The Role of Price-to-Book Ratio in Fundamental Analysis

The Price-to-Book (P/B) Ratio is a financial ratio that compares a company’s Book Value to its current market value. The P/B ratio identifies the portion of a company that is held by its shareholders.

The formula for P/B ratio is:

Market Capitalization/Current Book Value of Equity

The company’s market capitalization is usually readily available. However, it can be calculated by multiplying the current stock price by the number of diluted shares outstanding. A company’s book value (tangible net asset value) is the company’s assets minus its total liabilities which may include intangible assets (e.g. patents, goodwill). This is gleaned from a company’s financial statements which most companies issue quarterly.

The P/B ratio (which is less commonly known as the price-equity ratio) is only one of many measures that value investors may use to make an investment decision. The specific purpose of the P/B ratio is to give a sense of the company’s valuation.

Even more specifically, the P/B ratio attempts to answer the question: “Am I paying too much for what would remain of this company if it went bankrupt?” If a company goes into bankruptcy it would have to liquidate all of its assets and pay off its debt. Whatever value is left over would be the company’s book value. In that context, the P/B ratio lets investors see if they are getting growth at a reasonable price.

Ad DTI

Let’s be blunt

Let me be blunt with you for just a second… You may think you know when and why stocks move, but you’re wrong… Most traders have no idea about the biggest secret Wall Street keeps — even though it’s hiding in plain sight. But once you’ve cracked this code… It could be the breakthrough you need to start targeting $100-$150 a day in the stock market (starting with just $1,000)!

Check out the $100 Challenge now

In general, a stock with a low P/B ratio (around 1) suggests the stock is undervalued. However, there are many other things to consider. For example, if a company is in an emerging sector, its price-to-book ratio will likely be much higher. And for low-growth companies, such as utilities, a P/B ratio that is too low could suggest the company has other financial problems.

The P/B ratio is just one data point for value investors to use. Frequently it is compared to a company’s return on equity (ROE), which is a reliable indicator of growth. Ideally, value investors are looking for these two numbers to show a decent correlation. That is, if a company’s return on equity is growing, its P/B ratio should be growing. When a company shows a low ROE and a high P/B ratio it is almost always a sign that a stock is overvalued.

As noted above, in general a “good” P/B ratio is considered to be anything under 1.0. That is universally seen as a sign that a stock is undervalued. Benjamin Graham who is considered to be the “father of value investing” believed that value investors should not invest in any stock with a P/B ratio above 1.5. It’s safe to say that the stock market of today is very different than the one that Graham knew. And today, many investors regard any number under 3.0 to be a good price-to-book ratio.

However, an important concept to remember about the Price-to-Book ratio is that proper analysis of what makes a good or bad P/B ratio can depend on the industry or sector. For example, let’s look at the P/B rations for two companies in the semiconductor sector:  Advanced Micro Devices (NASDAQ:AMD) and Intel (NASDAQ:INTC).

At the time of this writing, AMD checks in with a P/B ratio of 20.11. That’s much higher than the sector average of 3.58. INTC has a P/B ratio of just 1.95. While that is a bit higher than what some analysts would want, it’s far below the P/B ratio of a competitor in the sector. It’s also below the sector average.

At first glance that would make Intel the better option. And the reality is it will be a better option for value investors. Intel is a mature company that is reflected in the fact that it pays a dividend. However, growth investors are far more likely to choose AMD which is a company that is still in growth mode. With that in mind, growth investors are more likely to ignore the P/B ratio altogether.

Compared to other valuation metrics, the P/B ratio has several advantages. First, a company’s book value is generally positive even if the price-to-earnings (P/E) ratio is negative – meaning the company is not profitable. In cases like these, P/B ratio can be used as a proxy of sorts. Second, a company’s P/B ratio tends to be less volatile than P/E ratio.  

The P/B ratio has to be viewed in context. By itself a low P/B ratio does not mean a stock is undervalued. In fact, it can suggest that a company is having financial trouble. Conversely, a high P/B ratio does not necessarily mean a stock is a poor choice for value investors as it reflects a moment in time.

The P/B ratio only covers tangible assets. However, companies have intangible assets that should rightly be considered in assessing a company’s value. For example, companies such as Starbucks (NASDAQ:SBUX) and Amazon (NASDAQ:AMZN) have strong brand value that is not accounted for. Also, the P/B ratio cannot properly value the human capital that is found in many service companies.

At first glance, P/B ratio does not account for different production methods that may change the value of assets. Similarly, inflation and technology can have a significant effect on the book and market value of assets.  Also, investors have to know what accounting method is being used (GAAP, non-GAAP, IFRS) because that will cause asset values to be different.