Hard disk drives (HDDs) were long seen as a sunsetting technology, with flash providing faster but more expensive alternatives. However, everything has changed with the proliferation of generative AI. Many of the processes vital to AI functioning require significant quantities of data, all of which must be stored. Hyperscalers are finding that much of their stored data does not need flash-speed accessibility, but rather a durable and inexpensive option.
Re-enter HDDs. Two primary U.S.-listed companies dominate the HDD market: Seagate Technology NASDAQ: STX and Western Digital Corp. NASDAQ: WDC. Both are reckoning with sold-out capacity, longer lead times, rising prices, and similar catalysts that have not impacted this industry in many years. At the same time, both stocks have seen sharp rallies this year—STX by over 90% and WDC by over 70%. While both seem to be good bets provided that the AI data demand continues, the companies do offer different approaches that may help investors distinguish one from the other.
Seagate's Bet Is on Leading HAMR Technology
For Seagate, the appeal lies in its heat-assisted magnetic recording (HAMR) technology. The company has spent years and billions of dollars developing this tech, which utilizes a small laser to heat the disk surface, enabling higher-density data writing.
Seagate Technology Stock Forecast Today
12-Month Stock Price Forecast:$1,000.8891.96% UpsideModerate BuyBased on 28 Analyst Ratings | Current Price | $521.39 |
|---|
| High Forecast | $1,600.00 |
|---|
| Average Forecast | $1,000.88 |
|---|
| Low Forecast | $325.00 |
|---|
Seagate Technology Stock Forecast DetailsThe bet seems to be paying off—the company's Mozaic platform provides 30-terabyte-plus drives to a long list of major cloud customers, with potential for increased capacity in future products. Crucially, HAMR allows the company to increase storage capacity without a proportional increase in the number of drives required, which should help to lower the cost per terabyte.
For hyperscalers, a lower cost per terabyte means lower costs thanks to fewer drives, racks, and lower power demands overall. This may be part of the reason why Seagate is moving toward a build-to-order model for larger customers, a decision that has boosted gross margins and led to a record Q1 fiscal 2027, including 61% year-over-year (YOY) revenue improvement and non-GAAP earnings per share (EPS) that almost tripled over the same period.
Still, Seagate's increasing reliance on data center demand—which accounted for 90% of its shipped capacity last quarter—may give some investors reason for concern. The question is whether the company's recent moves to boost shareholder value by increasing its dividend (it now pays a yield of 0.56%) and anticipating additional share buybacks will be enough to offset any hesitation about the risk of data center demand collapsing.
For the time being, analysts see Seagate as a strong prospect, with 23 Buy ratings and just five Holds. Even after its significant rally so far in 2026, the consensus analyst price target exceeds $1,000, implying substantial additional upside.
Western Digital May Be a Cleaner Pure Play on HDDs
The better part of the last two years has been a transition period for Western Digital since the February 2025 spin-off of its flash memory business as Sandisk Corp. NASDAQ: SNDK. The shift leaves Western Digital as a cleaner bet on HDDs in particular and has helped the company to improve its financials because of the volatility and capital-intensive nature of its flash business.
Western Digital Stock Forecast Today
12-Month Stock Price Forecast:$591.04108.54% UpsideModerate BuyBased on 28 Analyst Ratings | Current Price | $283.42 |
|---|
| High Forecast | $1,050.00 |
|---|
| Average Forecast | $591.04 |
|---|
| Low Forecast | $200.00 |
|---|
Western Digital Stock Forecast DetailsSince the separation, Western Digital has reinstated a dividend and offers a modest yield of 0.24%; like Seagate, it is committing itself to returning value to shareholders.
The spin-off also allows investors to see more clearly how Western Digital's HDD business is thriving thanks to data center demand. Revenue surged by 55% YOY last quarter, non-GAAP gross margin climbed to 58.1%, and non-GAAP EPS increased by 161% over the prior-year period. The company projects visibility for strong demand through 2031.
When it comes to technology, Western Digital's approach is different from Seagate's. Instead of HAMR, it has looked for energy-assisted techniques, UltraSMR recording, and OptiNAND, which utilizes a small amount of flash to boost drive capacity. The company is already qualifying HAMR drives and expects production to ramp in 2027, but for now its products remain competitive as-is.
The importance of HAMR may dictate whether one or the other of these companies emerges as a true leader in the future, but for the time being both are enjoying the benefits of being essentially a duopoly in a fairly niche industry. Investors can look for differences in the two companies' approach to technology, but both face rising valuations and major momentum into the end of the year. If hyperscalers continue to look for cost-per-terabyte deals, Seagate's HAMR may give it an edge. On the other hand, if investors want a simpler way to play the current HDD technology, Western Digital's post-spin-off structure may be compelling.
Before you consider Western Digital, you'll want to hear this.
MarketBeat keeps track of Wall Street's top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. MarketBeat has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on... and Western Digital wasn't on the list.
While Western Digital currently has a Moderate Buy rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.
View The Five Stocks Here
The space race is growing fast, and you don’t have to have gotten in early on SpaceX to profit. This report shows seven space stocks you can buy today that may grow as rockets, satellites, defense, space internet, and new space technology become more important.
Get This Free Report
Continue following MarketBeat
Add MarketBeat as your preferred source on Google to see our latest stories in your feed.
Like this article? Share it with a colleague.
Link copied to clipboard.