Zebra Technologies Q4 2023 Earnings Call Transcript

Presentation

[Operator]

Good day, and welcome to the Fourth Quarter and Full Year 2023 Zebra Technologies Earnings Conference Call. [Operator Instructions] Please note, this event is being recorded.

I'd now like to turn the conference over to Mike Steele, Vice President, Investor Relations. Please go ahead.

[Michael Steele, Vice President, Investor Relations at Zebra Technologies]

Good morning and welcome to Zebra's fourth quarter conference call. This presentation is being simulcast on our website at investorszebra.com and will be archived there for at least one year. Our forward looking statements are based on current expectations and assumptions and are subject to risks and uncertainties. Actual results could differ materially and we refer you to the factors discussed in our SEC filings.

During this call, we will reference non-GAAP financial measures as we describe our business performance. You can find reconciliations at the end of the slide presentation and in today's earnings press release. Throughout this presentation, unless otherwise indicated, our references to sales performance are year-over-year on a constant currency basis and exclude results from acquired businesses for the 12 months following the acquisition.

This presentation will include prepared remarks from Bill Burns, our Chief Executive Officer; and Nathan Winters, our Chief Financial Officer. Bill will begin with our fourth quarter results and actions we are taking. Nathan will then provide additional detail on the financials and discuss our 2024 outlook. Bill will conclude with progress we are making on advancing our enterprise asset intelligence vision. Following the prepared remarks, Bill and Nathan will take your questions.

Now let's turn to Slide 4 as I hand it over to Bill.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Thank you, Mike. Good morning and thank you for joining us. Today we would discuss our results, the demand environment and progress on actions we are taking to optimize our cost structure and drive sales as demand recovers. As expected, our fourth quarter performance was impacted by continued broad-based softness across our end markets and regions, which resulted in a significant decline in sales and profitability. For the quarter, we realized sales of $1 billion, a 33% decline from the prior year and adjusted EBITDA margin of 15.4%, a 7 point decrease and non-GAAP diluted earnings per share of $1.71, a 64% decrease from the prior year.

Although we experienced declines across all product categories, services and software were a bright spot in the quarter. From a sequential perspective, we realized Q4 sales growth from Q3 as demand trends stabilized. Overall profitability was primarily impacted by expense deleveraging on lower sales volumes and a charge to renegotiate a supplier contract. However, as a result of our cost restructuring actions and inventory management initiatives, we realized a significant sequential improvement in profitability and free cash flow.

Turning to Slide 5. I'd like to update you on our actions to address and mitigate the impacts of the current demand environment and position ourselves for long-term growth. As referenced in our earnings release, we have expanded the scope of our previously announced cost reduction plan and now expect $120 million of net annualized operating savings, an increase of $20 million from our last update, which we expect to implement by mid 2024. Our previously announced actions were substantially completed in the fourth quarter enable us to realize approximately $50 million of savings in 2023. On the supply front, we continue to work with our contract manufacturers to draw down component inventories and we are substantially complete with renegotiations of long-term supply commitments.

In Q4, we renegotiated a 2021 agreement with the key electronic component supplier incurring a $10 million expense. The revised agreement cancels a portion of the multiyear volume commitment and increases purchasing flexibility. We have also reallocated resources to accelerate growth in underpenetrated markets, including Japan along with government and manufacturing sectors and to address new automation use cases with RFID and machine vision. We expect our actions to improve profitability and drive sales growth as our end markets recover. We saw double-digit declines across each of our end markets for both Q4 and full year as many customers navigate a challenging environment and absorb capacity they built out during the pandemic to address the spike in ecommerce activity.

On Slide 6, we highlight secular trends that we expect to drive long-term growth, including labor and resource constraints, real time supply chain visibility, track and trace mandates, and increased consumer expectations. These are all focused areas in my conversations with our customers. Entering 2024, distributor inventories are aligned with current demand. Although we are seeing some improvement in order activity, we are not yet seeing signs of a broad market recovery remain cautious in our planning. Consequently, we continue to take an agile approach to navigating this uncertain environment and remain disciplined with respect to our cost structure and capital allocation.

I will now turn the call over to Nathan to review our Q4 financial results and discuss our 2024 outlook.

[Nathan Winters, Chief Financial Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Thank you, Bill. Let's start with the P&L on Slide 8. In Q4, sales decreased 33% with distributor destocking accounting for more than one quarter of the decline. We saw double-digit sales declines across our regions, major product categories and customers of all sizes. Our asset intelligence and tracking segment declined 33.6% primarily driven by printing. Enterprise visibility and mobility segment sales declined 32.7% led by data capture and mobile computing. On a positive note, we drove services growth with strong attach and renewal rates. From a sequential active, total Q4 sales were $53 million higher than Q3 despite a similar magnitude of distributor inventory destocking due to modest improvement in demand.

Adjusted gross margin decreased 100 basis points to 44.6% primarily due to expense deleveraging from lower sales volumes and the $10 million charge mentioned earlier associated with the renegotiation of a supplier agreement, all of which were partially offset by higher services and software margin and cycling premium supply chain costs in the prior year. Adjusted operating expenses delevered 670 basis points as a percent of sales. The impact was mitigated by more than $20 million of net savings in the quarter from our restructuring actions. This resulted in fourth quarter adjusted EBITDA margin of 15.4%, a 710 basis point decrease. Non-GAAP diluted earnings per share was $1.71, a 64% year-over-year decrease. Increased interest expense contributed to the decline offset by a lower tax rate from executing on a global tax strategy.

Turning now to the balance sheet and cash flow on Slide 9. We ended the quarter at a 2.5 times net debt to adjusted EBITDA leverage ratio, which is at the top end of our target range. We generated $102 million of free cash flow in Q4 and had approximately $1.1 billion of capacity on our revolving credit facility as of year end providing ample flexibility. The full year 2023 negative free cash flow of $91 million was unfavorable to the prior year primarily due to lower operating profit, higher interest and tax payments, restructuring actions and previously announced settlement payments, all of which were partially offset by lower incentive compensation payments.

Let's now turn to our outlook. We entered 2024 with distributor inventory levels aligned with recent demand trends and improved backlog driven by modest year end budget spending into January from certain retailers. For Q1, we expect a sales decrease between 17% and 20% compared to the prior year. This outlook assumes continued declines across our major product categories particularly printing and a 50 basis point favorable impact from FX. We anticipate Q1 adjusted EBITDA margin to be approximately 18% driven by expense deleveraging from lower sales volume, partially offset by lower premium supply chain costs. Non-GAAP diluted earnings per share are expected to be in the range of $2.30 to $2.60. Q1 sales and profitability are expected to sequentially increase from Q4 as distributor inventories and end market demand have stabilized and we have realized incremental benefit from cost actions.

For the full year 2024, we expect sales to be in the range of a 1% decline and 3% growth. Although we are beginning to see signs of improvement in order activity, we are not yet seeing signs of a broad market recovery. Consequently, we are taking a cautious approach to our guide until we have increased visibility to a sustained recovery in demand. Adjusted EBITDA for the full year 2024 is expected to be approximately 19%. We expect our restructuring actions and other profitability initiatives to drive improvement through the year delivering EBITDA margin of 20% in the second half. We remain cautious in our spending and continue to take an agile approach to navigating the environment.

We expect our free cash flow in 2024 to be at least $550 million including the impact of our final $45 million settlement payment in Q1. We remain focused on right-sizing inventory on our balance sheet driving 100% cash conversion over a cycle and prioritizing debt pay down in the near-term. Please reference additional modeling assumptions shown on Slide 10.

With that, I will turn the call to Bill to discuss how we are advancing our enterprise asset intelligence vision.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Thank you, Nathan. As you look towards the long-term opportunity for Zebra, our future is bright. Our solutions remain essential to our customers' operations and we are well positioned to benefit from secular trends to digitize and automate workflows. We are focused on advancing our enterprise asset intelligence vision by elevating Zebra as a premier solutions provider through a comprehensive portfolio of innovative solutions that demonstrate our industry leadership. We empower workers to execute tasks more effectively by navigating constant change in near real time utilizing insights driven by advanced software capabilities, such as intelligent automation, artificial intelligence, machine learning and prescriptive analytics. By transforming workflows with our proven solutions, enterprises can improve the experience of frontline workers and customers.

As you can see on Slide 13, customers leverage our technology to optimize workflows for the on-demand economy. Our solutions empower enterprises to increase collaboration and productivity and better serve their customers, shoppers and patients. I would like to high highlight some recent wins by our team. A leading North American retailer selected 30,000 Zebra mobile computers and our device tracker solution for customer order fulfillment and fresh food inventory tracking. This competitive win was secured by our ability to deliver higher productivity along with superior data capture performance and network connectivity.

A North American retailer refreshed 60,000 mobile printers and related accessories to enable frequent product pricing updates across various locations. This retailer has a long history with Zebra across our broad portfolio demonstrating the value they see in our hardware and software solutions coupled with our exceptional post sales support. The European Postal Service purchased more than 10,000 Zebra mobile computers to facilitate proof of delivery and package tracking. This organization's decision to replace a competitor was driven by superior product performance and enhanced cybersecurity features.

A European field service organization providing public housing repairs selected Zebra for both mobile computers and tablets to replace consumer devices that had been in place for three product generations. Zebra secured the win by demonstrating a customer first strategy by addressing their unique facial recognition and authentication challenges. And finally, a large retailer in our Asia Pacific region selected Zebra scheduling software to be utilized on Zebra mobile computers. Zebra's solution was selected over our competitors based on the capabilities of our software and our trusted partnership.

Slide 14 highlights Zebra's value proposition for retailers, which was showcased at the National Retail Federation Trade Show in January. Alongside our partners, we demonstrated how our innovative solutions help retailers solve their most pressing challenges and drive increased performance by optimizing inventory, engaging associates and elevating the customer experience. As retailers address e-commerce growth, the expansion of anywhere fulfillment and consumers' demand for hyper-convenience, Zebra solutions provide a performance edge for retail associates. Our demonstrations included next generation checkout solutions with machine vision, loss detection with RFID, a mobile computing AI assistant along with other innovative solutions.

In our booth, office depot shared how our solutions address their workflow challenges. This includes Zebra's workforce optimization software boosting operational efficiency of associates and delivering faster buy online, pickup and store order fulfillment. The combination of Zebra's software and mobile computers is driving associate productivity and engagement along with improved customer satisfaction.

In closing our long-term conviction and our strong business fundamentals remains unchanged and we are well positioned to benefit from trends to digitize and automate workflows. We are elevating our position with customers through our innovative portfolio of solutions while our cost and go to market actions are positioning us well for profitable growth as our end markets recover.

I will now hand it back to Mike.

[Michael Steele, Vice President, Investor Relations at Zebra Technologies]

Thanks, Bill. We'll now open the call to Q&A. We ask that you limit yourself to one question and one follow up so that we can get to as many of you as possible.

Questions and Answers

[Operator]

[Operator Instructions] And today's first question comes from Tommy Moll with Stephens. Please go ahead.

[Tommy Moll, Analyst at Stephens]

Good morning and thank you for taking my questions.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Good morning, Tommy.

[Tommy Moll, Analyst at Stephens]

I believe it was Bill who made the comment about the need to absorb some excess capacity in the e-commerce landscape. And I'm curious based on your discussions with end users in that ecosystem, do you have any visibility into when most of that capacity will be absorbed? Is there any assumption in your 2024 outlook about a return to more normal levels of spending there? Thank you.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah, Tommy. I think that we've clearly seen that retail IT budgets have been under pressure and the retailers overall certainly sweating assets, but also this idea of customers absorbing capacity not just in e-commerce, but also in transportation and logistics as well. And they built out significant capacity during the pandemic believing that ultimately the growth trajectory would continue off those rates. And now we've seen kind of a reset in both e-commerce continuing to grow obviously and parcel delivery both kind of resetting to pre pandemic levels and growing from there.

So we've seen some positive signs in the e-commerce side where some of that capacity has been used off and that we're beginning to see orders from those ecommerce providers that need and have continued demand now. So we're seeing that coming to an end on some of the e commerce providers. We're seeing across transportation and logistics still a challenge in volumes of parcel delivery. And we're seeing the T&L providers really taking this as an opportunity to kind restructure their businesses and think about how to be more effective and more efficient in their delivery mechanisms. We saw the same in e-commerce over the last year plus, but I think we're coming through it in e-commerce. Still T&L challenge there as we're continuing to see is the results around parcels being still remain challenged. So I would say coming to an end in e-commerce, but still challenging in the build out across e-commerce.

[Tommy Moll, Analyst at Stephens]

Thank you, Bill. Yeah. Thank you. And one point I wanted to clarify, Nathan, I think in your comments you talked to an improving backlog in January and that there were certain retail related orders that drove that. But could you correct the record there if I got it wrong and just give us any more detail there? Thank you.

[Nathan Winters, Chief Financial Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. No, Tommy, I think if you look, we did end the quarter, I'd say, back at pre pandemic levels entering the quarter from a backlog perspective where it was a little bit more depressed as we went into Q3 and Q4. And that was primarily driven by some of the uptick we saw in year end spend that we were able to ship here in the early part of Q1 driving some of the sequential improvement from Q4 to Q1. So I think again not to the backlog levels we were at a few years ago during maybe peak of the supply chain challenges, but definitely sequential improvement with some of the incremental volume as well as getting your inventory in the channel right-sized. So again, we feel good about the backlog we have entering the first quarter relative to the guide.

[Tommy Moll, Analyst at Stephens]

Great. Thank you both. I'll turn it back.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question comes from Brad Hewitt with Wolfe Research. Please go ahead.

[Brad Hewitt, Analyst at Wolfe Research]

Hey, thanks. Good morning, everybody.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Good morning.

[Brad Hewitt, Analyst at Wolfe Research]

So the Q1 guidance midpoint looks to imply a slight uptick sequentially on the top line excluding the Q4 destock headwind. But then your full year guide seems to imply revenue remains relatively flat sequentially as we progress throughout the year. So just curious if you could talk about how you see underlying demand progressing through the year and do you see the potential for orders in the pipeline conversion rate to improve as we exit '24 and into 2025?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. Maybe I'll start with just kind of the framework for the guidance. So yeah, you're right. If you look at our Q1 guide down 17% to 20%. Sequentially that does improve from Q4. We are not assuming any additional distributor destocking. So that drives the vast majority of the sequential improvement again along with some uptick in demand that we saw particularly around year end spend. And then if you look at the full year guide of 1% at the midpoint, as you noted, if you look, we expect Q2 to look similar to Q1 with the modest sequential improvement as we move through the second half. And as we talked about in the prepared remarks, I think we're cautious given the lack of visibility and the commitment to the pipeline in the second half. So if you look kind of again at the balance of the year, as you noted, really the growth is entirely driven by the 2023 destocking with the market flat, maybe down a little bit in Q2, up a little bit in the second half and we think that's the appropriate given the visibility we have around the demand environment.

[Brad Hewitt, Analyst at Wolfe Research]

Okay. That's helpful. And then you've talked in the past about how you typically tend to gain share coming out of downturns. Could you talk about how you see the opportunity for share gains as we turn the page to 2024 and kind of where you see the lowest hanging fruit in terms of potential share gains going forward?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

I would say that overall talking to customers and spending a lot of time with our customers and partners through NRF that clearly our customers see that there's tremendous value in what we do for them each and every day to make their businesses more effective and more efficient and to literally run their businesses. So we see the opportunities across each one of our vertical markets as we see really retail likely returning first as we're continuing to work with them as they've been holding off and sweating assets within their environments and our engagements with NRF. Certainly, we've seen optimism by our retail customers in the second half year.

We marry our mobile devices there with our software solutions and what we talk about is really resonating with them around our modern store initiative. We see that in transportation logistics, our value proposition remains really to help our customers with things like labor constraints and additional supply chain visibility across their businesses. And we're excited about opportunities there within opportunities and technologies such as RFID as they look to get more to productivity across their businesses. We've got the Modex trade show coming up and Transportation and Logistics Expo coming up next month here and we'll showcase our solutions across transportation logistics.

We've talked about manufacturing as really being an opportunity for us is that we're less penetrated in that market and we've got new solutions around machine vision and robotic automation and our demand planning software offering inside manufacturing. So we see that as an opportunity for us. And then lastly, healthcare, as we continue to see ways to automate workflows and digitally connect assets and patients and staff within the healthcare environment, we see home health care and telehealth being an opportunity. So there's lots of opportunities across each one of the vertical markets. We'd probably say that retail is a place that we've seen some of the positive year end spending first. And then I think the other vertical markets will follow.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question today comes from Meta Marshall with Morgan Stanley. Please go ahead.

[Meta Marshall, Analyst at Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC]

Great. Thanks. Maybe first question, just you noted that the headwind from destocking was about the same in Q4 as in Q3. I think we had expected it to be slightly smaller understanding that's largely behind us. But just was that amount of destocking kind of greater than expected in Q4? And then maybe as a second question, obviously, the interest rate environment is maybe a little bit friendlier now. Your balance sheet -- your interest rate is relatively heavy on your interest expense. Just wondering if you've looked at any opportunities to refinance at more attractive rates. Thanks.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. Meta, so on the first question, you're right. So it was about $20 million, $25 million more of incremental destocking versus our original guide. And the balance of that was offset by higher demand to come in above our guidance midpoint for Q4. So I think we thought that is again a positive trend that again we would take a little bit more out of the channel to set us up here as we've moved into 2024. As it relates to interest rates, I think we feel good about actually our position. What you'll see in the cost of borrowing that includes all of our crediting and banking fees. But if you look at the overall cost of borrowing and where we trade at, I think we feel good about the position, but we're always looking at opportunities given the environment to whether it makes sense to refinance and take advantage of the market. So that's something we're actively looking at. But today we don't feel like we're at a disadvantage relative to the debt cost position.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question today comes from Joe Giordano with TD Cowen. Please go ahead.

[Joseph Giordano, Analyst at TD Cowen]

Hey, guys. Good morning.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Good morning, Joe.

[Joseph Giordano, Analyst at TD Cowen]

Hey. I just want know -- last year, when we initially started to see the real weakness and you guys had to adjust your guide, there was clearly like a change in methodology and it was very stripped down. It was kind of discounting things that weren't bird in hand kind of orders and a change in how you were building up from the salesforce commentary. So I'm just curious now as you look into '24 and you give that kind of qualitative guide, how would you compare your build up methodology to how you were a full year ago versus how you were like six months ago when it got much more conservative?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah, Joe, I'd say that probably if we look back to January, we literally have met with thousands of our customers and partners across our channel partner summits in Asia Pacific and in Europe and then North America, Latin America and then with the National Retail Federation show. And it's clear that our solutions are essential to what our customers are doing in their business every day. And they're grateful to have quite honestly Zebra as a strong partner along with them. And they're excited about the innovation that we're bringing to market and they're optimistic. So our partners and our customers are optimistic. They're happy to put 2023 behind them quite honestly. And there's optimism for 2024, especially in second half year.

However, I would say that from our perspective and it's prudent to remain cautious and that we haven't seen a broader recovery, we've really seen some kind of green shoots here in the year end of year end spending across retail, mostly in North America. And we'd like to see first some orders, projects, deployments really move forward before we get ahead of ourselves kind of for the full year. So I think optimism, happy to put '23 behind us. I think we feel good about modest increases through the year as demand progresses throughout the year. But we'd like to get a little more confidence by having more orders, more projects, more deployments across our end customers move forward. And we think it's prudent and reflecting our guide to be a bit conservative at the moment.

[Nathan Winters, Chief Financial Officer at Zebra Technologies]

And I think if you look back historically at this point in the year, we would have always assumed we'd have several of those large mega deployments in the second half, even though we may not have identified exactly which customer. But that was something we always had. And I think that's where we've pulled back on that assumption given the experience we've had over the last several quarters and the fact as Bill said, there's not a firm commitment. So until we start to see some of those firm commitments, we didn't think it was appropriate to lean in and just assume that some of those will start to come back in the second half.

[Joseph Giordano, Analyst at TD Cowen]

Okay. That's fair. And then if I look at the margin guidance for the year, the EBITDA at 19%, maybe I thought maybe a little higher at that level of revenue, particularly given an extra $20 million in cost. So can you just maybe talk through the gross margin if you're seeing any pressures anywhere? And then if you could just touch on the working capital this year, just the free cash flow, how normalized is that going to look exiting the year?

[Nathan Winters, Chief Financial Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. So again, if you look at our full year guide of 19% that does have us at 20% in the second half and as we head into 2025. So we thought that was important for us to work through as we went through the cost actions. And if you look sequentially, it's about year-on-year, I should say about 1 point higher than '23 really around gross margin due to favorable pricing, some lower premium supply chain costs and a bit of volume leverage. If you think about the restructuring benefits, it's about $60 million of benefit improvement from 2024, but that's offset by incentive compensation. So getting back to fully loaded on our incentive compensation plans for the year. So those two negate each other for the full year.

Again, if you look at our full year guide for free cash flow, one important milestone was getting back to positive free cash flow, which we did in the fourth quarter. Our guidance of at least $550 million has us above 100% free cash flow conversion excluding our final Honeywell payment here in the first quarter. And our expectation is for modest decreases in inventory and working capital throughout the year. And there could be some opportunity to exceed if we get back to our optimized inventory levels. But we did not include that in our guidance just given some of the uncertainty around demand and the mix of that demand.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question today comes from Damian Karas with UBS. Please go ahead.

[Damian Karas, Analyst at UBS Securities]

Hey, good morning, everyone. Thanks for all the color on kind of demand and what you guys are seeing on the project front. Maybe just a question on these long-term supply commitments that you've been renegotiating. Could you just maybe talk a little bit more about what's happening there? You highlighted one particular contract, a $10 million expense impacting gross margin. Could you just clarify, is that a one time hit or is that going to kind of be a headwind for the next three quarters, a little bit of a structural change in your cost structure?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

So just as it relates to -- that was a one time charge that's behind us in the fourth quarter. No change in our structural cost or that we'd anticipate having moving forward. And we feel like we're at this point substantially complete working with our suppliers around a lot of those longer term supply agreements, particularly the ones that we had to enter into in 2021 when we had kind of both a combination of peak demand as well as some of the extended lead times across the supply chain. And you'll actually see that if you look, we have almost a 75% decrease in some of our long-term purchase commitments that we have in our 10-K. So again, a lot of great progress by the team working through that throughout the year.

And our focus really here this year is around components that we still have at our Tier 1 manufacturers. So that's a lot around just demand timing, working through that as well as a lot of the great work by the team to redesign those components into existing or new products, as well as working with our manufacturing partners just around the safety stock that they hold. So I think we see a lot of progress there. And again, the charge we had in the fourth quarter was really associated with one supplier and one contract we signed back in 2021. And that was a combination of canceling as well as deferring some of the purchase commitments we had here in 2024 to mitigate some of the working capital pressure as well as give us a lot more flexibility around the mix of the components and again the timing of when we expect to receive those or accept those components on our balance sheet. So again, we thought it was the right thing to do to kind of get that passed us and move forward here as we move into '24.

[Damian Karas, Analyst at UBS Securities]

Got it. Thank you for clarifying. And could you just comment on any impacts you're seeing owing to some of the overseas shipping issues, like what's happening in the Red Sea and to what extent that might be factored into your guidance?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. Obviously, there's new concerns that we're monitoring with the risk of the escalating tensions in the Red Sea. So we're monitoring the situation, working with our partners. Today, we have mitigation plans again pending any further escalation of the situation. I think what's important for context is this really primarily impacts our printing business into EMEA. That's where we ship via ocean through the Red Sea and the Suez Canal. So again, the vast majority of our products are still air shipped or ocean shipped from Asia into the West Coast of the U.S. So we think as of today, it's a modest impact on extended lead times, which we've communicated to our partners, particularly in the EMEA region and a negligible impact expected on margin here in the first quarter.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question comes from Keith Housum with Northcoast Research. Please go ahead.

[Keith Housum, Analyst at Northcoast Research]

Good morning, guys. Bill and Nathan, is there any reason to believe there's a change to your long term guidance of annual growth rate of 5% to 7% over a cycle?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

No, Keith, I think that we would see that the current sales declines are due to a cyclical bottom really accentuated by the pandemic overall and that our long-term conviction and the strong business fundamentals really remain unchanged. And we think we're well positioned to continue to be the market leader and continue to take share as our markets recover overall. The secular trends really to digitize and automate environments within our customer operations really remain unchanged. They were intact before the pandemic and they remain intact today. And I think that our strong competitive position we have in the marketplace, especially in our core, the exciting opportunities we have in our adjacent and expansion areas. And quite honestly, we're excited about the future. So despite the near term headwinds, we don't see that changing. We see the 5% to 7% through cycle what we're committed to and remains intact.

[Keith Housum, Analyst at Northcoast Research]

Okay. Appreciate that. Just a quick follow up. In terms of the software and services, obviously, it's been really resilient for you guys. As you think about that growth or what it does for 2024, can you unpack, I guess, your expectations there as we separate that from the rest of the hardware business?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. I think that we'd say software and services clearly recurring revenue, right? You saw a similar comment we had on supplies, right, which we've talked about as being semi recurring, right? It's like a recurring business. So clearly, services and software outperformed our broader product portfolio overall. But I say that customers today continuing to strong attach rates on our mobile devices. Also we're seeing -- this is the negative side of some of the services growth is really people extending service contracts at higher prices, right, that ultimately we're working closely with them to get their refreshes done within their environment.

So that's a target for us starting in kind of second half of '23 and into '24 is really working closely with those customers that are looking to extend service agreements and sweat assets is to get them to move ahead with new technologies and new advantages of our hardware. But that's helping software a bit -- I'm sorry, services a bit. In the short term. From a software perspective, we're seeing really a compelling value proposition to our customers around what we're really brought together is our work cloud software, which is bringing the multiple organic and acquisition assets together to really address the needs that are retail associate. And we talk about that in this modern store framework as an engaged associate. So think of it as communication, collaboration, think of it as task management, workforce management, demand planning.

So marrying that all together into a single application or instance for our customers and be able to really enhance the productivity of the retail worker and that's resonating well with our customers. We had our trade show on our internal event with our user group of our software customers in the second half year and rolled out really what we're doing around work cloud and the future of that. And they're pretty excited about it. I don't know Nate do you want to add? I mean, the other thing we're focused on is really profitability around those areas and not growing top line, but also profitability in our software business as we bring those together.

[Nathan Winters, Chief Financial Officer at Zebra Technologies]

That's right. I think the bright spot on the service and software was the improved margin. So a lot of great work by the team, focus on the cost structure for both of those pieces of the business. So that was a nice improvement as we move to the second half and will be a tailwind as we move here into 2024 along with the expectation that those businesses will continue to grow.

[Operator]

Thank you and our next question comes from Brian Drab with William Blair. Please go ahead.

[Brian Drab, Analyst at William Blair & Company, L.L.C.]

Hi. Good morning. I just wanted to clarify first on the cost savings. Exactly what is the incremental benefit that we'll see in terms of cost savings, opex savings in '24 versus '23 now that we've got these incremental savings coming on mid year, I guess?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. So if you look at the expanded cost reduction plan at $120 million of net annualized savings, $20 million higher than our prior guide with the additional actions expected to be completed here by the middle part of the year. So we realized $50 million of savings in the second half of '23. So we're expecting $60 million of incremental benefit into '24 and then the balance as we head into 2025.

[Brian Drab, Analyst at William Blair & Company, L.L.C.]

Yeah, perfect. Okay.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Similar to what we had in the past, they're pretty broad based across functions. So I'd say as similar with the declines, the incremental amount was similar structure as we had with the first pass in terms of fairly broad based.

[Brian Drab, Analyst at William Blair & Company, L.L.C.]

Okay. Got it. And that's all in opex and won't affect gross margin, I guess. And my next question was just going to be on gross margin. I guess the best assumption here for gross margin as we track through the year would be modest increases in -- sequential increases in gross margin as we move through the quarters on leverage and anything that you would correct me on there or add to that?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. So one thing I'd say there is a small piece of that is in gross margin, but I'd say the vast majority is opex. So there's a piece in gross margin just based on some of the actions the supply chain team is taking within our cost structure. So a bit of that is in -- of $120 million is in gross margin, but I'd say for modeling purposes, I'd assume the vast majority is in opex. But you're absolutely right in terms of the sequential improvement in gross margin and our EBITDA rate throughout the year is primarily going to be driven by gross margin, both as some of the actions we've taken around pricing, the lower premium supply chain costs, which is I guess really here in the first quarter, but also a little bit of volume leverage, project timing as we move through the year. So yeah, that's what we'd expect through the year as a kind of modest improvement as we go through the year to get us to where we have as an exit point in the fourth quarter.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question comes from Rob Mason with Baird. Please go ahead.

[Robert Mason, Analyst at Robert W. Baird & Co. Incorporated]

Yes, thank you. I wanted to circle back, Bill, you mentioned several times customers willing to sweat their assets more right now, which again we've seen that in the past during these downturn periods. It sounds like you're trying to address that some with service strategies. I'm curious if you're testing any other strategies around trying to stimulate new product demand, whether customers might be more amenable to as service or subscription or say leasing type arrangements in this period of time. And then maybe relatedly, is there anything as you look into, say, the 2018, 2019 devices that were put into the installed base, anything on the horizon that would more catalyze their replacement, just where they can't be upgraded any further, anything of that nature?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. Rob, so a couple of things kind of weaved into that. I would say, first that our sales teams are working and our partners closely with those customers that we have identified that have the devices in use longer than normal and working closely with them to understand how we can convince them to move forward with upgrades and lots of different ways to go do that. But the driver really would be a couple of areas. One would be technology transition. So think 4G to 5G and wireless, think of faster Wi-Fi speeds, like Wi-Fi 6, OS upgrades. So as devices become older, then there's Android releases aren't available and then along with that we extend the security with that OS so long, but eventually the security patches aren't available. So from a security perspective that's a driver as well.

The other place is really around use case expansion, right? So that adding more functionality to the devices, things like authentication and facial recognition, think of Zebra Pay, integrated RFID on those devices, we're going to release here shortly. Over time, we'll be releasing -- we showed this at the National Retail Federation show generative AI, large language models on the actual devices and an assistant. So we want this to really be about productivity and wanting more features and functionality within their environment versus just around security, right? And we're seeing that.

I would say that in the area of leasing, what we're looking at is opportunities to marry our software with hardware. And we demonstrated some of this at the National Retail show as well is that think of a wearable device that has our task management software, communication collaboration on that wearable device in retail, which would be sold as a service kind of offering to our customers. So not quite a lease. In most cases, our customers say, hey, I'd rather spend the capital than lease, but in this case, it would be an opex recurring revenue stream around software and hardware combined together. So sales teams have a lot of different plays they're running to try to move those customers forward with upgrades.

[Robert Mason, Analyst at Robert W. Baird & Co. Incorporated]

That's helpful. Just as a follow up, could you just comment on what you're seeing in some of these underpenetrated markets where perhaps you do have more runway? And I'm thinking Japan and government specifically, just what the current tone of business is there?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah, Rob, I'd say that there are opportunities for us as we look around the globe and we have differing market shares. Those are two good examples of really significantly lower share than we have in other places. But as we look at each vertical market, as we look at each geography, we see places where we can continue to take share as a business. Japan is a great opportunity for us as we've talked about for a while second largest market in Asia. We won the largest postal carrier there. We've won the largest retailer. We now have the attention of some of the largest integrators, system integrators and cellular carriers in Japan to work in some new opportunities there beyond retail and postal.

So those have gotten us some more attention and we've changed our channel strategy there a bit to work with larger SIs. We've just hired a new sales leader. If we look at government in the U.S., a new sales leader there is to refocus on government and building our partner community and expanding our reach inside government opportunities that includes public safety. So we're excited about these markets because we have low share and we know there's opportunities for our portfolio within those underserved markets.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question today comes from Jim Ricchiuti with Needleman and Company. Please go ahead.

[Chris Grenga, Analyst at Needham & Company, LLC]

Hi. Good morning. This is Chris Grenga on for Jim, maybe just one from me. You had mentioned the trend of new automation use cases in RFID and machine vision. Could you talk about what you expect from these technologies in 2024 and what use cases are you having the most productive conversations with customers currently?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Chris, maybe start with RFID, we're continuing to see strong interest across many customers and verticals. We've seen the opportunity to expand beyond retail, apparel, really into track and trace and supply chains, parcel tracking, baggage tracking tools, work in progress in manufacturing, healthcare opportunities, all with RFID. Certainly, Walmart and what UPS is doing inside smart package, inside their environment has caused others to continue to look at the interest in RFID. The cost of tags coming down has created opportunity because today we have the broadest and deepest set of RFID solutions in the market and that includes fixed readers, handheld readers, industrial and mobile printers, software and the labels to go along with that.

So we've seen strong double-digit growth over the past few years in RFID, including in 2023. And we are excited about the opportunity across everything we do in RFID. I would say in machine vision really focused in two areas, manufacturing and transportation logistics. From a manufacturing perspective, automotive, food and beverage inside logistics, it's really about warehouse and distribution. We combined our organic investment really with a few acquisitions of Matrix and adaptive vision. That's really given us a broad differentiated offering across those markets and creates opportunities for us to win in what we see is a fragmented multibillion dollar market opportunity for us.

Our value proposition really is around marrying software and hardware together and giving a unified software platform to our customers and easy to set up, easy to upgrade really to drive simplicity, speed, efficiency within our customers' organizations and allow them to automate in an easier way and upgrade that automation from things like fixed industrial scanning to machine vision. So we're excited about both these opportunities. We are the leaders in RFID reading today. We're a challenger in the machine vision market, and we see both being a tremendous opportunity for Zebra.

[Operator]

Thank you. And our next question today comes from Ken Newman at KeyBanc Capital Markets. Please go ahead.

[Ken Newman, Analyst at KeyBanc Capital Markets]

Hey, good morning, guys. Thanks for squeezing me in.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Good morning.

[Ken Newman, Analyst at KeyBanc Capital Markets]

First question here, just looking at R&D expense, I know I saw that it took a sequential step down this quarter from 3Q. Just as I think about this first quarter guide in the full year, how should we think about the cadence of R&D dollars as we move through the year? And is there maybe more room to take out there as we progress after the first quarter?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. So I think a couple of things. Just some of the sequential decline from Q3 to Q4 was related to the cost actions that we took and just the timing of those rolling into the P&L, which is again what we had expected coming into the quarter. You'll see it increase a bit here as we go through '24 just as we reset comp plans and things like that around incentive compensation. And typically the first half is a little more front end loaded just with the timing of projects and deployments. And then Q4 is always a little light just with holidays and whatnot from a project execution. So I think I would think of a similar trajectory from a sequential perspective as we move through the year, but maybe a bit of an uptick just as we kind of again reset all of our comp plans and whatnot for the year.

[Ken Newman, Analyst at KeyBanc Capital Markets]

Got it. That's helpful. And then for my follow up, with free cash flow improving this year and you being at the top in a leverage target range, what does the midpoint of guide imply here for where you think net leverage ends up relative to debt pay down? And am I right in assuming that the priority for capital deployment will be towards the debt side or is there other portions or avenues that you see a better return for that capital?

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Yeah. So as you mentioned, we ended the quarter at 2.5 times debt leverage, which is at the high end of our target range. We are prioritizing debt pay down of our variable rate debt here in the short-term and we would expect the debt leverage to increase a bit here through the first and second quarter really just as we lap on the profitability side, not so much -- debt will come down, but the ratio will increase, but then will decline through the second half as we kind of lap Q3 and Q4's lower profitability. And so that is really the priority here. Starting out the year is debt pay down. But as always, we're going to reassess overall capital deployment and opportunities we have, whether that's share buyback or M&A as the year progresses.

[Operator]

Thank you. And ladies and gentlemen, this concludes our question and answer session. I'd like to turn the conference back over to Mr. Burns for any closing remarks.

[Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer at Zebra Technologies]

Thank you. As we look towards the long term, the opportunity for Zebra is bright. I'd just like to thank our customers, our partners and employees for their support. We look forward to returning to growth in 2024. Have a good day, everyone.

[Operator]

[Operator Closing Remarks]

Participants

Corporate Executives

• Michael Steele, Vice President, Investor Relations
• Bill Burns, Chief Executive Officer
• Nathan Winters, Chief Financial Officer

Analysts

• Tommy Moll, Stephens
• Brad Hewitt, Wolfe Research
• Meta Marshall, Morgan Stanley & Co. LLC
• Joseph Giordano, TD Cowen
• Damian Karas, UBS Securities
• Keith Housum, Northcoast Research
• Brian Drab, William Blair & Company, L.L.C.
• Robert Mason, Robert W. Baird & Co. Incorporated
• Chris Grenga, Needham & Company, LLC
• Ken Newman, KeyBanc Capital Markets