Free Trial

Medicare Advantage Costs Surge: How These 2 Insurers Are Thriving

Photo of two hands cupping a red heart monitor line shaped like a heart

Key Points

  • Medicare Advantage and Medicaid managed care organizations (MCO) are experiencing rising medical benefits ratios (MBRs) due to growing utilization and medical costs.
  • Centene’s Q3 2024 revenue of $42.02 billion obliterated consensus analyst estimates by more than $4 billion.
  • Molina Healthcare's Q3 EPS rose 19% YoY to $6.01, and revenues surged 21% YoY to $10.34 billion, beating consensus estimates by over $420 million.
  • 5 stocks we like better than Centene.

Health insurers have been getting a lot of heat surrounding the rising costs of Medicare Advantage (MA) plans. Companies like CVS Health Co. NYSE: CVS have seen their medical benefits ratio (MBR) continue to rise, forecasting 90.8%, driven by the rising costs to provide MA plans to seniors. The MBR, also referred to as the health benefits ratio (HBR) and medical costs ratio (MCR), is the percentage of insurance premium payments that are paid out to providers and facilities for medical services. Higher MBR/HCRs mean smaller profits and compressed margins for the insurers.

In light of regulators cracking down and providers' reluctance to accept MA plans, there are still health insurers in the medical sector that are thriving (for now). Here are two health insurers that are still profiting in this uncertain healthcare landscape.

Centene: Managed Care Magic or Mischief?  

Centene Today

Centene Co. stock logo
CNCCNC 90-day performance
Centene
$59.67 +0.09 (+0.15%)
(As of 11:10 AM ET)
52-Week Range
$55.03
$81.42
P/E Ratio
10.36
Price Target
$80.92

Medicaid is a joint federal and state health insurance program for low-income people. Individual states administer the program and establish eligibility requirements, payment rates and covered services. The federal government funds half of the costs of the program. Medicaid is arguably the stingiest payer of all insurance plans, as many providers opt not to take Medicaid patients due to the low reimbursements and hassle involved in getting paid. Centene Co. NYSE: CNC has swooped in, applying "managed care" tactics for Medicaid, locking in lucrative state contracts to offer Medicaid plans, becoming the nation's largest Medicaid managed care organization (MCO).

Centene is a massive company with numerous subsidiaries that offer its Medicaid and MA plans through different states. Credit has to be given to Centene for taking the most difficult segment of the medical patient population with the lowest reimbursement rates and turning a massive profit. The company has settled previous claims for overcharging states for pharmacy services.

Centene Stock Forecast Today

12-Month Stock Price Forecast:
$80.92
35.82% Upside
Moderate Buy
Based on 14 Analyst Ratings
High Forecast$93.00
Average Forecast$80.92
Low Forecast$52.00
Centene Stock Forecast Details

The company reported a third quarter of 2024 EPS of $1.62, beating consensus estimates by 26 cents. Revenues rose 10.5% YoY to $42.02 billion, absolutely obliterating consensus estimates of $37.91 billion. Premium and service revenue rose 6% YoY to $36.9 billion, driven by Medicaid rate increases and Marketplace membership growth. However, its MBR has been up-ticking, reporting 89.2% in the quarter, up from 87% last year. This impacted its adjusted EPS, which actually dropped 19% YoY to $1.62.

Centene issued upside guidance for full-year 2024 EPS consensus estimates of $6.80 versus $6.72. The company expects revenues of $159 billion to $161 billion versus $1.56.58 billion.

Centene stock is trading down 14.4% year-to-date (YTD), with a 32% upside to the consensus analyst price target of $84.00.

Molina Health: A Top 5 Medicaid MCO    

Molina Healthcare Today

Molina Healthcare, Inc. stock logo
MOHMOH 90-day performance
Molina Healthcare
$292.17 -2.56 (-0.87%)
(As of 11:08 AM ET)
52-Week Range
$272.69
$423.92
P/E Ratio
14.84
Price Target
$361.91

While Centene is the largest Medicaid MCO, Molina Healthcare NYSE: MOH is one of the top five providers of Medicaid and MA in the United States. The company saw its consolidated Medicaid and MA MBR at 89.2% in its third quarter of 2024. However, its Medicaid MBR rose to 90.5%. Molina mentions that 50 basis points was from a retroactive premium rate reduction back to the start of 2024, and 20 basis points was attributed to new Medicaid "store" plans. Backing out the adjustments and new stores, its Medicaid MBR was 89.8%, which was still higher than 89.2% for Centene. Medicare MBR was 89.6%, reflecting higher-than-expected utilization, which is a common theme among MA insurers.

For its Q3, Molina reported EPS of $6.01, beating consensus estimates by 7 cents. Revenues surged 21% YoY to $10.34 billion, beating $9.92 billion consensus estimates. Its premium revenue rose 18% YoY to $9.7 billion, driven by new contract wins and acquisitions offset by Medicaid redeterminations. Adjusted net income took the opposite trajectory from Centene's 19% decline, with a 19% YoY rise for Molina to $6.01.

Molina Healthcare Today

Molina Healthcare, Inc. stock logo
MOHMOH 90-day performance
Molina Healthcare
$292.17 -2.56 (-0.87%)
(As of 11:08 AM ET)
52-Week Range
$272.69
$423.92
P/E Ratio
14.84
Price Target
$361.91

The company closed the quarter with $195 million in cash and investments, down from $742 million due to the buyback of 1.5 million shares for $500 million in Q3.

Molina reaffirmed full-year 2024 EPS guidance of $23.50 versus $23.51 consensus estimates. Premium revenue is expected to grow 17% YoY to $38 billion. Molina shares are trading down 9.5% YTD with a 12% upside to its consensus analyst price target of $367.00.

Should you invest $1,000 in Centene right now?

Before you consider Centene, you'll want to hear this.

MarketBeat keeps track of Wall Street's top-rated and best performing research analysts and the stocks they recommend to their clients on a daily basis. MarketBeat has identified the five stocks that top analysts are quietly whispering to their clients to buy now before the broader market catches on... and Centene wasn't on the list.

While Centene currently has a "Moderate Buy" rating among analysts, top-rated analysts believe these five stocks are better buys.

View The Five Stocks Here

Beginners Guide To Retirement Stocks Cover

Click the link below and we'll send you MarketBeat's list of seven best retirement stocks and why they should be in your portfolio.

Get This Free Report
Jea Yu
About The Author

Jea Yu

Contributing Author

Trading Strategies

Like this article? Share it with a colleague.

Companies Mentioned in This Article

CompanyMarketRank™Current PricePrice ChangeDividend YieldP/E RatioConsensus RatingConsensus Price Target
Centene (CNC)
4.9666 of 5 stars
$59.67+0.2%N/A10.36Moderate Buy$80.92
CVS Health (CVS)
5 of 5 stars
$43.71-1.5%6.09%11.09Moderate Buy$69.12
Molina Healthcare (MOH)
4.8197 of 5 stars
$292.17-0.9%N/A14.84Hold$361.91
Compare These Stocks  Add These Stocks to My Watchlist 


Featured Articles and Offers

Recent Videos

From Landfills to Profits: Opal Fuels CEO Shares How the Company Turns Trash into Cash
The Real Reason Tesla Stock Is Soaring – and Why Tech Expert Says It Won’t Stop
Best ETFs for 2025: Growth, Stability, and AI-Driven Investing

Stock Lists

All Stock Lists

Investing Tools

Calendars and Tools

Search Headlines