josey
Analyst at Smith Barney Citigroup

Thank you, Ewout. Thank you, Glenn.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Thank you.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Jed Kelly of Oppenheimer. Please go ahead.

Jed Kelly
Analyst at Oppenheimer

Hey, great. Thanks for taking my question. Just following up on that last point, Glenn. How do you think about getting more of that single unit inventory? Is it connecting more with property managers, the PMS systems? And then my second question is, just how should we view the big events in Europe this year, this summer in travel, particularly around the Olympics, impacting demand or how people would travel? Thanks.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Sure. So, yes and we definitely have -- you're not surprised, the fact that it's easier to get more inventory when you go to some of the managers who have significant number of the inventory you're looking for and there is multi property managers are the place where we definitely assume more emphasis and we have not until very recently, really spent a lot of time trying to do it in the low, you know, trying to go for individuals and try and bring them in too. There's no doubt, though, over time, we have to make sure to make an effort to everybody and that means making sure that we are providing a platform that a supplier really likes to use and I saw something recently, just to give you an example.

It turns out that until fairly recently, it was hard for some of our big managers to be able to reconcile the payments with individual properties and we improved that significantly recently and that's a reason, so it's okay, now I'll do that. And I can go through a whole bunch of different individual things that, well, by themselves may not be so big as a whole, they end up saying, yeah, I will now be more than happy to get incremental demand from Booking.com because I find it easy and helpful.

If somebody is in to make business, to make money, you definitely never want to have your property empty, that zero revenue you're never going to get back, that inventory expires. So that's why people are always looking to try and get more demand. As long as we provide them with demand and we provide them with a platform that they find easy to use and helpful, they will come to us. In regards to the summer and things like Paris and the Olympics stuff like that, well, it's always a mystery what's going to happen with the Olympics. I've been here now 24 years, so I've been through a whole bunch of Olympics and thought it was going to be, this is what's going to happen and then something else happens.

Here's the big point, let's not concentrate too much on one individual event, the last for a couple of weeks. I continue to say the important way to view value of this company is the long run. What have we done? What have we done over the last 24 years here? Continue to increase the value, bring in more customers and more suppliers and continue to produce more cash flow for our investors. That's the way we've done in the past and what we do in the past and how the Paris Olympics go, I really, I can't guess, but I guess as good as yours and I don't think that's something that I'd spend a lot of time worrying about.

Jed Kelly
Analyst at Oppenheimer

Thank you.

Ewout Steenbergen
Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer at Booking

Thanks, Jeff.

Operator

Your next question comes from the line of Tom White from D.A. Davidson. Please go ahead.

Tom White
Analyst at D.A. Davidson

Great. Thanks for taking my question. Just one, I wanted to follow up on some of the prior questions on the US market. I was hoping you could kind of comment on maybe the relative unit economics of your US accommodations business today versus in Europe. Obviously the Booking.com brand here is well known, but less well known than in Europe and so maybe there's like a heavier kind of marketing load per room night here, but the ADRs here are nice and high, but then again, maybe the take rates are lower. So I'm just kind of curious directionally how accommodation kind of unit economics in the US stack up versus Europe at the moment and maybe where you kind of see that going over the next few years? Thanks.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Yeah, we don't disclose much more than giving you these regional growth rates and we don't go any further than that in terms of detail and I don't think we'll be starting that right now. I understand your reason for asking, but for a reason of competitiveness and such, we're not going to break this down any further than that.

Tom White
Analyst at D.A. Davidson

Okay.

Operator

Thank you. That concludes our Q&A session. I will now turn the conference back over to Glenn Fogel for closing remarks.

Glenn Fogel
Chief Executive Officer at Booking

Thank you. I want to thank our partners, our customers, our dedicated employees, our shareholders and I especially want to thank Ewout for joining the team. Ewout, thank you very much. We greatly appreciate everyone's support as we continue to build on the long-term vision for our company. Thank you and good night.

Operator

[Operator Closing Remarks]

Corporate Executives
  • Glenn Fogel
    Chief Executive Officer
  • Ewout Steenbergen
    Executive Vice President and Chief Financial Officer
Analysts

Alpha Street Logo